• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145


This was my first post in here and now I will elaborate on my feeling of this film.

Clears throat

I left this film with a mixture of happiness (80%) and disappointment (20%). Rather than state what I did like, I'll state what disappointed me since I had less of that.

It did seem rushed to me in some places.

The disappointments that stick out the most to me (in my memory) are:

The Dead Army Fighting
They show up and you really don't see them kick any ass, just kinda float around a few orcs and then they are asking to be released. I'd have liked to have seen more of them.

Gandalf vs. Lord of the Nagul (I don't like the name Witch King)
I really wanted to see this. It is what I am looking forward to the most in the EE. I believe it will be there because the Lord of the Nazgul said he would take care of Gandalf, (not in those words) and also it shows him landing in front of Gandlaf while he is on Shadowfax in the preview of ROTK in the special features disc of TTT. Plus there is a picture which is on the official movie website showing it http://www.lordoftherings.net/index_downloads.html

Eyown Vs. Lord of the Nazgul
I just would have liked there to have been a little more of a struggle. The Nazgul King went down pretty fast, it sure didn't make him seem very powerful.

Frodo and Sam's journey after Shelob
This would probably be what seem the most rushed to me. When Sam is going to Cirith Ungol: Right before he walks in a fight starts, cut to Sam walking in, next cut he is walking through it and everyone is dead or gone except for the few guards on the stairs. That went way to fast IMO. Pretty much everything until they are actually in Mount Doom seemed too fast paced to me.

No Lieutenant of Sauron at the Black Gate
This is the another scene I was really looking forward to. I really hope it is in the EE, but I have my doubts.

And lastly

Gollum's Death
Although I am pleased with the scene as a whole, I would have liked Gollum to realize at least half way down that " Oh crap, I'm about to die" and start freaking out. Rather than be in blissful ignorance all the way. I just would have liked to see him fear for his fate. Does that make me sick?

But even with those few things, I still really liked the film and love the trilogy as a whole. I will be seeing it again this weekend and probably a ton more times.
 
hehe no that doesn't make you sick. After the movie I thought back on that scene and wished Gollum had shown intense pain at both the realization that he would not have the ring, and the feel of the lava burning him.

Maybe I am sick too
 
When did he defy gravity? Not going up the oliphaunts legs...

I was thinking that too, but 'upon further review' (2nd viewing), I believe Legolas was using the arrows sticking to the side of the Oliphant's legs to climb. At least, I want to believe that.


Frodo teling Sam to go home. I defy anyone to explain it away. Frodo trusting Gollum over Sam? Never, never, never

Not that I liked it, but here goes......

The power of the Ring distorting Frodo's perception coupled with Gollum's deception.


BTW, I agree the Gandalf returned from the dead should have been named not 'The White' but 'Gandalf The Stupid'.

Some of the stuff he was saying & doing was absurd......

"Sauron will suspect a trap." on marching to the Black Gate.

Riding out to meet the Nazgul with Pippin on Shadowfax.



"I've sent Frodo to his death." - Well, DUH!
 
I just got back from a midnight showing and have the RotK soundtrack on (love the soundtrack). Ooh yeah, what a movie! I had this silly grin on my face through at least the entire last half of the movie, and I was shaking my head, I couldn't believe it was so good and I was finally seeing it. I think PJ should get the Director's Oscar for cramming so much into RotK and still making it work, still having it flow well and keeping me emotionally involved. I did feel like he needed more than the 3 hours and 20 minutes to film the whole book, but what are ya gonna do. So, I have no quibbles about his adaptation of the book, though a few things were Hollywood-ized. I also think the film would've worked just fine if we'd gotten to see Gandalf, Saruman, Grima and all at Isengard, though it would've made it even longer.

Parts I really liked:
--The view from above as Gandalf and Pippin arrive at Minas Tirith on Shadowfax, galloping up the different levels 'till they reach the top.
--Pippin lighting the beacon, and the other beacons being lit.
--Elrond presenting Anduril to Aragorn.
--Paths of the Dead and Aragorn saying to the King of the Dead, "What say you?!" Very cool visually, too!
--The Stairs of Cirith Ungol were steeper and more treacherous than I imagined them--made me more nervous.
--Shelob--very scary, and very valiant of Sam to battle her.
--That was sad when Faramir was before Denethor and Denethor told him to get back out there and retake Osgiliath.
--Gandalf rallying the troops inside Minas Tirith.
--Eowyn and Merry versus the Lord of the Nazgul!
--Frodo, Sam and Gollum at the Crack of Doom--they finally got there!
--Aragorn, then the others, charge the enemy at the Black Gate.
--Seeing the lava cascade down Mount Doom around Frodo and Sam, then the Eagles come!
--The "wrap-up." Some critics said PJ didn't know when to end the film, but it had to be shown; Frodo waking up and being joined by the Fellowship was very touching.
--The hobbits got to see the shire again, and so did we!

Part I wanted to see or hear about but didn't:
--Aragorn looking into the palantir (not just when he grabbed it from Pippin) to let Sauron know Isildur's heir was alive and was challenging him, and Sauron's concern over that, though how would PJ have conveyed that--show the giant fiery eyeball quivering in fear? Speaking of which, the eye of Sauron's "lighthouse effect" took a little getting used to, but then I accepted it; it works for me as a way to convey its probing nature--again, how else could that have been filmed?

Part that had me scratching my head a bit:
--It seemed a little too easy for Sam to get up to the Tower of Cirith Ungol. Should've been more guards and orcs creepin' about, watchin' the place.

Excellent cinematography--great coloring, nice darkness and dark blues near Minas Morgul and through the Stairs of Cirith Ungol. Great rhythmic editing too. And Howard Shore's gotta win the Oscar and Grammy for the RotK soundtrack!

This movie, like the book, impressed on me how it takes all the characters pulling their weight, doing the tasks that were appointed to them, to achieve victory for all. Yet of all the characters, the hobbits impressed me the most. Pippin and Merry showed their warrior sides; I think Billy Boyd should be nominated for a Best Supporting Actor Oscar for his range of emotion and overall portrayal; Samwise was truly the brave and steady soul he is; and Frodo carried on, struggling under the weight of the Ring.

I might like RotK better than the other two--I'll have to see it a few more times--but I truly feel even the films are hard to separate because it's one big story. But if pressed to do so, I'd say I give both RotK and FotR 5 out of 5 stars and TTT 4-and-a-half.
 

Yes, that's what I said. You don't think they'd actually have someone climb vertically up an oliphaunt without anything to hold onto... It was perfectly prefaced by the scene with the oliphaunt collapsing, showing its legs riddled with ranged weaponry.
 
WELL DONE PARTS:

I have to say, PJ did some things well. Eowyn's dispatching the Witch King at Pelennor was fantastic.

As was the siege of Gondor, including the never to be duplicated Grond, the battering ram "with the head of a ravening wolf" you betcha!

But I really missed the Houses of Healing and especially the Fields of Cormallen.

And Sam never got to have his conversation with Frodo, just before Shelob's lair, about being in a story, and curling up with the Red Book, and his kids asking him to read the "story about Frodo and Ring, dad! He was the most famousest hobbit ever, wasn't he dad?" And after Sammath Naur, when the ring is gone, bemoaning the fact that he'd never hear the story about Frodo of the nine fingers and ring of doom. And then later, hearing it when they are honored.

Sigh.

ROTK was an action flik. Gandalf and Legolas were action figures. Am I the only one comparing Legolas with Luke in the Empire Strikes Back taking on the Imperial walkers at the Battle of Hoth? Luke Elfwalker!

The definitive interpretation of The Lord of the Rings remains to be accomplished.
 
Another of my NPW comments I forgot to mention in my review....I didn't like the lighting of the beacons (or the way it was done initially). Gandalf having Pippin climb the tower on his own with no help from free falling a hundred meters or so to his death and doing it against the Lord of the city's wishes while he looks out of his window in disgust.

The more I think about it and the more reviews that I read the more I am disgruntled with the way Gandalf was portrayed as a whole. He was a coward and pessimist and he obviously had no respect for Denethor at all (whacking him down with his staff was an obvious sign, wasn't it?) Of course with the way PJ portrayed Denethor, who would have respect for such a pig of a man.

Luckily (unlike TTT) there was much good that replaced the annoying and sometimes devastating PJisms that kept the story going and true to Tolkien.
 
I'm curious to know who voted that it was a complete waste of money. I thought that ROTK rocked!!!! I plan on seeing it again during Christmas break.
 
I've seen it! I have I have. But it is some-what hard for me to rate so I didn't vote in the poll and I won't until I see it again. And this review is just temperary untill I have the chance to see it again which will most likely be on Sunday.

Now it might have been because of the rude and uncivilized young men who sat behind me but I was some-what dissapointed.
But it might also have to do with the fact that it was so loud I still have a head-che and I saw it Yesterday.
And it could have also been that I am a writer and I have studdied tolkiens books and know them well and I love how poetic and Shakespearian they are in their speach and they seemed to take that out.
Also even though I was prepared for all the deleted scenes I still didn't like that they weren't there.
And I was some-what dissapointed how half of it was not true to the book.

OK Now that I've finished with the not so good stuff we can look at the goodies.

Costumes were great and acting was superb! Very realistic battle sequences very exciting like on the edge of your seat or holding your knees exciting and great choriograghed fight scenes. Wonderful special effects and the storyline was ok.
But the BEST of all to me was the sound track with Billy and Viggo singing!
Well, I hope I didn't mess it up for you guys, That is my oppinion. And I'm sure it is different from what others are saying.
 
Yey seen it!!!!!!!

It was worth the wait. Awesome, some truly great scenes.

I was left breathless.


Gimils comedy again....super....and oscar nomination at LEAST for Gollum....super performance
 
Greatest Movie Made.

This movie by far has got to be one of the greatest I have ever seen.
I have been a Tolkien fan ever since my father introduced Tolkiens works to me 10 years ago and I have read through every work he has done ( as well as his son), just finishing The Tolkien Companion recently.

These movies really have set a trademark in filming history, seeing as how I take into the account of how the actors put every ounce of their soul into these movies. The dedication put forth, either for the sake of the book, or just the movie is amazing.
I consider myself a purist, and always enjoy defending a good Tolkien and his works, but seeing as how the movies are a great thing....well then I can't really defend anything.
All in all...an all time favorite movie.
 
Like FotR and TTT, I am overwhelmed, and have trouble summing it up in a few words. But unlike those two previous movies, I am entirely unconflicted in this one respect: I loved the movie. Through and through. I don't have any doubts about it now. It may need an EE here and there, but it carries the trilogy exactly where it needs to go.

I have to admit that I was relatively detached from Tolkien, so I saw this much more as a film than anything else. But without a doubt what stuck out most for me, and what I think proves that PJ can show extreme subtlety on-screen that matches Tolkien, was the Frodo-Sam relationship. Everything building up on it led to something monumental, and that relationship is ultimately the heart of the movie. It's what carries it past the battles. There is a look of Frodo's, after he wakes up in Minas Tirith, where he's been laughing and crying with his friends, and then Sam comes in, last of the Fellowship, and Frodo's stare is worth... well, it's priceless. It's a look of sorrow, regret, joy, gratitude, shame, and incredible love. It's so touching that none of these words really do it justice, and that's what the best of Tolkien is like. In FotR I already knew that the Frodo/Sam relationship would be powerful. The scene in the boat was enough to get me teary-eyed. But in TTT and RotK PJ developed (partly off the book, partly off his own ideas) a sort of tension between the two charachters that makes it so much more poignant.

And I guess that's what I feel like... this is ultimately Frodo and Sam's story. Which is incredibly fitting. I think the coronation scene brought that into full perspective. When Aragorn says "You bow to no one," I really felt that PJ got it. The hobbits were ultimately the heart of the tale.


Now even though PJ nailed Frodo and Sam perfectly, I felt that many other threads suffered. I mean, maybe it's just the fact that the Frodo/Sam thread was by contrast so much more powerful, but many threads lacked the emotional weight I was looking for. Given that RotK had the longest rough cut of the three, I'm not too surprised, and I expect many of these threads to be deepened in the EE. In fact, these problems are so charachteristic of the kind the EE "fixes" that I'm certain the EE of RotK will be mindblowing. The EE tends to deepen charachter threads, and that's what I lacked in a number of places. To list a few of them:


Aragorn's kingship. I didn't feel the emotional weight behind it.

Aragorn/Arwen. I felt that the build-up in FotR and TTT lost its flight towards the end of RotK. This is partially due to the fact that the Eowyn thread was never resolved. Aragorn essentially tells her it can't happen, and all we get is her dispair. The Houses of the Healing, which will resolve her conflict regarding Aragorn, will in turn resolve Aragorns thread with Arwen as well.

Theoden. He had scenes, but I felt detached at his death. For one, there was no aftermath for it. Nobody spoke of it again. Nobody seemed to notice he died. This left the emotional weight of the scene in limbo.

Faramir. He never gets to redeem himself, because Denethor never finds out he rejected the Ring. And he never gets to resolve his thread, because Houses of the Healing didn't make the cut. Add those two in and Faramir becomes a much more emotionally satisfying charachter. I'd also like a little something with him finding out how Denethor died, after he wakes up.


I don't mean to imply that these threads ought to match the Frodo/Sam thread in emotional weight. They can't, and they shouldn't. But they should deffinitely pay-off, and I'm sure in the EE they will.

But for the moment the Frodo/Sam stuff is incredibly touching. Frodo's last shot in the movie, smiling back at his companions, is Elijah Wood's crowning moment. It's such an innocent, wise, and ultimately relieved expression. The feeling that scene captures, of the hobbits being left behind, and of loosing such magic and wonder... it absolutely devastated me. And Sam being the last one to turn away from the Havens... and his look, still yearning for more innocent, simpler days, of somehow wishing none of this would have happened... that him and Frodo could be back where they were before the Ring, before the war... I felt PJ brought that across brilliantly. It's something you feel in the book as well. That feeling where nothing will ever be the same. It can't be. There's no point trying to change the past. And yet you yearn for it so much. In Sam's eyes, just as the ship is leaving, Sean Astin has this brilliant conflict, where he just wants to see Frodo come back, and live in the Shire... that's the dream he's been fighting for. And as the boat leaves, we see that dream die in Sam's eyes. We see him shed his innocense right there, without a single word spoken. One of the great moments in film I've ever seen, and a perfect way to end the trilogy.
 
I've seen it !!!!!!!

oh, I don't know what to say...
many things were marvellous to behold, like the Ride of the Rohirrim out of the dawn to the Fields of Pelennor... the scene at Samamth Naur was marvellous and the end ... it made up for any deviations PJ made so far, to his credit he got the end spot on, it was beautiful


but also things that bothered me, like the Pass of Cirith Ungol in plain sight of Minas Morgul, the whole business with Shelob and Sam running around the grounds of the Tower all visible. The Battle of Pelennor Fields was disappointing, it didn't convey the horror of three days of fighting, it just seemed one disorganised mess, and I didn;t like the ords invading the city, Minas Tirith was supposed to be huge, seven levels and each gate had a guard and a password... not a cramped fortress where the orcs could find their way to the top with such ease.

but all in all, the good things outweighed the bad ones and it didn't feel like three and a half hours. I left the theatre pleased, with the picture of Frodo smiling on board the Elven ship with his friends smiling through their tears on the shore lingering on my mind... now I can sit back and look forward to the Extended Editions and next Christmas I will sit in front of the telly and watch them all and be happy it was made
 
I saw it yesterday, and I have nothing to complain for except that I couldn´t stay still for the last ten minutes. If it only had been ten minutes less this long, it would have been perfectly perfect. The end was excellent but it was too long.

I expected longer battlescenes, more DRAMATIC, and NEW things.
Because it´s really those new, creative artistic things that makes you open your mouth.

And the only time I was near crying was when Arwen saw her son.

The best performance was made by Pippin, and the horseriding to which he sings are very touching.

I also excpected more fighting and less talking, and I didn´t have a 200-minute orgasm, but almost....Anyway it beats every other film.
 
The definitive interpretation of The Lord of the Rings remains to be accomplished.


That would take aboiut 69 hours & someone would still be pissed off because you forgot the ten cases of Old Winyards for Rory Brandybuck when Bilbo leaves the gifts after THe Long expected opartry......
 
I have to agree with Maddona Baggins about that Pippin thing. He and Aragorn's siging was like the best to me! And Pippin's performance with the Palantir was pretty awesome but Sam deserves a best supporting actor award because he had a very hard emotional roll that deviated quite a bit from the original works.
 
I have just seen RotK this afternoon. I feel really satisfied with it, it is a grand ending to the story, as it completes all of the loose ends left over from the previous movies. Some people had predicted that this movie would fall apart because of the plot deviations in the earlier films, but far from it – now that I have the chance to look back on the entire project I feel even more at ease and impressed with it than before.

As a film, this one is stunning. PJ has managed to put Middle Earth on the screen in front of us, with the geography, the peoples, the monsters, the cities and fortresses. It is a visual feast that I can watch over and over again. Minas Tirith is beautiful, I hope they did not really have to destroy the miniature during the battle! Minas Morgul is a totally dreadful place, it gave me the creeps all over. Mordor is all I could hope for, the eruption of Mount Doom is incredible. I know that the movie has to be more than the visuals (and it is), but I think a lot of people take already too much of what we see here for granted. Maybe it is that I grew up with the Bakshi effort, but I am really very impressed with the looks of the film.

The characters were developed much as I had anticipated. I have always said that PJ simply uses the oldest trick in the book of theatre: dramatising his characters. I think this is justifiable because even with three long films the viewers do not have the same time and opportunity to get to know the characters as readers of the books. To help us understand them he paints them with bolder strokes. Frodo and Sam’s characters have reached a great depth, I am perhaps one of the few that have no problem at all with Frodo sending Sam away. It fitted quite naturally in the way the film portrays the interaction between them and Gollum, and the very strong power the Ring has over him. The way they reconcile, even with the tension when Sam has to hand the Ring back, is far more emotional just because of what happened before. Merry and Pippin have matured exactly as I thought they would, and the transition from playful and innocent hobbits to wise and hardened warriors is quite convincing. Aragorn is truly King at the end, his taking the paths of the Dead, his later decision to ride to the Black Gate and his behaviour there show that he has finally grown into his destiny. Gandalf is no longer just the wise councellor but becomes very commanding and takes personal charge of the defense of Minas Tirith. I’m fine with Denethor, his madness is more important than his high lineage and potentially deep insights, and his madness came out very well in the movie. Faramir is now also complete as a character and I have no more problems with the way he is depicted in the film – already the TTT EE did much to fill out the gaps left in the TE.

The actions are stunning. Stunning! The shot of the hundreds of riders leaving Edoras was only the first of a series of truly amazing big action, big drama scenes. The lighting of the beacons – a cinematic high point! The charge of the Rohirrim sent chills down my spine, I pressed myself hard in my seat at the moment of impact with the Orc army. The siege engines, Grond, the Mumakil, the Trolls pushing the siege towers, Wow! The Nazgul steeds flying over the battlefield, grabbing soldiers and horses and dropping them from great height, you have to see it to believe it. I actually quite like Denethor running in flames over the wall and jumping down, another example where PJ changes a more static scene for a more dynamic, cinematically effective way of telling the story.

Emotionally, the Frodo and Sam thread is of course the most intense. I had to sniff a bit after the destruction of the Ring when they sat on the rock surrounded by the lava and spoke about the End of All Things. Of course the scene at the Crack of Doom itself is extremely powerful cinema. Just the lighting on Frodo’s face as he stands on the edge, deciding what to do, is worth a Special Effects Oscar alone.

The multiple endings are so many essential conclusions to the multitude of character arcs and plot strands. I am sure that the EE will add a few more with Faramir and Eowyn, and perhaps the wedding of Aragorn and Arwen. The return to the shire (with a cameo of my good old alter ego, if I may be excused ) does show the feeling of estrangedness that the hobbits have after their monumental experiences in a subtle but effective way with a scene in the Green Dragon.

The Grey Havens scene is of course very emotional, but I did my best not to sniff any more because I had already drawn too much attention from a couple of teenage kids sitting next to me!

The ending is simply perfect.

Looking back on all the three films as one long movie, all I can say now is that PJ has done a fan-tas-tic job. Not just for the Tolkien lovers, but most certainly for the millions of non-readers out there. With the project completed, his changes from the book already fade into the background and become mostly inconsequential for me, and do indeed on the whole improve the story as a movie. In my opinion, of course, your mileage may vary.

Go to see it again after Christmas. Yippee!

Odo
 
Posting here this late in the game, it would be hard for me to come up with anything new regarding ROTK. I will say that this film is a case of the whole being greater than the sum of the parts. There were several faults I found with ROTK that, added together, should have made it worse than it was. As it is, I found this to be the most emotionally satisfying of the three films (as it's supposed to be, I guess).

A couple of points:

1. I had no problem with the Smeagol/Deagol episode. I'm just not sure if starting the film with that was the right way to go. I heard people around me muttering "what the heck is this?". I like the fact that PJ filmed it through Gollum's decent into madness (even given Gandalf's reproduction of this event in "Shadow of the Past", it was off-stage). By the way, in FOTR's (the movie) prologue when we see a hand grabbing the Ring underwater, did anyone else assume that PJ was showing us that Smeagol found the Ring?

2. "Go home, Sam". I saw something like this coming, given the way Frodo was acting in TTT. PJ didn't need to go down this road, but I don't see the amount of harm in it that many of you do. I know PJ was trying to beat the audience over the head with how damging the effects of the Ring were, but if the audience didn't get it by now, they never would - it's the whole premise of the story, after all!! I differ a little with some on Frodo's motive for this, however. I read it more as him saying "the Ring's having an effect on you, Sam. Get away before it destroys you". As opposed to "I have a new friend now. I don't want to play with you anymore".

3. "Arwen is dying". Ugh.....Completely unnecessary. At this point in the story, Aragorn had all of the motivation he needed to want to become King. Thankfully, this didn't come up again, although I'm afraid it may get fleshed out in the EE. Nothing like a little pressure from the future father-in-law, huh? "Make sure the Ring is destroyed, get rid of Sauron, and become King so my daughter will live". Although, come to think of it, Elrond's line to Aragorn in the book about Arwen not giving up her immortailty for anyone less than the King of both Gondor & Arnor amounts to pretty much the same thing. I'm probably making a mountain from a molehill on this, but it just didn't sit well with me.

4. The acting. This (IMO) doesn't get talked about enough, except in passing on the way to ripping or defending PJ. The actors (for the most part) in this film are wonderful. I don't recall ever seeing Miranda Otto in anything before, but I thought she was fantastic as Eowyn. What she can do with a facial expression is just amazing.

5. Paths of the Dead. I had no problem with PJ bringing the Dead directly to Minas Tirith. Although, given the effect they had on the battle, Aragorn should have gone into the Haunted Mountain two days before & saved everyone a lot of trouble. I also thought Aragorn's dialogue got a little whiny when he was trying to convince the King of the Dead to honor their oath.

6. Mount Doom. Wonderful. Except for a slight change in dialogue, it was exactly the way I pictured it.

7. Jack Nicholso......er, Denethor. PJ makes Kubrick's mistake in "The Shining". By portraying (hell, even casting Jack was a mistake) Nicholson's character as looney from the get-go, he makes the character a lot less interesting, IMO.

That's about it for now. I'm sure I'm forgetting something I wanted to address ("then write it down, dummy!). All in all I enjoyed this film most of the three. The acting was marvelous. The visuals were stunning. As for the story, most of PJs inventions were completely unnecessary, but he had painted himself into several corners in the earlier films.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…