Yes! Great opening. When do you start? (Peter who?)aragil said:Eledhwen- glad to see you're here, as I remember you posting some rather enticing sequences from the Hobbit. Those were of course more in-line with the tone of the Lord of the Rings than with TH, but that is fine by me. Personally, I'd think the Gandalf/Dol Guldur stuff would work well enough in flashback. That would allow for an ultimate James Bond-style opening: Smaug attacking the Mountain. What fun to go through a transition from Smaug smoking out the Dwarves to Bilbo smoking quietly in the Shire.
Greenwood said:Lotho,
Your idea of using the material from Unfinished Tales as an intro to The Hobbit is a good one, but will never happen during Christopher Tolkien's lifetime. Even if New Line and MGM come to an accommodation, that is only the rights to The Hobbit; Unfinished Tales is a whole other question. I don't think Christopher Tolkien has sold the film rights of any of his father's posthumously published works to anyone. Given Christopher Tolkien's behavior in cutting off his own son for having anything to do with the current films, I can't see him letting Jackson (or probably anyone else) use anything from Unifinished Tales.
Greenwood said:I saw Christopher's son being interviewed on CNN News a few weeks ago. They did not go into the specifics of Christopher's refusal to have any involvement with the films but it dated to before they were made. Christopher's son thought that the family should have been involved in the films (once again there were no specifics that I remember about what sort of involvement that meant). As I remember, CT's son (I keep referring to him that way because I don't remember his name -- sorry) looks at the films as a way of introducing more people to his grandfather's writings. Anyway CT, ao disapproved of his son expressing support for the films that he has not spoken to him since before the films came out. (I have the impression that CT cut his son out of the family estate over this, but I will not swear to that -- I saw the story a few weeks ago and didn't take notes. One of JRRT's other grandchildren -- not a child of CT -- flew to New Zealand and was actually an extra on one of the films. I can only assume CT is not talking to him either.) And people thought the disagreements on TTF got nasty!
Lotho_Pimple said:I'm sure it would have been calamitously grievous for poor JRR, had he been alive to know of it.
"Roid" has a certain connotation where I come from...Eledhwen said:You have a problem with 'Royd', Parrot? It's no stranger than 'Reuel' to me.
I know you have hemor"rhoid"s in England, I have had words with a few of them on this forum.Eledhwen said:Are you American? Who was it that said we are two nations divided by a common language? I ask again if anyone knows of an American equivalent to www.effingpot.com, so I can understand Parrot's posts.
I think Peter Jackson will make The Hobbit, because he has the location on his doorstep. Whether we will recognise the end product is another story. I think he'll have to change the Trolls, if he wants over-eights to watch it. Tolkien would have, if he had known what was to follow.
Oh, I get it! (eventuallyParrot said:I know you have hemor"rhoid"s in England, I have had words with a few of them on this forum.
Eledhwen said:...I'm sure the film will be made. They already have a Misty Mountains location, Rivendell, and the petrified trolls (if they haven't been disassembled) which will save them couple of hundred quid. I expect someone at Weta is already working on the dragon, in the hope of getting the contract.
I really agree with you on that point, but if PJ does make a movie, it can't get any worse than the cartoon version of The Hobbit... That was just bad...duilwen said:oh dear. as much as i'd like to see this story adapted, by far simpler than the lord of the rings
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?