Heehee, that's me! And <off topic> are you Japanese, or living in Japan for some other reason? I lived outside Tokyo for three years because my dad's in the Air Force.cookie girl
I could have forgiven a lot if the majesty had been there for me. But it wasn't.Why, because I love books mayby too much and to see that Tolkiens ideology has been mocked just feels uneasy. After TTT I decided I will not going to see this one in a thetre, because i was so angry. Now I think I will go to see it, but I also realise that this movie is still going to be a farse. Still, I love to see its majesty, just to experience it.
Rhiannon said:Heehee, that's me! And <off topic> are you Japanese, or living in Japan for some other reason? I lived outside Tokyo for three years because my dad's in the Air Force.
It was you Rhiannon, thank you very much for you comments about the movie. I believe you more then those Jackson fans. We are still lovers of Tolkiens Middle-Earth, not that silly illogical world of Jacksons. I believe that when we went to see these movies we were expecting to see movie about Tolkiens LOTR, but it turned out to be something else, a typical fantasy movie.
I could have forgiven a lot if the majesty had been there for me. But it wasn't.
Thanks! Nom makes the best avatarsoh.my.goodness.
Rhiannon, your avatar is the coolest. can't believe I have to wait ANOTHER year to see this on film *sigh*
You're welcome, Khazad, and I agree with you; watching RotK, all I could think was 'Hey, this reminds me of Willow'- now, Willow is a good film and I enjoy it a lot, but it's not Tolkien.It was you Rhiannon, thank you very much for you comments about the movie. I believe you more then those Jackson fans. We are still lovers of Tolkiens Middle-Earth, not that silly illogical world of Jacksons. I believe that when we went to see these movies we were expecting to see movie about Tolkiens LOTR, but it turned out to be something else, a typical fantasy movie.
And even sadder to write. I'm no longer violently annoyed by the film- I'm just sad.This was sad to read
I was not happy with Gimli in TTT at all, and he had some of the same sorts of moments in RotK, but he also had one or two of his good lines preserved. Kind of two little too late- much too little, much too late- but at least it was there.When I was a kid I really loved dwarfs, but Jackson just made Gimli as a stupid, whining clown. It really made me angry, especially in TTT. Hmmm...doesnt look good for RoftK too
Rhiannon said:And, off topic again, isn't Japan beautiful? I've been in the States for a year and a half now, and I still miss the mountains.
Rhiannon said:We are very glad to have your permission, Lotho.
I would never expect that of you, GW! *expression of shocked horror* Just scroll, dear.You can have my permission too, but do not expect me to listen.
It was that jarring to me. I gave my reasons above for why it's acceptable for him to walk on snow but not to climb an oliphaunt. The special effects were bad because I could tell they were special effects- or maybe I've just gotten too good at spotting computer animation. And I do agree that Gimli's line was great, but I think Legolas could have brought an oliphaunt down in a more reasonable way and still have allowed for the line.I agree that the now seemingly infamous 'oliphaunt scene' should not have been included, but it certainly is not as jarring as some of you make it to be. Heavens, the elf can walk on the top of snow, yet can't stand on some substantially sized arrows? Except, perhaps, for the scene where Legolas is on the oliphaunt shooting men off, the scene looks perfectly believable. And the special effects are not bad. (Also, let me not fail to mention Gimli's great line once Legolas is back on the ground!)
Trebuchets are way cool as a rule, but I was kind of curious about the idea of Minas Tirith having them mounted on the walls. I didn't really think it was likely, but my brother pointed out that Minas Tirith was a fortress, designed to withstand a siege.I thought Minas Tirith firing catapults back at the Orcs was cool.
Rhiannon said:Trebuchets are way cool as a rule, but I was kind of curious about the idea of Minas Tirith having them mounted on the walls. I didn't really think it was likely, but my brother pointed out that Minas Tirith was a fortress, designed to withstand a siege.
Madonna Baggins said:Has anyone seen ROTK more than once and thought it was boring or slow the second time?
Has anyone seen ROTK more than once and thought it was boring or slow the second time?
Madonna Baggins said:Has anyone seen ROTK more than once and thought it was boring or slow the second time?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?