I have just seen RotK this afternoon. I feel really satisfied with it, it is a grand ending to the story, as it completes all of the loose ends left over from the previous movies. Some people had predicted that this movie would fall apart because of the plot deviations in the earlier films, but far from it – now that I have the chance to look back on the entire project I feel even more at ease and impressed with it than before.
As a film, this one is stunning. PJ has managed to put
Middle Earth on the screen in front of us, with the geography, the
peoples, the
monsters, the
cities and
fortresses. It is a visual feast that I can watch over and over again.
Minas Tirith is beautiful, I hope they did not really have to destroy the miniature during the battle!
Minas Morgul is a totally dreadful place, it gave me the creeps all over.
Mordor is all I could hope for, the eruption of Mount Doom is incredible. I know that the movie has to be more than the visuals (and it is), but I think a lot of people take already too much of what we see here for granted. Maybe it is that I grew up with the Bakshi effort, but I am really very impressed with the looks of the film.
The characters were developed much as I had anticipated. I have always said that PJ simply uses the oldest trick in the book of theatre: dramatising his characters. I think this is justifiable because even with three long films the viewers do not have the same time and opportunity to get to know the characters as readers of the
books. To help us understand them he paints them with bolder strokes.
Frodo and
Sam’s characters have reached a great depth, I am perhaps one of the few that have no problem at all with Frodo sending Sam away. It fitted quite naturally in the way the film portrays the interaction between them and
Gollum, and the very strong power
the Ring has over him. The way they reconcile, even with the tension when Sam has to hand the Ring back, is far more emotional just because of what happened before.
Merry and
Pippin have matured exactly as I thought they would, and the transition from playful and innocent
hobbits to wise and hardened warriors is quite convincing.
Aragorn is truly King at the end, his taking the paths of the Dead, his later decision to ride to the
Black Gate and his behaviour there show that he has finally grown into his destiny.
Gandalf is no longer just
the wise councellor but becomes very commanding and takes personal charge of the defense of Minas Tirith. I’m fine with
Denethor, his madness is more important than his high lineage and potentially deep insights, and his madness came out very well in the movie.
Faramir is now also complete as a character and I have no more problems with the way he is depicted in the film – already the TTT EE did much to fill out the gaps left in the TE.
The actions are stunning. Stunning! The shot of the hundreds of riders leaving Edoras was only the first of a series of truly amazing big action, big drama scenes. The lighting of the
beacons – a cinematic high point! The charge of the
Rohirrim sent chills down my spine, I pressed myself hard in my seat at the moment of impact with the
Orc army. The siege engines, Grond, the
Mumakil,
the Trolls pushing the siege
towers, Wow! The
Nazgul steeds flying over the battlefield, grabbing soldiers and
horses and dropping them from great height, you have to see it to believe it. I actually quite like Denethor running in flames over the wall and jumping down, another example where PJ changes a more static scene for a more dynamic, cinematically effective way of telling the story.
Emotionally, the Frodo and Sam thread is of course the most intense. I had to sniff a bit after the destruction of the Ring when they sat on the rock surrounded by the lava and spoke about the End of All Things. Of course the scene at the Crack of Doom itself is extremely powerful cinema. Just the lighting on Frodo’s face as he stands on the edge, deciding what to do, is worth a Special Effects Oscar alone.
The multiple endings are so many essential conclusions to the multitude of character arcs and plot strands. I am sure that the EE will add a few more with Faramir and
Eowyn, and perhaps the wedding of Aragorn and
Arwen. The return to
the shire (with a cameo of my good old
alter ego, if I may be excused
) does show the feeling of estrangedness that the hobbits have after their monumental experiences in a subtle but effective way with a scene in the Green
Dragon.
The Grey Havens scene is of course very emotional, but I did my best not to sniff any more because I had already drawn too much attention from a couple of teenage kids sitting next to me!
The ending is simply perfect.
Looking back on all the three films as one long movie, all I can say now is that PJ has done a fan-tas-tic job. Not just for the
Tolkien lovers, but most certainly for the millions of non-readers out there. With the project completed, his changes from the book already fade into the background and become mostly inconsequential for me, and do indeed on the whole improve the story as a movie. In my opinion, of course, your mileage may vary.
Go to see it again after Christmas. Yippee!
Odo