• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Fall of Gondolin: Out!

You expect me to remember a typo I noticed almost two years ago?! :oops:

I'm no Francis Bacon, you know -- by this point, my brain is toast!
 
Bacon 'n' eggs on toast - my favorite breakfast on our vacations. 😋
 
Bacon 'n' eggs on toast - my favorite breakfast on our vacations. 😋
No more bacons for you due to your age XDD. Hello, “Hello. I am Baymax, your personal healthcare companion.

1596787105558.png
 
The Fall of Gondolin: In my interpretations of the works of JRR Tolkien, it goes farther back in years and isn't even remotely close to sudden.

I would say it all starts with Eol The Dark. From him and his smithy (probably the greatest smith of the Sindar elves) he fashioned 2 great longswords. I would also say I do not think he was evil in his heart to begin with, but more a sundered elf alone and powerful. In pure speculation I would imagine he was bitter, or jaded towards the Kings of The Noldor elves. I guess I would too if stronger elves invaded my homelands as a Laiquendi or Moriquendi, right?

So... I could be wrong... but I'm pretty sure I remember Eol The Dark crafting black armor of might, which he would wear abroad. And most notably, the 2 Longswords of Anguirel and Anglachel that played Ancient Artifact level of power in the Tolkien world. These 2 swords pretty much sealed the fate of any and all who wield them for even a short time. (Which we see in Beleg Strongbow). Gifted and cursed swords both.

(As a side note;... Imagine one elf wielding both swords of Eol in combat. Too cool.)

In reality, those 2 swords were separated far from one another. Again, back to Eol The Dark. Then his son Maeglin stole his father's sword and departed from Nan Elmoth with his mother Aredhel back to Gondolin. Eol was slain along with his wife, and so was fostered Maeglin; Son of Eol and Aredhel, a mighty Prince of the Noldor and Sindar in Gondolin. In my personal opinion and knowledge, I'd say that Maeglin bringing that Black Sword Anguirel to Gondolin was its downfall. The books say Gondolin fell to Maeglin Son of Eol, but I say it fell to Anguirel. The first and mightiest black sword of Eol.

That being said.... lmao.... The second Black Sword.

Anglachel/ Gurthang:
Anglachel was one of two swords Eöl forged from a meteorite. The other, Anguirel, he kept for himself. Eöl gave this sword to Thingol as payment for staying in his forest, Nan Elmoth, though he did not relish giving it away. Thingol gave the sword in keeping to his subject Beleg Cúthalion, when Beleg left to seek down Turin. Whenever Beleg took the sword out of its sheath, the sword is said to have sung with gladness.

At one time, Beleg was unbinding the unconscious Túrin, who had been held captive and tormented by Orcs. However, whilst undoing his bonds, the sword slipped and cut Túrin's foot. Túrin woke, thinking Orcs again upon him, and in the dark slew Beleg with Anglachel before realizing who it was. This mistake he rued bitterly.

Túrin was then given the sword by Gwindor, and Túrin travelled to Nargothrond, Gwindor's place of birth, where the sword was reforged and renamed Gurthang, "Iron of Death."

Hope that helps!!
Interesting perspective, but I don't think the narratives support it? It was not Anglachel that wrought Turin's doom but the curse of Morgoth, and after Maeglin stole Anguirel it doesn't figure in the story in any way that I can recall. They are dark swords imbued with the malice of their creator, and I think that's all. Anglachel helped along in the operation of Morgoth's Curse, but we'll never know if Tolkien would have developed Anguirel's role in the fall of Gondolin. Though I can imagine it being wielded in Maeglin's final battle against Tuor, it is clear that Tuor and Dramborleg prevailed.
 
No my friend, both swords held the doom of any who would use them. You are correct in your published truth, but if anyone filled in the gaps it would look like this scenario most likely.

If Turin never wielded Gurthang, then all that misery that came with it would have never happened. Only great people make tragic things happen. If those 2 swords never existed, then the story of Eol would have been different, and so the story of his son Maeglin.

I imagine that Anguirel is lost at the bottom of the depths of the Belegear Sea, somewhere near the ruins of Gondolin beneath the ocean, west of Tol Himling, which used to be the March of Maedhros..
Gap-filling is only compelling when supported by evidence from canon. So unless you have some quotes from the texts to back this up, speaking with conviction isn't going to get you far.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top