• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Durin VII - "The Decline of TTF" and Moria

Status
Not open for further replies.
Both of you can bite me... :p

How's that for negative? ;)

Now that we've been posting redundant statements the post count of this thread has reached 100! Rarely see that these days! Now, there's a positive comment! :D

Cheers,

Úlairi.
 
Hehe, careful there Úlairi. I grew up in a house that took the words "bite me" quite seriously. I have scars to prove it!:eek::p
 
That's rather worrying Firawyn:eek:

Anyhoo, I feel like a complete noob now tbh. I am sure most of those who posted regularly and left for whatever reason feel the same. Nice to see you Elbereth btw:) Long time no speaky;)

I was thinking, the best questions I was ever asked on this forum were by people who knew perty much nuthin about Tolkien but after their first read thought of something: 'The Way is Shut Guy' and 'Can the Ring Think' were great, momentus debates asked by people who by their own admission knew bugger all about Tolkien, just goes to show you really!
 
That's rather worrying Firawyn:eek:

Yeah well, get to know me a bit and you'll learn I had a rather...I'm going to go with the word "insane", childhood. :rolleyes: But, I'm trying to get past that and not slip into the "decline" that was my homelife. :)
 
Fir said:
I grew up in a house that took the words "bite me" quite seriously.
Anc said:
That's rather worrying Firawyn

Personally, I will only find it worrying if she also admits to reading the Twillight series. Otherwise, it's just Fir.
 
I seem to remember this same debate raging on before, we've never actually reached any kind of a resolution that would be acceptable to everyone.
In response to you, dear Úlairi, I'm sure you have heard the saying 'It's not the quantity, but the quality that matters'? We may have less posts and less 'old' members posting daily than we used to, but the quality of fare served here is still very high.
Why is it so important to you that people who were very active when you started should come back and keep this forum alive? Shouldn't we rather thank them of their contributions so far and let them enjoy some well-deserved rest from the fray? Let the new kids have their say as well, as has been pointed out earlier in the thread, many are afraid to post for fear of being ridiculed.
Now, I was reading The Hobbit when you were not yet even born, and started on LoTR about the time you learned to talk, dear boy - but I cannot honestly say that I have more than scratched the surface of this amazing world Tolkien created. I wander around the forum and post stuff because I feel I have something to discuss, but not everybody feels the same way. And we should respect that, let's remember that we all have real lives to contend with too.
 
Wow! Life really does get in the way of this place, doesn't it?

Cheers,

Úlairi.
 
Personally, I will only find it worrying if she also admits to reading the Twillight series. Otherwise, it's just Fir.

Oh I know of this series. It is...really really bad. I do not like this new care bear Vampire that exists in that series.
 
I seem to remember this same debate raging on before, we've never actually reached any kind of a resolution that would be acceptable to everyone.

Well, oft that's just life, ain't it?

In response to you, dear Úlairi, I'm sure you have heard the saying 'It's not the quantity, but the quality that matters'? We may have less posts and less 'old' members posting daily than we used to, but the quality of fare served here is still very high.

I personally find that saying to be ultimately futile. The greater the quantity of posters on this forum; the greater the quality. It's just the laws of probability, dear Starflower. I was not arguing for an increase in quantity however, but directly the opposite. It is of no import to me whatsoever if we see the exodus of newbs to the fora; as long as we retain those who have been responsible for embellishing the halls of this forum. This was once (and hopefully will be again) an oasis and I find no issue with voicing the opinion that this place is far more proficient with them than without them.

Why is it so important to you that people who were very active when you started should come back and keep this forum alive?

Because those are the people that I have learnt a great many things from; and as such I hold them in the highest of high regards, and respect them. The acquisition of wisdom is far greater than that of knowledge. Discussing aspects of that which I find to be one of the most magnificent pieces of literature perpetuates a deeper understanding of not just the knowledge of the text but often revelatory comprehension and wisdom that I can apply in my own personal life. I have virtually never found this from "quantity posters".

Shouldn't we rather thank them of their contributions so far and let them enjoy some well-deserved rest from the fray?

This is a place of rest and thus they can rest here. I'll thank them when they come back...

Let the new kids have their say as well, as has been pointed out earlier in the thread, many are afraid to post for fear of being ridiculed.

And I see no need to reiterate my position on that matter again. I know many wish to point the finger at me in this respect for making them feel unwelcome but since my return the problems I've encountered have not been with anyone new to the forum. I have in fact welcomed some of them. Just ask Itnjmy.

Now, I was reading The Hobbit when you were not yet even born, and started on LoTR about the time you learned to talk, dear boy - but I cannot honestly say that I have more than scratched the surface of this amazing world Tolkien created. I wander around the forum and post stuff because I feel I have something to discuss, but not everybody feels the same way. And we should respect that, let's remember that we all have real lives to contend with too.

Sorry Starflower, but the "real-life" argument is getting a little tedious for me. I lead a real life as everyone else and I often resent reading hundreds of pages of law to ascertain a very limited range of ratio decidenda. When I'm at work the sheer mundanity of it inexorably leads me here where I feel the happiness of contributing in a way that is far more meaningful to me than writing a thesis as to why a 400 year old case has such an important impact on the law and jurisdiction of equity or what staff members populate a particular corporation. Just doin' what makes me feel happy. The true shame perhaps is that these people have left because they no longer feel a passion for the works of JRRT - but that is their choice and I much prefer that as a reason not to participate than just life getting in the damn way. I know I hate it when it forces my hand. As for how, when and where you've read the works of Tolkien I fail to see the relevance other than the fact that as my elder you deserve respect and if you have any wisdom to impart through the quality of your posts I'd be more than happy to listen.

Cheers,

Úlairi.
 
I am very grateful to :p Firawyn, RangerStryder & Ulari :pfor making me feel very welcome.

My first posting was an inadvertent mistake - to a thread another newbie had started and one poster did make me feeling uncomfortable about that error - but other than that - I have felt very welcome here. :cool:

((In my opinion - many of the posters on http://www.theonering.com are not as nice and open as those here. Many are somewhat pompous and rarely carry on conversations regarding Professor Tolkien's masterpieces.))
 
Well, I guess there's at least one new person to the forum that does not feel intimidated.

Cheers,

Úlairi.
 
Well, I guess there's at least one new person to the forum that does not feel intimidated.

Make that two of us. And i'd like to thank Firawyn, Chrysophalax, Prince of Cats, and of course Varokhâr (without whom i never would have come here in the first place) for making me feel welcome. :)

But i would also like to mention that not everyone who comes through here is going to be one extreme or the other. Just because a poster is not a literary-analyst/thesis-writing/debating scholarly type does not mean that they are automatically the shallow-minded/pop-culture-infatuated/lowest-common-denominator of the fandom, either. And vice versa. There are many shades in between.

As others have already mentioned, some of us are here simply to connect with others who also love the world that Tolkien created. We are here to commune with kindred spirits - not for a contest of wits, but to enjoy with others something that we mutually love. Perhaps to some that may sound overly simple and emotional, and i fully admit to being an idealist and a romantic by nature (and i don't think there's anything wrong with that :)), but there is no right or wrong way to love something. If some enjoy that love through scholarly debate, then that's fine (for them). Others enjoy it through RPG, lighthearted discussions, fanfic writing, etc, and that too is fine. Isn't this why there are so many different sections on this forum? There is room for all of us. Ideally everyone has their niche and, as long as all involved are putting care and thought behind what they contribute, and are as true to and respecting of the canon as it deserves us to be, i see no problems with either form of expression, nor do i see one as greater than or less than the other.

I have already enjoyed being here, and, while i admit that my heart sank while i was reading some of these posts (as i don't believe any of us, regardless of which niche we belong to, should allow arrogance to mar the experience in any way), i still look forward to continuing my stay.
 
We are here to commune with kindred spirits - not for a contest of wits, but to enjoy with others something that we mutually love.

If some enjoy that love through scholarly debate, then that's fine (for them).

Commune with kindred spirits?

Your attempt to remain pacifistically objective unfortunately missed the mark. There are those, such as myself, that enjoy nothing more than a contest of wits; even when they lose. It is often my lifeblood in which I draw sustenance from this place.

There is room for all of us.

I know that the reference to arrogant posting was possibly in reference to myself but if you're going to insinuate that I claimed that there wasn't room for us all then kindly point out where I said that so that I may remedy it. I have no recollection of even making the slightest remark purporting such an idea.

I have already enjoyed being here, and, while i admit that my heart sank while i was reading some of these posts (as i don't believe any of us, regardless of which niche we belong to, should allow arrogance to mar the experience in any way), i still look forward to continuing my stay.

And I shall continue to remain indifferent until the quality of posting on this board is in accordance with the standard that compels me to participate. This is, of course, what all of us do whether we consider ourselves to be higher and mightier or not.

Cheers,

Úlairi.
 
Well goodness. I guess should be on a the TTF Welcoming Committee. :eek: Thanks guys.

Now onward.

Because those are the people that I have learnt a great many things from; and as such I hold them in the highest of high regards, and respect them. The acquisition of wisdom is far greater than that of knowledge. Discussing aspects of that which I find to be one of the most magnificent pieces of literature perpetuates a deeper understanding of not just the knowledge of the text but often revelatory comprehension and wisdom that I can apply in my own personal life. I have virtually never found this from "quantity posters".

Ulairi, dear, if I didn't know any better, I'd say that you miss some of these people. Interesting. ;)


But i would also like to mention that not everyone who comes through here is going to be one extreme or the other. Just because a poster is not a literary-analyst/thesis-writing/debating scholarly type does not mean that they are automatically the shallow-minded/pop-culture-infatuated/lowest-common-denominator of the fandom, either. And vice versa. There are many shades in between.

I agree completely with this.

Your attempt to remain pacifistically objective unfortunately missed the mark. There are those, such as myself, that enjoy nothing more than a contest of wits; even when they lose. It is often my lifeblood in which I draw sustenance from this place.

True, Ulairi, but just because you like it that way does not mean it is the ONLY way to be. And you would certainly have no grounds to say (not saying that you have said) that your way is the best way. Life is not about proving you are the best. Everyone has strengths, and everyone has weaknesses. That why we need relationships - so that we can pull others up in thier weaknesses, and so that they can pull us up in ours. It's a delicate balance that is extreamly good for us, as human beings.

And by the way, please get off Starflower about pointing out the facts of real life, because like it or not, you do exist outside of cyberspace, as do the rest of us, and real life is a valid point in any discussion.
 
I am not about to argue with you, Úlairi, and i apologize if you felt in any way singled out by my post, as that was not my intent. I learned years ago that arguing and getting upset over posts on an internet forum was not good for my (or anyone's) health. I hope one day you find the experience you seek. Until then, i hope that you and i can at the very least enjoy a peaceable acquaintance.

Life is not about proving you are the best. Everyone has strengths, and everyone has weaknesses. That why we need relationships - so that we can pull others up in thier weaknesses, and so that they can pull us up in ours. It's a delicate balance that is extreamly good for us, as human beings.

That was beautifully said, Firawyn, and i cannot agree more.
 
Ulairi, dear, if I didn't know any better, I'd say that you miss some of these people. Interesting. ;)

Your perceptiveness is astounding as always Fir. :p

True, Ulairi, but just because you like it that way does not mean it is the ONLY way to be.

And again I never purported this concept. It's simply a matter of personal taste. I am not, nor have I ever forced upon anyone on this board where, how and when they should post. To even believe that I have such power is profoundly egotistical. Do you all think that I'm just some egomaniacal megalomaniac who wishes to establish an esoterically intellectual oligarchy? WM can flick me off this board with his little finger if he so wishes. I have no delusions of grandeur; I simply expressing the opinion that I consider this place to be far more rewarding and worthwhile when it is populated by people who have great wisdom which they apply to the knowledge derived from the works of Tolkien. It is The Tolkien Forum, after all... although it sure as hell doesn't feel like it anymore (and this may be why Alcuin is no longer present :(). Other than that I'm just a simple-minded plebian.

And you would certainly have no grounds to say (not saying that you have said) that your way is the best way.

Thanks Captain Obvious. :p I am of the opinion that my way is the best way only because it is how I feel about the particular matter. My personal view, a contention, an ideal, a belief inimated etc... I will not concede however, from the position that this forum is better populated by noobs unless from newbs (and I used the different variation here for obvious reasons) we see the development of a particular few that can generate brilliant discussion. Quality arises from quantity and quantity from quality. A self-perpetuating cycle. We can get certain random brilliant threads from time to time like Finding God in The Lord of the Rings from newbs but those discussions are maintained and much more deeply explored by more adept minds.

Life is not about proving you are the best.

Well, it is a fundamental tenet of capitalism upon which the financial aspects of our lives are founded upon, but I agree with you nonetheless. There is no point preaching to me here on this point as I have not made this contention previously, and more to the point I agree with this wholeheartedly. If I have an opinion I feel strongly about I will simply defend it to the best of my ability. If I come out the victor in the end then all I have been is successful in my endeavour to defend that belief, nothing more, nothing less.

Everyone has strengths, and everyone has weaknesses. That why we need relationships - so that we can pull others up in thier weaknesses, and so that they can pull us up in ours. It's a delicate balance that is extreamly good for us, as human beings.

I have no weaknesses...

I'm invincible!
You're a looney.

;)

And by the way, please get off Starflower about pointing out the facts of real life, because like it or not, you do exist outside of cyberspace, as do the rest of us, and real life is a valid point in any discussion.

I don't need the facts of life pointed out to me when I come here to get away from them, it simply defeats the entire purpose of coming on here in the first place. Real life is certainly a valid point as I can't make a point without having one. I just simply get bored of having the same point reiterated to me as I don't listen to broken records.

I am not about to argue with you, Úlairi, and i apologize if you felt in any way singled out by my post, as that was not my intent.

I wasn't spoiling for a fight Voronwen. I don't understand why everyone on this board contorts into a twisted ball everytime someone expresses an opinion contrary to the accepted norm or majority view. You have an opinion on the matter and so do I. We can leave it at that. I have no plans to pursue it further as not only has this argument become stale... it just goes around in circles. It may not have been your intent Voronwen to single me out but the placement in relation to threads made it quite obvious. You can call me arrogant, I have absolutely no problem with this whatsoever. "There's nothing you can't throw at me that I haven't already heard." If you call me arrogant a need will arise to defend myself and I will do so. Once I have done so I will leave it at that. What I am saying and I have repeatedly said to this forum is that I will not instigate personal attacks from now on. The first bullet fired will not come from my gun, but the second one most definitely will be.

I learned years ago that arguing and getting upset over posts on an internet forum was not good for my (or anyone's) health. I hope one day you find the experience you seek. Until then, i hope that you and i can at the very least enjoy a peaceable acquaintance.

We can enjoy more than that Voronwen. I often find the people I have the greatest repoire with are the people I initially experience dissension with; just ask Fir and Illuin. Just because I avidly defend my position it does not mean that I have personal dislike for you; quite the opposite actually. Being a law student requires that I have to maintain a level of objectivity in any argument.

Your "peaceable acquaintance",

Úlairi.
 
Last edited:
Originally posted by Úlairi
It is The Tolkien Forum, after all... although it sure as hell doesn't feel like it anymore (and this may be why Alcuin is no longer present :(). Other than that I'm just a simple-minded plebian.

I have a lot of free time in the summer :D, and I promise I'll make it up to you. I prefer the in-depth stuff myself, but right now my head is about to implode. I can't even remember if I have eaten lunch or dinner most of the time. Give me just a couple of months and we'll head back to the Eldanyárë and get busy again. I've been wondering about Alcuin myself lately. I guess a PM would be useless if he doesn't log on :rolleyes:.
 
I have a lot of free time in the summer :D, and I promise I'll make it up to you. I prefer the in-depth stuff myself, but right now my head is about to implode. I can't even remember if I have eaten lunch or dinner most of the time. Give me just a couple of months and we'll head back to the Eldanyárë and get busy again. I've been wondering about Alcuin myself lately. I guess a PM would be useless if he doesn't log on :rolleyes:.

I know what you mean mate. The law is becoming so burdensome I often find myself wondering why I'm even doing it in the first place! Try e-mailing him. He often responds to that.

Cheers,

Úlairi.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top