Thanks Deimos. It has been added.OK... I'm going to throw one out there that is almost guaranteed to raise a hue and a cry, but it needs to be included, for two reasons:
(1) to further dispel the mistaken assertion that Tolkien is a racist, and
(2) to deny the willfully ignorant the arrogance to dictate what words they take offense at; where, had they taken the a few minutes to educate themselves, no offense should be possible. Note well the etymology of the word
The word is niggard : noun, a meanly covetous and stingy person, a miser
adjective, niggardly
From Middle English nigard, nygard (“miser”), from nig (“niggardly person”), possibly of Scandinavian origin; compare Old Icelandic hnǫggr (“miserly, stingy”), Old Norse *hniggw, with descendants Swedish njugg (“stingy”), dialectal Swedish niggla (“be stingy”), dialectal Norwegian nigla.[1][2] Ultimately from Proto-Germanic *hnauwjaz, source of Old English hneaw (“stingy”), replaced by Middle English nig. Possibly cognate to niggle (“miser”).[3] Compare German Knicker (“niggard”), knickerig
It is obvious that this word long pre-dates the more modern N-word, which did not come into use until the 16th C. and which the wilfully ignorant assume is related "niggard".
It no surprise that Tolkien would use it because it's a commonly used Anglo Saxon word.
"And Faramir and Éowyn stood forth and set hand in hand; and all there drank to them and were glad. 'Thus,' said Éomer, 'is the friendship of the Mark and of Gondor bound with a new bond, and the more do I rejoice.' 'No niggard are you, Éomer,' said Aragorn, 'to give thus to Gondor the fairest thing in your realm!'"
Aragorn is complimenting Eomer saying he is being very generous (no [miser] are you) in giving Eowyn --"the fairest thing in your realm" to Gondor .
The context makes the meaning obvious, and the mistaken definition, if applied, makes absolutely no contextual sense.
I think it's important to include this word, probably the most important entry in your entire list, because of the confusion that surrounds it.
How many folks here have thought Tolkien was using a racial slur?
It is would be a service to him and everyone here who desires to fully appriecate him and his work. to understand his use of the word " niggard" .
Go HERE to learn the difference (and similarity) between "march" (or marches) and "mark"Thanks Deimos. It has been added.
Coincidentally, the same quote includes another word I was just studying this morning: "The Mark" or "The Riddermark" as alternate names for Rohan. I got as far as seeing it's a synonym for "march" meaning some sort of borderland. I thought it was strange that Rohan is "The Mark" yet Tolkien uses "march" at its southern border within "Fenmarch". Why not Fenmark? Sounds too close to Denmark maybe? (Uh oh. Now I'm wondering how Denmark got its name.) 🙂
Anyway, still have work to do on that one....
Well educated.What does this make me?
In the case of bolster-the-pillow: to me, it would make you The Loremaster of Pillows.So many of these are words I am familiar with and even use. What does this make me?
Thanks. This one was surprisingly educational and entertaining.You don't seem to have Buttery: a room for storing foods or wines.
Minas Tirith: ''The visit shall be short, a mere call of courtesy, and we will go thence to the butteries.''
Your dictionary is not lacking.I added three more words to the collection.
Strangely, flammiferous was in my usual English dictionary, but I had to refer to a Latin dictionary to find flammifer. (I think my dictionary may be lacking.)
It is one of my favorite Tolkien phrases, just based on the sound of the words:but how he wanted to say it.
Yep... First time I read that phrase the loveliest image came to mind.It is one of my favorite Tolkien phrases, just based on the sound of the words:
...the Flammifer of Westernesse.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?