• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145
Hmmm.....

I live in Japan, so I will see RotK after couple of months. After reading your messages until page 7 I somehow came to a conclusion that this movie is not going to be any better then previous two were. Why, because I love books mayby too much and to see that Tolkiens ideology has been mocked just feels uneasy. After TTT I decided I will not going to see this one in a thetre, because i was so angry. Now I think I will go to see it, but I also realise that this movie is still going to be a farse. Still, I love to see its majesty, just to experience it.

Still I think (sorry forgot you username) that cookie girl is very much like me, and I am not going to like the movies storyboard. I understand books are books and movies are movies, but still this trilogy should never have label Tolkiens LOTR on it. Shame Christopher
 
cookie girl
Heehee, that's me! And <off topic> are you Japanese, or living in Japan for some other reason? I lived outside Tokyo for three years because my dad's in the Air Force.

I could have forgiven a lot if the majesty had been there for me. But it wasn't.
 
oh.my.goodness.
Rhiannon, your avatar is the coolest. can't believe I have to wait ANOTHER year to see this on film *sigh*

Elves walk lightly upon the earth - this is why L can walk on snow without sinking. But there is a definate line drawn - THERE. If Elves are under different rules of gravity that allow them to shimmy up the side of a huge Mumak using nothing but toothpicks and then STAY on the Mumak through all types of gravity defying moves, why do the elves need to take a ship from the Gray Havens at all? They could just walk there across the water!
 

This was sad to read

When I was a kid I really loved dwarfs, but Jackson just made Gimli as a stupid, whining clown. It really made me angry, especially in TTT. Hmmm...doesnt look good for RoftK too

I am a finn, living in Nagano.
 
oh.my.goodness.
Rhiannon, your avatar is the coolest. can't believe I have to wait ANOTHER year to see this on film *sigh*
Thanks! Nom makes the best avatars

You're welcome, Khazad, and I agree with you; watching RotK, all I could think was 'Hey, this reminds me of Willow'- now, Willow is a good film and I enjoy it a lot, but it's not Tolkien.

This was sad to read
And even sadder to write. I'm no longer violently annoyed by the film- I'm just sad.

When I was a kid I really loved dwarfs, but Jackson just made Gimli as a stupid, whining clown. It really made me angry, especially in TTT. Hmmm...doesnt look good for RoftK too
I was not happy with Gimli in TTT at all, and he had some of the same sorts of moments in RotK, but he also had one or two of his good lines preserved. Kind of two little too late- much too little, much too late- but at least it was there.

And, off topic again, isn't Japan beautiful? I've been in the States for a year and a half now, and I still miss the mountains.
 
Today I saw RotK for the second time. I had prepared myself by watching FotR EE last night and TTT EE this morning

I enjoyed the second viewing as much as I did the first. Special moments for me were:

- Gandalf and Pippin coming to Minas Tirith, riding through the city and arriving at the palace

- The lighting of the Beacons (moist moment # 1).

- Frodo, Sam and Gollum witnessing the emptying of Minas Morgul. Scary, scary, scary...

- Looking down upon the Gathering of the Rohirrim in Dunharrow (the first time I hadn't noticed the zig-zagging way up to the King's encampment, complete with Pukel-men).

- Pippin's song, Faramir's charge and Denethor's meal (moist moment # 2).

- Grond (evil!).

- Theoden's speech before the Charge of the Rohirrim, and the actual charge. I have never seen anything like this on film (and that includes the movie 'Waterloo' with Rod Steiger, which has a couple of very good cavalry charges too) (moist moment # 3).

- Eowyn vs Witch King, of course. Perhaps the single most emotional moment in the film (moist moment # 4).

- Sam carrying Frodo (moist moment # 5).

- Frodo standing at the crack of Doom considering his decision. The lighting on his face is amazing. What struck me is that he actually looked a lot like Isildur in the scene with Elrond at the same place. He had the same expression on his face - a kind of greedy stubbornness against all better judgement.

- Aragorn's speech before the assault at the Black Gate.

- Frodo and Sam sitting on their rock (moist moment # 6).

- Everybody bowing to the hobbits.

- Grey Havens (moist moment # 7).

This time no annoying teenagers sitting next to me, but my wife and daughters. They know me by now as a soppy old f*rt when it comes to LotR films, so I wasn't bothered too much about sniffing in public

Some things I found not as satisfying (apart from the cut scenes that we will get back eventually):

- the Palantir scene is a bit over-dramatic. The way Pippin looks into it is OK, but him jumping about holding the flaming thing is a bit too much.

- Gandalf is very curt to Pippin when he offers Denethor his service. I thought it quite touching but Gandalf clearly saw it differently!

- It is a bit of a shame that the Orcs actually enter Minas Tirith, it might have been nicer if Rohan had arrived at the moment the Gate is breached (perhaps with a crowing ****?)

- I found the scene with Frodo in Shelob's lair a bit too long.

- Those Oliphaunts are a wee bit too big.

But none if these detract from my viewing pleasure.

My wife and middle daughter thought this one the best of the three, my youngest daughter thinks TTT is best. I most like FotR, mainly because of the greater diversity in events and settings. My third and eldest daughter can't be bothered with anything LotR, she finds it all boring

Odo
 
Rhiannon said:
And, off topic again, isn't Japan beautiful? I've been in the States for a year and a half now, and I still miss the mountains.

We got some snow lately, so mountains looks so beautiful especially during sunset and sunrise. I live between Japans Northern and Southern Alps. Cows, sheeps and horses are herding just under my window. Cannot complain.
 
Thanks Odo, for that long post about your reactions to ROTK. My wife and I just saw it a couple of hours ago.

As a person who's been reading the book fer nigh on ta 40 yarn, I can say that PJ has given us a stupendous, glorious gift, one that creates a new cinematic benchmark, and sets the bar several notches higher.

Let those who are moved to nitpick pick nits to their heart's content, if that's what gives them contentedness. I in the meanwhile will spend my time enjoying the books and the PJ films (and probably whatever remakes may come down the pike) for many many years to come.

Lotho
 
Lotho_Pimple said:
Let those who are moved to nitpick pick nits to their heart's content, if that's what gives them contentedness.

We are very glad to have your permission, Lotho.
 
I would have like to have seen Frodo and Sam together in Shelob's Lair and the fight between Gollum and Sam outside of the Lair. There was so much energy in that fight because both had let loose all their angry and hatred of each other. I know they fought before they entered the Lair but it didn't have the same impact for me. And more of Shelob creeping up behind them.....it was sooooooo scary in the book. I really didn't picture Shelob as a tarantula....I think she definitely should have had a fatter body and looked more like a black widow (someone said earlier).

However, the scene at Minas Morgul where Sam and Gollum had to fight Frodo to get off the bridge and then the gates opened, the ugly light shot up straight into the sky and the piercing, shrill cry from the Witchking was just perfect. I thought I had died and gone to heaven. I must see it again just for that scene.

When Eowyn confronted the Witchking, my heart was pounding so hard, I thought it was going to pop out of my chest. I agree with someone earlier who said her identity should have been concealed until that moment.

I truly LOVED this movie.
 
Rhiannon said:
We are very glad to have your permission, Lotho.

You can have my permission too, but do not expect me to listen.

I agree that the now seemingly infamous 'oliphaunt scene' should not have been included, but it certainly is not as jarring as some of you make it to be. Heavens, the elf can walk on the top of snow, yet can't stand on some substantially sized arrows? Except, perhaps, for the scene where Legolas is on the oliphaunt shooting men off, the scene looks perfectly believable. And the special effects are not bad. (Also, let me not fail to mention Gimli's great line once Legolas is back on the ground!)

If Legolas bringing down an Oliphaunt was somehow homage to Luke taking out an AT&T (or whatever those things were) than no doubt Gandalf's "Steady, steady" line to the Gondorian soldiers at the gate was homage to our brave general, Jar Jar Binks...
 
Hey, I got this one question:

Where the heck were the Easterlings? They were mentions many times in the Battle of the Pelennor Fields chapter and PJ shows them entering the Morannon when Frodo, Sam, and Gollum come there. What, were the Easterlings just passing through the Black Gate and Mordor? Sorry, I was just really looking forward to seeing them, oh well, I can forgive PJ's forgeting that.

Hmm, well, I dunno were I stand. I loved the movie but it did irk me quite a bit in a few scenes. Here we go:

- I know every FAD seems to be tired of this (and maybe a few NPW), but Gandalf hitting Denethor. Please, the only thing I don't get is what those 30-some guards were doing there. What are they there for? If Denethor is allowed to get hit (crazy or not), then he better find some new guards.

- Army of the Dead. They looked great and they were awesome, but sorry, they never showed up on the Pelennor or Minas Tirith. I was hoping and to see more of the Cosairs' ship and Aragorn and co. coming to the Pelennor with a whole Gondorian army from southern Gondor.

- Theoden and Éowyn on the Pelennor. Theoden never knew Éowyn was there. It was a great scene but I think it could have been done (better) with Éomer. He was left out of TTT way to much and it seemed like that in RotK. Just thought that PJ could give up some Éowyn time for Éomer. But I guess he wasn't important enough. PJ could and should've given him more screen time.

- Frodo, Sam, and Smeagol. Please. Frodo and Sam did have some good, emotional moments, but, Frodo telling Sam to leave? Trusting Smeagol/Gollum to much. No Frodo+Sam+Shelob fight?

~ Okay, maybe I've said to many bad things about the movie. So, here's some good:

+ Siege of Gondor. Great. Well done. I thought Minas Tirith firing catapults back at the Orcs was cool. I wish they would have shown more of the Gondorian Archers mowing down Orcs with arrows, but, nothing to left out, well done.

+ Battle of the Pelennor Fields. Very nice. Of course, as one the biggest Rohirrim lovers in the world, I liked it. Except the see them get killed by the Mumakil. But still, I love it, it was soo emostional. I loved it.

+ Muster of Rohan. To short, but nice seeing them leaving Edoras and Dunharrow whole-heartedly for Gondor. I hope to see more in EE

+ The Black Gate opens. I know it's going to be amazing in the EE. Plus the Eagles coming I totally forgot about the first time I saw it, so that was really neat.

+ Faramir and Denethor. I was really well done, and alot of lines were from the book that was spoken between them. Also, the Gondorian Cavalry charging towards Osgiliath was great.

Hmm, I was sad that Prine Imrahil was not there. He seemed like a very important character. Oh well. As a Tolkien Purist, I stilled liked the movie alot.
 
You can have my permission too, but do not expect me to listen.
I would never expect that of you, GW! *expression of shocked horror* Just scroll, dear.

It was that jarring to me. I gave my reasons above for why it's acceptable for him to walk on snow but not to climb an oliphaunt. The special effects were bad because I could tell they were special effects- or maybe I've just gotten too good at spotting computer animation. And I do agree that Gimli's line was great, but I think Legolas could have brought an oliphaunt down in a more reasonable way and still have allowed for the line.

I thought Minas Tirith firing catapults back at the Orcs was cool.
Trebuchets are way cool as a rule, but I was kind of curious about the idea of Minas Tirith having them mounted on the walls. I didn't really think it was likely, but my brother pointed out that Minas Tirith was a fortress, designed to withstand a siege.
 

Indeed, another name for Minas Tirith was Tower of Guard. Also the lowest level wall could not be broken (they were made of the same stone that Orthanc was made of) unless Sauron himself was there. Anywho, yeah, it does make sense to for Minas Tirith to have Trebuchets (thanks for the correction Rhiannon) But what I was guessing during the siege was if those Trebuchets could be reloaded quickly. It looked might hard to roll a huge stone on a small wall walk-way. Who knows.

I forgot to mention, I the Eye of Sauron Spotlight made me laff. And how close Mt. Doom and Barad-Dur were to the Black Gate. Look at some maps, no way could they apper that big. Hehe..
 
Madonna Baggins said:
Has anyone seen ROTK more than once and thought it was boring or slow the second time?

I finally got to see it again, and thought it was even better than the first viewing. (If that be possible)
 
Has anyone seen ROTK more than once and thought it was boring or slow the second time?

I actually enjoyed the second viewing much more than the first. The second time around, this Purist was able to emotionally protect myself from the ugly changes (Frodo > Sam - "Go away!", Arwen and the Ring, etc.). So I was able to enjoy the truly enjoyable parts all the better.

I might even see it a third time and especially look forward to owning the EE version.
 
Madonna Baggins said:
Has anyone seen ROTK more than once and thought it was boring or slow the second time?

I thought it was slow both times, but more slow the second. But I was also really tired and worn out when I went the second time (the first time I was all sugared up beforehand).
 
The first time I saw it I was anxious to see the different scenes. When I saw it the second time I was still excited.
 
I'm actually ready to see it again just so it's fresh in my mind and giving it another chance.

My best friend and I said that the third movie simply needed a new director because it seemed as though PJ just slacked off in some things. I'm still pretty furious over the scouring of the Shire.
And all of the dieviations and stuff.
But yes he did to pretty darn well with all the battle sequences. I will admitt that.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…