• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Hobbit as movie?

Lotho,

Your idea of using the material from Unfinished Tales as an intro to The Hobbit is a good one, but will never happen during Christopher Tolkien's lifetime. Even if New Line and MGM come to an accommodation, that is only the rights to The Hobbit; Unfinished Tales is a whole other question. I don't think Christopher Tolkien has sold the film rights of any of his father's posthumously published works to anyone. Given Christopher Tolkien's behavior in cutting off his own son for having anything to do with the current films, I can't see him letting Jackson (or probably anyone else) use anything from Unifinished Tales.
 
I just hope they can reach an agreement I mean it would bring in another boatload of cash. Well they have plenty of time snice Jackson is off making King Kong. It should be a great film if it ever happens I think it will happen but I dont expect it to come out anytime soon.
 
aragil said:
Eledhwen- glad to see you're here, as I remember you posting some rather enticing sequences from the Hobbit. Those were of course more in-line with the tone of the Lord of the Rings than with TH, but that is fine by me. Personally, I'd think the Gandalf/Dol Guldur stuff would work well enough in flashback. That would allow for an ultimate James Bond-style opening: Smaug attacking the Mountain. What fun to go through a transition from Smaug smoking out the Dwarves to Bilbo smoking quietly in the Shire.
Yes! Great opening. When do you start? (Peter who?)


Greenwood, where did you get the information that CT cut his son off for having truck with the films?
 
Greenwood said:
Lotho,

Your idea of using the material from Unfinished Tales as an intro to The Hobbit is a good one, but will never happen during Christopher Tolkien's lifetime. Even if New Line and MGM come to an accommodation, that is only the rights to The Hobbit; Unfinished Tales is a whole other question. I don't think Christopher Tolkien has sold the film rights of any of his father's posthumously published works to anyone. Given Christopher Tolkien's behavior in cutting off his own son for having anything to do with the current films, I can't see him letting Jackson (or probably anyone else) use anything from Unifinished Tales.

I'd like to know more about CT's actions with his son. That's a pity. But there are reasons:

In reading from Tolkien's letters (and I don't feel like running to the book to quote chapter and verse right now), what I discovered was, that Christopher was the child that Tolkien considered to be most like himself in temperament and values. He said as much to Christopher in some of the letters, and went further: he said that when he was writing LOTR, he was actually writing it with Christopher in mind! Would it please Christopher, would Christopher approve of this or that passage, and so forth. He let his son in on all his secrets during the whole writing process.

So you can imagine that Christopher is exceptionally protective — some would say overprotective — of his father's works. We may not agree with what he has done with his father's output, but at least we can understand it. It is as if his father made him the sole curator, a duty which CT has made his life's mission.

Lotho
 
I saw Christopher's son being interviewed on CNN News a few weeks ago. They did not go into the specifics of Christopher's refusal to have any involvement with the films but it dated to before they were made. Christopher's son thought that the family should have been involved in the films (once again there were no specifics that I remember about what sort of involvement that meant). As I remember, CT's son (I keep referring to him that way because I don't remember his name -- sorry) looks at the films as a way of introducing more people to his grandfather's writings. Anyway CT, so disapproved of his son expressing support for the films that he has not spoken to him since before the films came out. (I have the impression that CT cut his son out of the family estate over this, but I will not swear to that -- I saw the story a few weeks ago and didn't take notes. One of JRRT's other grandchildren -- not a child of CT -- flew to New Zealand and was actually an extra on one of the films. I can only assume CT is not talking to him either.) And people thought the disagreements on TTF got nasty! :eek:
 
Last edited:
Greenwood said:
I saw Christopher's son being interviewed on CNN News a few weeks ago. They did not go into the specifics of Christopher's refusal to have any involvement with the films but it dated to before they were made. Christopher's son thought that the family should have been involved in the films (once again there were no specifics that I remember about what sort of involvement that meant). As I remember, CT's son (I keep referring to him that way because I don't remember his name -- sorry) looks at the films as a way of introducing more people to his grandfather's writings. Anyway CT, ao disapproved of his son expressing support for the films that he has not spoken to him since before the films came out. (I have the impression that CT cut his son out of the family estate over this, but I will not swear to that -- I saw the story a few weeks ago and didn't take notes. One of JRRT's other grandchildren -- not a child of CT -- flew to New Zealand and was actually an extra on one of the films. I can only assume CT is not talking to him either.) And people thought the disagreements on TTF got nasty! :eek:

Well that is indeed a very sad thing. None of it is worth the estrangement of one's own child! I'm sure it would have been calamitously grievous for poor JRR, had he been alive to know of it.

The other child you speak of is Royd Tolkien, Tolkien's great-grandson, who had a walk-on in ROTK (see http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainment/film/3324387.stm)?

Lotho
 
Lotho_Pimple said:
I'm sure it would have been calamitously grievous for poor JRR, had he been alive to know of it.

I completely agree.

And while I greatly appreciate CT's work in publishing The Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales and the HoME series, I think CT should consider the likelihood that his father would never have approved of much of that material being published when he decides to cut himself off from his own son.
 
CT's son is named Simon. A bit more on the issue can be found here

Eledhwen- personally, I liked all of your ideas for adapting the Hobbit to a more 'adult' tone, I just thought the dragon intro would be quite good. Of course, I don't think I have anything near the talent (or willpower) to pull off any screenwriting. However, whoever makes it (and I hope PJ does, just for consistency in storytelling) I will definitely see it!
 
You have a problem with 'Royd', Parrot? It's no stranger than 'Reuel' to me.

I think there is little doubt that there is now a market for Tolkien's work being adapted for film; and New Line have first refusal on The Hobbit (unless the option has expired since I heard). Eventually, I expect to see the Great Stories of the Silmarillion on screen, especially now they've discovered New Zealand (or was that Captain Cook?). I note that filming starts there this summer on The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe.
 
Eledhwen said:
You have a problem with 'Royd', Parrot? It's no stranger than 'Reuel' to me.
"Roid" has a certain connotation where I come from...
 
Are you American? Who was it that said we are two nations divided by a common language? I ask again if anyone knows of an American equivalent to www.effingpot.com, so I can understand Parrot's posts.

I think Peter Jackson will make The Hobbit, because he has the location on his doorstep. Whether we will recognise the end product is another story. I think he'll have to change the Trolls, if he wants over-eights to watch it. Tolkien would have, if he had known what was to follow.
 
Eledhwen said:
Are you American? Who was it that said we are two nations divided by a common language? I ask again if anyone knows of an American equivalent to www.effingpot.com, so I can understand Parrot's posts.

I think Peter Jackson will make The Hobbit, because he has the location on his doorstep. Whether we will recognise the end product is another story. I think he'll have to change the Trolls, if he wants over-eights to watch it. Tolkien would have, if he had known what was to follow.
I know you have hemor"rhoid"s in England, I have had words with a few of them on this forum. :)
 
Parrot said:
I know you have hemor"rhoid"s in England, I have had words with a few of them on this forum. :)
Oh, I get it! (eventually :rolleyes: ) We spell it differently in England (keeping the haem=blood on all such words), but that wouldn't affect the other end (if you'll pardon my slightly unintentional pun). The colloquial word for haemorrhoids here is 'piles', and Piles Tolkien doesn't have much of a ring to it.

So, not only have we gone off subject here, but via Tolkien's descendant, we have descended to discussing embarassing bowel conditions. At last read, I don't actually remember any such reference in The Hobbit, and I'm sure I would have heard if Peter Jackson was a sufferer. Old wives tales tell us that sitting on a cold step could bring the condition on, and PJ does always wear shorts.

I'm sure the film will be made. They already have a Misty Mountains location, Rivendell, and the petrified trolls (if they haven't been disassembled) which will save them couple of hundred quid. I expect someone at Weta is already working on the dragon, in the hope of getting the contract.
 
Eledhwen said:
...I'm sure the film will be made. They already have a Misty Mountains location, Rivendell, and the petrified trolls (if they haven't been disassembled) which will save them couple of hundred quid. I expect someone at Weta is already working on the dragon, in the hope of getting the contract.

Wahoo! Where did you get that info, I wanna go check it out!

Lotho
 
Jan said:
My first thought is that he would have to make some "adjustment" to the Elves. They seemed very different in the Hobbit and LOTR.

i was thinking that too. the elves in "the hobbit" seem more like dreams than actual beings.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top