• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Tolkien's "Special" Words

Interesting that you’ve never listed the word “doom” .
And let me guess the reason: because everyone already knows what “doom” means; it means destruction and death.

Well, yes…..unless you happen to be JRRT, in which case it means much, so much more than that.
Doom originally meant fate, or judgment , typically an evil fate or a negative judgment .
To pronounce or state someone’s doom usually did not bode well.
Death may be part of it but it may not.
But one’s doom wasn’t always bad. It could merely mean one’s destiny, which could be good or neutral or bad.

In Sindarin Mount Doom was both Amon Amarth (hill of fate) and Orodruin (mountain of doom)
Notice: hill=mountain and fate=doom...not doom = destruction.

So”doom” as Tolkien used it primarily meant fate or destiny, secondarily it meant destruction.
But if it meant the latter it was to be understood that the destruction was fated, the destiny of the person (or city or race) that could not normally [i.e., barring supernatural help] be changed or avoided.

Recall what Theoden ponders as his men muster to ride to aid Gondor: "So ... It is before the walls of Minas Tirith that the doom of our time will be decided."**

He has no crystal ball. He does not foresee either the rescue of Gondor or its destruction; he does not foresee his own death or his avoidance of it.
He knows that any outcome is possible. What he is saying is that they will soon learn the fated outcome, whether it be good or evil.

Right before Denethor immolates himself he tells Gandalf how he preferred his life to end: "...To be Lord of this City in peace, and leave my chair to a son after me... But if doom [fate] denies this to me, then I will have naught..."

**Theoden says this to himself in the movie: in the book a messenger from Gondor says it to Theoden, but doom still means fate or destiny
 
Last edited:
Interesting that you’ve never listed the word “doom” .
And let me guess the reason: because everyone already knows what “doom” means; it means destruction and death.

Well, yes…..unless you happen to be JRRT, in which case it means much, so much more than that.
Doom originally meant fate, or judgment , typically an evil fate or a negative judgment .
To pronounce or state someone’s doom usually did not bode well.
Death may be part of it but it may not.
But one’s doom wasn’t always bad. It could merely mean one’s destiny, which could be good or neutral or bad.

In Sindarin Mount Doom was both Amon Amarth (hill of fate) and Orodruin (mountain of doom)
Notice: hill=mountain and fate=doom...not doom = destruction.

So”doom” as Tolkien used it primarily meant fate or destiny, secondarily it meant destruction.
But if it meant the latter it was to be understood that the destruction was fated, the destiny of the person (or city or race) that could not normally [i.e., barring supernatural help] be changed or avoided.

Recall what Theoden ponders as his men muster to ride to aid Gondor: "So ... It is before the walls of Minas Tirith that the doom of our time will be decided."**

He has no crystal ball. He does not foresee either the rescue of destruction of Gondor; he does not foresee his own death or his avoidance of it.
He knows that any outcome is possible. What he is saying is that they will soon learn the fated outcome, whether it be good or evil.

Right before Denethor immolates himself he tells Gandalf how he preferred his life to end: "...To be Lord of this City in peace, and leave my chair to a son after me... But if doom [fate] denies this to me, then I will have naught..."

**Theoden says this to himself in the movie: in the book a messenger from Gondor says it to Theoden, but doom still means fate or destiny
I did expend some brain BTU's in the past looking for the meaning in Turin's epitaph: "Master of doom. By doom mastered."

To start, I decided I could just substitute "fate" for the two "dooms". So, he was a master of his own fate but also mastered by his fate. Then, anything beyond a superficial meaning just seems to elude me.
 
"In old England, pubs owners referred to P's and Q's as pints and quarts. The pub owners would request the bartender to keep account of the evening's tally. Additionally, the bartenders and wait staff would redirect ruckus customers to return to their pints and quarts vice creating a scene."
 
"In old England, pubs owners referred to P's and Q's as pints and quarts. The pub owners would request the bartender to keep account of the evening's tally. Additionally, the bartenders and wait staff would redirect ruckus customers to return to their pints and quarts vice creating a scene."
Is that true?
 
Wikipedia, the absolute MOST TRUSTWORTHY source of all time :eek:, contains the definition Ent grew up with:

"Mind your Ps and Qs is an English language expression meaning "mind your manners", "mind your language", "be on your best behaviour", "watch what you're doing"."
 
And I do believe this "holds water" (or other liquids) as well:

"Nevertheless, a number of alternative explanations have been considered plausible. One suggests "Ps and Qs" is short for "pleases" and "thank-yous", the latter syllables pronounced like the letter "Q". Another proposal is from the English pubs and taverns of the 17th century: bartenders would keep watch over the pints and quarts consumed by the patrons, telling them to "mind their Ps and Qs".[5] This may also have been a reminder to bartenders not to confuse the two units, written as "p" and "q" on the tally slate.[3]"
 
I did expend some brain BTU's in the past looking for the meaning in Turin's epitaph: "Master of doom. By doom mastered."

To start, I decided I could just substitute "fate" for the two "dooms". So, he was a master of his own fate but also mastered by his fate. Then, anything beyond a superficial meaning just seems to elude me.
Your "translation" is correct.
It may, perhaps, seem contradictory, but being both master of and mastered by fate (one's destiny) is a paradox of the human experience.
(Tolkien knew exactly what he was saying 😉)
 
Interesting that you’ve never listed the word “doom” .
I added doom, thanks.
My doom is to keep at this list until it's finished.

Here's another example where the doom was something good:

doom The Field of Cormallen: “But Gandalf lifted up his arms and called once more in a clear voice: ‘Stand, Men of the West! Stand and wait! This is the hour of doom.’ And even as he spoke the earth rocked beneath their feet.”, [Definition: destiny. Often unhappy destiny, but not always.]

Also, I think an example of another variant of doom, as a judicial sentence, is exemplified in the exchange between King Elessar and Beregond:
"For these things, of old, death was the penalty. Now therefore I must pronounce your doom."
 
I added doom, thanks.
My doom is to keep at this list until it's finished.

Here's another example where the doom was something good:

doom The Field of Cormallen: “But Gandalf lifted up his arms and called once more in a clear voice: ‘Stand, Men of the West! Stand and wait! This is the hour of doom.’ And even as he spoke the earth rocked beneath their feet.”, [Definition: destiny. Often unhappy destiny, but not always.]

Also, I think an example of another variant of doom, as a judicial sentence, is exemplified in the exchange between King Elessar and Beregond:
"For these things, of old, death was the penalty. Now therefore I must pronounce your doom."
Right. And Beregond was aghast at the first part of his "doom"...banishment from Minas Tirith.
Only to learn that the second part of his "doom" was a blessing..to be made captain of the guard for his beloved Lord Faramir.
btw...Aragorn's judgment on Beregond was an excellent example of tempering justice with mercy.
Good judges in any era and in any realm (or plane of existence 😉) know how to do this, strike this balance.
 
Here be two more.
Thudder.
Meaning: A heavy dull sound (as made by impact of heavy object)
The Unfinished Tales. Page 222
''In the list of names accompanying the tale Dramborleg is translated Thudder-Sharp.''

Vice-gerent.
Meaning: a person exercising delegated power on behalf of a sovereign or ruler.
The Unfinished Tales. Page 258
''When the Valar gave to us The Land Of Gift they did not make us vive-gerents.''
 
Here be two more.
Thudder.
Meaning: A heavy dull sound (as made by impact of heavy object)
The Unfinished Tales. Page 222
''In the list of names accompanying the tale Dramborleg is translated Thudder-Sharp.''

Vice-gerent.
Meaning: a person exercising delegated power on behalf of a sovereign or ruler.
The Unfinished Tales. Page 258
''When the Valar gave to us The Land Of Gift they did not make us vive-gerents.''
Thanks Aethelwulf.

Thudder and vice-gerent will be added.

I think gerent seems to have almost the same meaning as regent. I wonder why Tolkien chose to use gerent instead of the word more commonly known.

thudder Unfinished Tales: ''In the list of names accompanying the tale, Dramborleg [Tuor’s axe] is translated Thudder-Sharp.'', [Meaning: a heavy dull sound (as made by impact of heavy object).]

vice-gerent Unfinished Tales: ''When the Valar gave to us The Land Of Gift they did not make us vice-gerents.'', [Meaning: a person exercising delegated power on behalf of a sovereign or ruler.]
 
Its quite strange that gerent has almost the same meaning as regent, and is even the same word but mixed up.
 
I added five words to the list today.

Seeing the definitions now, the use of troth and plighted together seems somewhat like a duplication.

troth The Children of Hurin, Chapter 15 (Niniel has a happy moment.): “Then she was glad indeed, and she plighted her troth, and at the mid-summer they were wedded…”, [Definition: loyal or pledged faithfulness, fidelity.]

plight The Children of Hurin, Chapter 15 (Niniel has a happy moment.): “Then she was glad indeed, and she plighted her troth, and at the mid-summer they were wedded…”, [Definition: to put or give in pledge.]

craven The Children of Hurin, Chapter 10 (Turin tries to cheer up Finduilas): “Nargothrond shall stand! Never again will Morgoth the Craven come forth from Angband, and all his reliance must be on his servants…”, [Definition: lacking the least bit of courage, fainthearted.]

gainsay The Children of Hurin, Chapter 2: “But this was the counsel of Turambar, and it was useless to gainsay him.”, [Definition: contradict, oppose.]

hillock The Children of Hurin, Chapter 13 (Turin grieves at the burial site of Finduilas): “…they led him to a hillock by the Crossings of Teiglin. There he laid himself down, and a darkness fell on him, so that they thought he was dead.”, [Definition: a small hill.]
 
Excellent start.

But you are leaving off some very obvious use-cases.

I give you:

Black v black (Capital v. Lower-cased)

Light v light (same).

Mountain v mountain (same).

And, to make matters even more confusing:

Black when referring to people who are identified as a Northern European ancestors, or as the Idealization OF those people (this is certainly likely to create some problems, as most people today don’t understand how widespread the word was in Northern Europe as applied to others of the same Racial Groups — Itself something non-existent in our world that does exist in Middle-earth).

Black when referring to a ‘Person’ seen by Tolkien to be an even earlier ancestor of the English who spent most of his nearly 700 year life in deep caverns.

Ruddy and Brown when referring specifically to the Antecedents of the English

There are many, many, MANY different words that were in common use in late-19th and early–20th Centuries that are now seen as offensive and racist (and are Such in their modern forms, which have little to no connection to those as used by Tolkien, whether spoken or within his written works and correspondences.

As for the words “Fag/Faggot” (something I heard often in my youth in the more derogatory form, yet when I went to College in England, I heard the word “fag” and “faggot” every ten seconds it seemed… Of people asking for a cigarette or a light for one/to light another from one of these , etc…).

The words were still in widespread use in the 1990s, the last time I returned to visit friends made in the 1980s

Oops… I missed one of my favorites (if not two, three or four):

MB

Edit:
Crooked and Bent

Corrupted
and Perverted

These can be applied to physical objects as well as it can be applied to Acts or Thoughts that are believed to be seen as such.

MB

Its quite strange that gerent has almost the same meaning as regent, and is even the same word but mixed up.
Not really strange when you look at the structure of noun declensions in Old English/Saxon:

‘Ge-“ tended to be a part of a declension about doing to, or being done by as a part of a noun/pronoun and verb combination. It meant “You-all” or “all of you people.”

So Ge-Rent would be a term for “renting” (seeking the rule and ordering) of “you all,” which transformed to “regent” in one of the various laguage collisions of the later Medieval period(s).

MB
 
Last edited:
Doom originally meant fate, or judgment
While perusing the list I came across this one and remembered our recent discussion about doom and fate. Here's another synonym for fate (even stranger sounding than doom.) I thought you might find it interesting.


weird The Fall of Gondolin, The Original Tale: “And Ulmo said: ‘O Tuor of the lonely heart…fare now on thy destined journey and tarry not, for far from hence is thy weird set.’”, [Definition: fate, destiny.]
 
Weird: "c. 1400, "having power to control fate," from wierd (n.), from Old English wyrd "fate, chance, fortune; destiny; the Fates," literally "that which comes," from Proto-Germanic *wurthiz (source also of Old Saxon wurd, Old High German wurt "fate," Old Norse urðr "fate, one of the three Norns"), from PIE *wert- "to turn, to wind," (source also of German werden, Old English weorðan "to become"), from root *wer- (2) "to turn, bend." For the sense development from "turning" to "becoming," compare phrase turn into "become."

The sense of "uncanny, supernatural" developed from Middle English use of weird sisters for the three Fates or Norns (in Germanic mythology), the goddesses who controlled human destiny. They were portrayed as odd or frightening in appearance, as in "Macbeth" (and especially in 18th and 19th century productions of it), which led to the adjectival meaning "odd-looking, uncanny" (1815); "odd, strange, disturbingly different" (1820). Also see Macbeth. Related: Weirdly;
--------
Words are so lovely.
--------------------------------
1683124558057.jpeg
 
While perusing the list I came across this one and remembered our recent discussion about doom and fate. Here's another synonym for fate (even stranger sounding than doom.) I thought you might find it interesting.


weird The Fall of Gondolin, The Original Tale: “And Ulmo said: ‘O Tuor of the lonely heart…fare now on thy destined journey and tarry not, for far from hence is thy weird set.’”, [Definition: fate, destiny.]
I was aware of that definition.... it appears in Macbeth.
The three witches on the heath are also called "the weird sisters" because they foretell the fates of the other characters.
 
Carrock - Yes, as Ent recalls, Tolkien covers that word off really well.
One of the hobbits, Ent thinks, asks why it is called the Carrock. Gandalf's reply is something like "It is called the Carrock because that's what he calls it." (stifling any arguments about the word before they even arise? whatever, it's a memorable interlude to a degree.)
Don't have text handy, so can't confirm with precision.

There IS a word Carrack... one of the potential meanings of in its etymology is 'pinnacle.' But it mostly refers to boats.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top