breadfan35
New Member
- Joined
- Oct 5, 2003
- Messages
- 55
Originally posted by breadfan35
It has to be, we already know that Saruman will be in the EE, along with at least one scene inthe House of Healing with Faramir and Eowyn, but the Lord of the Nazgul vs. Gandalf (I pray) must be in the EE. It was in the trailer so that leaves me to believe it will be. Also, Saurons Lieutenant at the Black Gate. I think that will be in the EE also. It was in the ROTK PS2 game. I know that just because the game has something doesn't mean it will be in the movie, but in both LOTR games, their stories were drawn from the films. They never drew something from the book, that was not to be in the movie. So that gives me hope.
This was my first post in here and now I will elaborate on my feeling of this film.
Clears throat
I left this film with a mixture of happiness (80%) and disappointment (20%). Rather than state what I did like, I'll state what disappointed me since I had less of that.
It did seem rushed to me in some places.
The disappointments that stick out the most to me (in my memory) are:
The Dead Army Fighting
They show up and you really don't see them kick any ass, just kinda float around a few orcs and then they are asking to be released. I'd have liked to have seen more of them.
Gandalf vs. Lord of the Nagul (I don't like the name Witch King)
I really wanted to see this. It is what I am looking forward to the most in the EE. I believe it will be there because the Lord of the Nazgul said he would take care of Gandalf, (not in those words) and also it shows him landing in front of Gandlaf while he is on Shadowfax in the preview of ROTK in the special features disc of TTT. Plus there is a picture which is on the official movie website showing it http://www.lordoftherings.net/index_downloads.html
Eyown Vs. Lord of the Nazgul
I just would have liked there to have been a little more of a struggle. The Nazgul King went down pretty fast, it sure didn't make him seem very powerful.
Frodo and Sam's journey after Shelob
This would probably be what seem the most rushed to me. When Sam is going to Cirith Ungol: Right before he walks in a fight starts, cut to Sam walking in, next cut he is walking through it and everyone is dead or gone except for the few guards on the stairs. That went way to fast IMO. Pretty much everything until they are actually in Mount Doom seemed too fast paced to me.
No Lieutenant of Sauron at the Black Gate
This is the another scene I was really looking forward to. I really hope it is in the EE, but I have my doubts.
And lastly
Gollum's Death
Although I am pleased with the scene as a whole, I would have liked Gollum to realize at least half way down that " Oh crap, I'm about to die" and start freaking out. Rather than be in blissful ignorance all the way. I just would have liked to see him fear for his fate. Does that make me sick?
But even with those few things, I still really liked the film and love the trilogy as a whole. I will be seeing it again this weekend and probably a ton more times.

