Deimos
Elite
- Joined
- Sep 6, 2022
- Messages
- 5,105
Interesting that you’ve never listed the word “doom” .
And let me guess the reason: because everyone already knows what “doom” means; it means destruction and death.
Well, yes…..unless you happen to be JRRT, in which case it means much, so much more than that.
Doom originally meant fate, or judgment , typically an evil fate or a negative judgment .
To pronounce or state someone’s doom usually did not bode well.
Death may be part of it but it may not.
But one’s doom wasn’t always bad. It could merely mean one’s destiny, which could be good or neutral or bad.
In Sindarin Mount Doom was both Amon Amarth (hill of fate) and Orodruin (mountain of doom)
Notice: hill=mountain and fate=doom...not doom = destruction.
So”doom” as Tolkien used it primarily meant fate or destiny, secondarily it meant destruction.
But if it meant the latter it was to be understood that the destruction was fated, the destiny of the person (or city or race) that could not normally [i.e., barring supernatural help] be changed or avoided.
Recall what Theoden ponders as his men muster to ride to aid Gondor: "So ... It is before the walls of Minas Tirith that the doom of our time will be decided."**
He has no crystal ball. He does not foresee either the rescue of Gondor or its destruction; he does not foresee his own death or his avoidance of it.
He knows that any outcome is possible. What he is saying is that they will soon learn the fated outcome, whether it be good or evil.
Right before Denethor immolates himself he tells Gandalf how he preferred his life to end: "...To be Lord of this City in peace, and leave my chair to a son after me... But if doom [fate] denies this to me, then I will have naught..."
**Theoden says this to himself in the movie: in the book a messenger from Gondor says it to Theoden, but doom still means fate or destiny
And let me guess the reason: because everyone already knows what “doom” means; it means destruction and death.
Well, yes…..unless you happen to be JRRT, in which case it means much, so much more than that.
Doom originally meant fate, or judgment , typically an evil fate or a negative judgment .
To pronounce or state someone’s doom usually did not bode well.
Death may be part of it but it may not.
But one’s doom wasn’t always bad. It could merely mean one’s destiny, which could be good or neutral or bad.
In Sindarin Mount Doom was both Amon Amarth (hill of fate) and Orodruin (mountain of doom)
Notice: hill=mountain and fate=doom...not doom = destruction.
So”doom” as Tolkien used it primarily meant fate or destiny, secondarily it meant destruction.
But if it meant the latter it was to be understood that the destruction was fated, the destiny of the person (or city or race) that could not normally [i.e., barring supernatural help] be changed or avoided.
Recall what Theoden ponders as his men muster to ride to aid Gondor: "So ... It is before the walls of Minas Tirith that the doom of our time will be decided."**
He has no crystal ball. He does not foresee either the rescue of Gondor or its destruction; he does not foresee his own death or his avoidance of it.
He knows that any outcome is possible. What he is saying is that they will soon learn the fated outcome, whether it be good or evil.
Right before Denethor immolates himself he tells Gandalf how he preferred his life to end: "...To be Lord of this City in peace, and leave my chair to a son after me... But if doom [fate] denies this to me, then I will have naught..."
**Theoden says this to himself in the movie: in the book a messenger from Gondor says it to Theoden, but doom still means fate or destiny
Last edited:



