• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

Real swords are far sharper and and far more dangerous.

Try startling a friend by suddenly and unexpectedly pressing a sharp knife against a friend’s neck as a joke. See what happens!

Aragorn, a trained Ranger and Numenorean Royalty, with nine Nazgul within earshot, in an age where swords were a necessary and widespread tool of society. I am sure Aragorn would have reacted quite differently than "a friend."

I feel this is a hideous reference, but one that struck me as relevant nonetheless: In the James Bond film Goldeneye, (featuring Boromir with a gun!) We are introduced to Valentin Zukovsky (Robbie Coltrane) with a pistol at his head. He immediately identifies the weapon and owner and decides there is no real danger in turning around.
Aragorn would have almost certainly identified the sword at his throat as Elvish before Arwen had even spoke. I can imagine that a troll's club doesn't feel quite the same, nor an Orkish scimitar.

Also, the flat of a blade is not exceedingly sharp, and direct contact with a sharp blade will not lacerate the skin without considerable force. Boromir is cut because he runs his finger along the blade.

I don't know how you treat your friends but I think I'll keep mine rather than face an attempted murder charge.

Thanks
Morgaphry
 
So I suppose that other scene on the Stairs of Cirith Ungol, in which Gollum finds Frodo and Sam nestled together in sleep, and for a brief heart-breaking moment seems "an old weary hobbit, shrunken by the years that had carried him far beyond his time, beyond friends and kin, and the fields and streams of youth, an old starved pitiable thing" was simply beyond the cinematic powers of PJ. (Too much for him, or not enough?) Boffo blockbuster movies just can't show such subtle emotion! Understatement obviously "does not work" on film! Sure, his dear uncle Bilbo can be suddenly transformed before the Ringbearer's eyes into a slavering wretch with pointed teeth, but render poor Gollum sympathetic without schizophrenia? Don't think so! Better he should be just a worm-squeezing creep from the start. Sure, Tolkien himself thought this "fleeting moment" the saddest in the entire story, but what does he know about "being true to the spirit of Tolkien"?

I really liked the movies; I thought they are perhaps the best movies made in the past 10 years at least; still there are some changes that were, to me, absolutely disgusting. Faramir was one and this scene was another; not for the way Frodo treated Sam (though that was ridiculous, I could live with it); not for the cheap melodrama; but simply because of the use of the word 'sneak'. When Sam says that in the book, he's being horribly unfair, and in a way, 'damning' Gollum, who lost his chance for salvation at that moment. It is the only part of the book when I am really angry with Sam, and feel the real loneliness of Gollum. In the movie, Sam is right! Gollum is being a sneak indeed; to use this word in such a horribly different context (but one in which someone who read the book 10 years ago could mistake for the original) was simply awful.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
As for "video games": yes, certainly they can help a person aquire a certain amount of manual dexterity and eye-hand coordination. But even the most unbiased critic of the culture must admit that they are a fixation to the point where they have become the main source of "exercise" for far too many children. I have seen youngsters on picnics, at the beach and even at the movies totally absorbed in these games to the point at which they are totally unaware of their surroundings! One sometimes wonders if the concept of the film "The Matrix" might not be much closer than we realize if so many of especially our younger people seem to live "through" their computers!

I'm not talking about hand-eye coordination or the sort, I'm talking of real emotions and thought provoking ideas.

For example, I've been a gamer for a good ten years. And in that time I've played a number of RPG games that have moved me and have given me and friends ideas for many discussions and the sort, these games such as Final Fantasy and Breath of Fire can have more meanings than many may understand, and I understand that many older people who have not experienced these for themselves are shocked at young people who play videogames.
But to claim that they are the reason that youngsters are out of touch with reality is codswallop.

But this is going too offtopic, I'm going to start a discussion in the Stuff and Bother on this, as this is a interesting debate topic.
 
Morgaphry said:
Aragorn, a trained Ranger and Numenorean Royalty, with nine Nazgul within earshot, in an age where swords were a necessary and widespread tool of society. I am sure Aragorn would have reacted quite differently than "a friend."

I feel this is a hideous reference, but one that struck me as relevant nonetheless: In the James Bond film Goldeneye, (featuring Boromir with a gun!) We are introduced to Valentin Zukovsky (Robbie Coltrane) with a pistol at his head. He immediately identifies the weapon and owner and decides there is no real danger in turning around.
Aragorn would have almost certainly identified the sword at his throat as Elvish before Arwen had even spoke. I can imagine that a troll's club doesn't feel quite the same, nor an Orkish scimitar.

Also, the flat of a blade is not exceedingly sharp, and direct contact with a sharp blade will not lacerate the skin without considerable force. Boromir is cut because he runs his finger along the blade.

I don't know how you treat your friends but I think I'll keep mine rather than face an attempted murder charge.

Thanks
Morgaphry
And we've been told that purists go out of their way to attack the films! It would seem that you are going out of your way to defend something very stupid that Jackson did that fairly ruined the "mood" of the first film for me! (And it was going along so well to that point!)

But if you wish to look at the matter in context, then by all means let's do so! Aragorn at that point is totally fixated on the thought that the Ringbearer is slipping into a wraith state (and the Ring would then be under the direct control of the Nazgul because Frodo would be in their power). He is aware that the Nazul are near, but he doesn't know quite hownear. He is also aware that they are probably skilled enough to slit his throat or at least attack him directly (he has no "burning brands" to defend himself) and he is also looking as hard as he can for athelas to treat Frodo's wound! Are you saying that under those circumstances Arwen could be sure that he would not act first and look later? Or, in fact, that she would be either so stupid or so callous as to put them in the position where either or both of them could be seriously hurt - especially given the existing circumstances??

Let's face it! This was not a well thought out plot ploy designed to enlighten the audience about a newly introduced character (that was when Arwen comes to Frodo in the "light"), but another of Jackson's "silly moments" which was put in the film at a time when, in fact, no such a moment should have been included. Remember, the company was at the height of the peril. Any reasonably intelligent person would have made themselves known in advance if for no other reason than the comfort and well being of the other. Such "jokes" remind me of people who pull chairs out from under those who about to sit down! 'Tain't funny, McGee!
 
(I stopped right here because every point so far illustrated the points I was making. and it seems as if you are commited to not learning.)

jallan said:
That’s hardly being clueless or pretending to be at the same level technically as many creators of films or music or books. I many not be able to build a house but I can tell when a roof leaks.

Your statement pre-supposes that YOU (and those like you) are they only ones capable of telling if a roof leaks. I'm here to tell you that most people can tell if a roof leaks, that would be a MAJORITY OF PEOPLE. A majority of people like the movies, as is, and do not view them as you do. Your opinion about this movie is OUTSIDE the majority. So, we are not talking about something as simple as a leak in a roof. Making a successful movie is not as easy as making a roof that doesn't leak.

They way I see your argument about changes that positively, 100%, for sure would have made it a better movie for everyone, is more along the lines of a compition to get to the moon. You figure all you have to do is take aim and fire and you'll hit it. The truth of it is the gravitational pull of the moon and earth along with a thousand other technical facts (that you are totally clueless of) makes your solution impossible. By the time you reached the original position, it's been long gone and now your momentum makes it impossible to get back. Meanwhile, your compititor is using all the technical knowledge and facts to plan his trip and his actually works because he hits the moon. But you sit there heading into deep space and complain that you didn't like the way he did it and if he had only done what you said it would have been better. He tries to point out why his plan worked, but you don't listen to that and continue to claim your plan was better, yet do not have the technical knowledge or the desire to be educated about said knowledge to give your argument some credibility.

The same is true of successful movie making. You think it is sooooo easy to do when you make silly statements about changes that you know for sure would have worked. That is total hogwash.

If you really feel that those changes would have made it a better movie for you and those like you, then say so, and stop claiming that everyone else (the majority) are somehow flawed because they liked this movie as it is.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
As usual, F.H., you don't read (at least with comprehension) what has been posted and if you bother to do so, you don't respond to the post but to some vague understanding you seem to have of it. When I spoke of a culture that adores violence, you interpreted that to mean that ancient war was just as bloody as modern war. Well, to a certain extent that is true. Killing is killing, albeit on a smaller scale and with more primitive weapons. But that isn't the point I was making! I was speaking of the fact that we have made violence - real and contrived, physical and emotional - into a spectator sport. Not since the Romans sat around watching gladiators kill each other and Christians being fed to the lions has a culture gloried in gore as we do today. And therefore I maintain my contention that "popularity" does not necessarily equate with excellence - morally, artistically or any other way.

Oh, I heard you, and you can try to hide behind your rhetoric explaining what you said. My reference to violence was stripping away your facade and getting to what you are really saying. It was, in reality, just another backdoor insult of those who enjoyed the movie and don't hold your view.

You cannot claim that the movie was a success based on your personal view that a majority of society, revels in sex, violence, car chases and the like. That self same society is the most charitable. Using your logic, I can claim that that people really enjoyed this movie for the tender moments and the triump of good over evil because people as a whole people are kind and charitable.

The bottom line is that you prefer the book over the film and cannot stand the fact the the movie is making millions and people love it. A since you were so dissapointed in it because you are "enlightened", then those that don't hold your view must be your opposite. That is how you come off when you make those comments.
 
The films were egregiously unfaithful to the book, frequently for no defendable reason (despite the shrill defenses made). Most of Jackson changes had nothing whatsoever to do with his medium since he was able to be faithful to the book when he chose to be. Ergo, "faithfulness" to the book was not inherently "bad" nor were "Jacksonian inventions" inherently "good" - even from a cinematic perspective.

The quality of the book is not the matter under discussion. One cannot "elevate" Jackson by trashing Tolkien. If Tolkien's book was not worth filming, Jackson should have chosen another vehicle. The very fact that he chose as he does makes one suspect that even Jackson considered the book worthwhile - which again makes one wonder why he felt the need to deviate from it so often and frequently so egregiously.

The popularity of the films cannot be disputed. My point is that such popularity is not necessarily an indication of quality - or at least quality as it has been defined over the years not only in film but in other areas of the arts. Many extremely popular films are totally nihilistic and morally bankrupt while less heralded offerings may be quite worthwhile. Again, these are subjective matters which cannot be debated since there is no "right" or "wrong", only matters of individual taste.

And as it is a matter of "taste", then comments about the state of the culture matter very much since that condition reflects what must be considered the "tastes" of a majority of the people within the culture. Therefore, if most people today enjoy "reality TV" of the Jerry Springer/COPS/Survivor type and entertainment immersed in gratuitous sex, violence and gore, then you cannot say that this fact is irrelevant to the "popularity" of any film. Given Jackson's past films and the audiences for which he intended them, one has to wonder if much of what he did with LOTR was the result of those past efforts. We will probably never know, but I for one would not be surprised if that were the case.

I know that many on this forum enjoy these films for those efforts by Jackson that are universally considered to have been well done. They are willing to accept what they like and overlook the rest which is probably what we all do with most films since very few "classic gems" of the cinema are without their weak points. Therefore, I do not say that everyone who likes the films is into "mindless violence". I merely point out that had these films been made in, say, the 1950s perhaps Mr. Jackson might have felt less constrained about including more lower-keyed but essential character development and less c.g. battle scenes. But, of course, that we'll never know.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
He tries to point out why his plan worked, but you don't listen to that and continue to claim your plan was better, yet do not have the technical knowledge or the desire to be educated about said knowledge to give your argument some credibility.
We have been told that this "technical knowledge" made it necessary to replace Glorfindel with another character. Bakshi and PJ both did this, so we can take it there is some truth in the claim.
I have seen no other example of an explanation being offered of the technical reasons being the explanation of any other change.
What technical reasons are there for the complete change in the appearance of Bree, for the emphasis on the humorous sides of Merry, Pippin, and Gimli, to the exclusion of all other aspects of their characters, for any of the instances of giving dialogue from one book character to a different film one, for sometimes leaving Tolkien's words intact and at other times changing them to or replacing them with words in a modern anachronistic idiom?
Until we see some specific examples to support this claim, of cinematographic necessity, then the changes will remain credited simply to PJ's personal likes and dislikes.
 
;)
Aldanil said:
Screenwriting is always the most important element.
Now, there's a point that this cinematically uneducated critic can understand, about the intricate technical process that is involved in the making of a cinema film.
Can someone tell us the qualifications and experience of each of the screenwriters chosen for this massive and very expensive enterprise?
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
The films were egregiously unfaithful to the book, frequently for no defendable reason (despite the shrill defenses made). Most of Jackson changes had nothing whatsoever to do with his medium since he was able to be faithful to the book when he chose to be. Ergo, "faithfulness" to the book was not inherently "bad" nor were "Jacksonian inventions" inherently "good" - even from a cinematic perspective.

Those are assumptions based on wishful thinking. You assume that every part of tolkiens book could have been filmed faithfully and still made an enjoyable movie that needed to crack a 300 million dollar nut. You have no credible experience or data to back that up and as a matter of fact what he did accomplished makes your assertion less likely because blockbuster movies are not a common occurance.

Mrs. Maggott said:
The quality of the book is not the matter under discussion. One cannot "elevate" Jackson by trashing Tolkien. If Tolkien's book was not worth filming, Jackson should have chosen another vehicle. The very fact that he chose as he does makes one suspect that even Jackson considered the book worthwhile - which again makes one wonder why he felt the need to deviate from it so often and frequently so egregiously.

I wasn't trying to elevate PJ, I was pointing out the weaknesses in jrr's work in an attempt to illustrate the differences in a way that reflected reality.

Mrs. Maggott said:
these are subjective matters which cannot be debated since there is no "right" or "wrong", only matters of individual taste.

You do include your opinion in that too I hope.

Mrs. Maggott said:
Therefore, if most people today enjoy "reality TV" of the Jerry Springer/COPS/Survivor type and entertainment immersed in gratuitous sex, violence and gore,

With the amount of choices available on cable etc, you cannot make that claim. Surely certian people enjoy those shows, but there is no data to suggest that they are universally enjoyed by the same audience that sees the movie. It is very possible that the silent majority has been waiting for a feel good film that doesn't glorify behavior them deem immoral etc and are rewarding new line for giving them a good movie. I would suggest that people who like springer would NOT go see this movie because arwen breasts were not shown. I can see the segment of people that like survivor shows would not like this movie because the worst, sneakiest, low-life did not win in the end.

Mrs. Maggott said:
I know that many on this forum enjoy these films for those efforts by Jackson that are universally considered to have been well done. They are willing to accept what they like and overlook the rest which is probably what we all do with most films since very few "classic gems" of the cinema are without their weak points. Therefore, I do not say that everyone who likes the films is into "mindless violence". I merely point out that had these films been made in, say, the 1950s perhaps Mr. Jackson might have felt less constrained about including more lower-keyed but essential character development and less c.g. battle scenes. But, of course, that we'll never know.

Mrs M, I can say that I totally agree with what you just said. It is perhapes sad that the new morality of the majority is less constrained and I blame that on the 60's and 70's. But without the upheaval of those years, many, many improvements that came from it would not have happened either.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
Those are assumptions based on wishful thinking. You assume that every part of tolkiens book could have been filmed faithfully....
I was pointing out the weaknesses in jrr's work....
....the 60's and 70's. But without the upheaval of those years, many, many improvements that came from it would not have happened either.
Yes, I know that was to Mrs M! :)

Neither Mrs M, nor anyone, assumes that "every part of tolkiens book could have been filmed faithfully" - that claim, against
Mrs M, and against many, was threadbare when it was first made, and ought to be thrown away now as completely worn out.
The points being made are that PJ managed reasonably well to include many parts of T's work without substantially changing them, and that a man of his skill and talents ( :cool: ) should have been able to find all the other parts he needed that could have been rendered equally well and equally without changes. "We" ask the question: what is so different about the parts that he changed that makes them impossible to adapt without change, compared with the parts that did not change. You may tell us that the answer is too cinematically technical, too complex for us mere amateurs to understand - but we wish you'd give it a try!

You didn't point out, specifically, those weaknesses; you claimed they existed. We are still waiting for one, even two, of them to be pointed out, specifically.

I agree with your thoughts on the 60s and 70s, but would be interested to hear one, even two, specific instances of improvements which would not have happened without the special features which characterise that period, things which would not have happened simply by the passage of time.
 
aragil said:
I believe that Merry and Pippin were spot-on in FotR, and I'd love to discuss it in a characterization thread....
Gimli....his 'counting game' with Legolas that, while amusing, also come from the books.
I don't understand the complaints about Denethor- certainly in the TT EE his material seems drawn directly from the book.
M&P....I think their characterizations were closer to the book than Saruman's!
Gimli has rather distracted me, but I will get back to M&P eventually, here, and also in your characterisation thread.
As you long as you mean the counting game while the battle was on, and as long as I can look away when G makes a special effort to catch up by hitting someone right between the legs - another of PJ's dark corners at work there, I suspect - I agree.
The effect is ruined later by the really black corner of PJ's mind that forces J R-D to play with the dead orc's corpse and talk about his nervous system while completing his tally - to 43, of course, Tolkien's 42 being woefully inadequate.
Is Denethor's total aversion to Faramir really in the book?
Yes, back to M&P, later. :eek:
 
joxy said:
Yes, I know that was to Mrs M! :)

Neither Mrs M, nor anyone, assumes that "every part of tolkiens book could have been filmed faithfully" - that claim, against
Mrs M, and against many, was threadbare when it was first made, and ought to be thrown away now as completely worn out.

(You continue to speak for MM...why is that? She thinks that because one part was filmed faithfully, that it is justification for the parts that bother her and my dear joxy, she is bothered by every change from the book concerning characters.)

My next response is to you alone. I suggest you quit complaining about all the changes from the book and stop using the faithfully shot scenes as "evidence" that all changed scenes could have been shot according to the book.

joxy said:
The points being made are that PJ managed reasonably well to include many parts of T's work without substantially changing them, and that a man of his skill and talents ( :cool: ) should have been able to find all the other parts he needed that could have been rendered equally well and equally without changes.

See? You're doing it again.

joxy said:
"We" ask the question: what is so different about the parts that he changed that makes them impossible to adapt without change, compared with the parts that did not change. You may tell us that the answer is too cinematically technical, too complex for us mere amateurs to understand - but we wish you'd give it a try!

I have and you do not accept them. My suggestion is that you ask PJ for the difinitive answer since he is the professional.

joxy said:
You didn't point out, specifically, those weaknesses; you claimed they existed. We are still waiting for one, even two, of them to be pointed out, specifically.

Yes, I have. For starters, Arragorns character is too fairytale-like for a realistic film. To add the required depth to make his character believable would require another three hour film. You will probably, just to disagree, dispute that. You always do, yet you have no training in film making. (I can lead the horse to water but I can't make him drink.) I suggest you enrole in film making 101 and see for yourself or quit trying to pass off your opinion as factually achievable.

joxy said:
I agree with your thoughts on the 60s and 70s, but would be interested to hear one, even two, specific instances of improvements which would not have happened without the special features which characterise that period, things which would not have happened simply by the passage of time.

Gay rights. Womans liberation. Religious frredom. Rights for the Handicapped. Enviromental issues. Voting rights.
We have no way of knowing if or when any of those things would have happened without that cultural revolution, but it sure did not exist before it.

Bad things that are a result......sexual promiscuity, drug abuse, religious apathy, political upheaval (assinations and the like) on top of the list that MM had. (even though a lot of her list already existed, but it was hidden and we were not exposed to it daily. Interesting thing...in the old west...hangings were seen by the general public, but now they are not. I think movies like PJ's LoTR is the closest we get to seeing baddies get their come uppins)

Please, lets end this 60's discussion before we go spinning of into left field. I made that as a passing remark and did not intend it to dominate the thread.

Thanx
 
About Mrs M: You keep telling her what she "assumes" and what she "thinks". I can see, and I am sure many others can see,
that she has said nothing to justify you reading these things into her mind. You may not believe her when she tells you that you are wrong about her; I try to add a little weight to that, in the hope of persuading you to read again what she actually says.

About unchanged scenes making it difficult to understand why other scenes have to be changed: This is more of a question -
see posting #429 - than a complaint, or a statement of fact, from me. You say you have answered the question; I haven't seen such an answer, and I invite you to repeat it, rather than making the somewhat impractical suggestion of consulting Mr J.

About "weaknesses" in the books: Your reply deals mainly with the films! You say Aragorn is too "fairy-like", "for a film"! I don't know what "fairy-like" means, but the question here is how he, or anyone or anything else, is a "weakness" within the books.

About good coming out of the 60s and 70s: I've a feeling that most of those valuable improvements had their base in the 50s and were already in unstoppable progress. The cultural upheaval, and the vast expansion of the "media", obviously sped them on their way, but the extent of that is now becoming more questionable. I don't know how the reference to the old west comes into this -perhaps you'd explain. I take your point though about "spinning off into left field", even though that particular game is reserved here for the infants' schools!
 
joxy said:
About Mrs M: You keep telling her what she "assumes" and what she "thinks". I can see, and I am sure many others can see,
that she has said nothing to justify you reading these things into her mind. You may not believe her when she tells you that you are wrong about her; I try to add a little weight to that, in the hope of persuading you to read again what she actually says.

You cannot clarify what she means unless you are actually her. I am referring to MY experiences with MM and you are not there for every post that I am using to base my answers to her from. AND when I answer you, after you lump others in with your opinion, they start posting stuff like "I never said that", etc. You need to quit speaking for others and limit your responses to what you think and leave other persons names etc out of it. If what others say applies to you also, then couch your response as it applies to you. You guys aren't joined at the hip are you? I mean she's in Long Island and you're in the UK. That'd be a hellva trick.

joxy said:
About unchanged scenes making it difficult to understand why other scenes have to be changed: This is more of a question,
than a complaint, or a statement of fact, from me. You say you have answered the question; I haven't seen such an answer,
and I invite you to repeat it, rather than making the somewhat impractical suggestion of consulting Mr J.

I'm not going through this with you again. The last time I did, you said you would check out the dvd and then you dropped it. Don't ask if you aren't going to finish it...and cetainly don't give me a ration of crap and then forget to admit you were in error when it is proven that you were.

joxy said:
About "weaknesses" in the books: Your response deals mainly with the films! You say Aragorn is too "fairy-like", "for a film"! I don't know what you mean by "fairy-like"

Fairytale-like is what I said. Unrealistic. Not acting like a real king would.

joxy said:
but the question here is how he, or anyone or anything else, is "weak" within the book.

Again, this is not the book thread. Arragorns character is unsuitable for film as he was written by jrr. In that sense jrr's work is weak. I use that argument because you continue to claim jrr's work, as written, was suitable as a screenplay. I know you never used those words, but when you claim PJ could have used arragorn the way jrr did, you are in essence saying exactly that.
 
joxy said:
We have been told that this "technical knowledge" made it necessary to replace Glorfindel with another character. Bakshi and PJ both did this, so we can take it there is some truth in the claim.
I have seen no other example of an explanation being offered of the technical reasons being the explanation of any other change.
What technical reasons are there for the complete change in the appearance of Bree, for the emphasis on the humorous sides of Merry, Pippin, and Gimli, to the exclusion of all other aspects of their characters, for any of the instances of giving dialogue from one book character to a different film one, for sometimes leaving Tolkien's words intact and at other times changing them to or replacing them with words in a modern anachronistic idiom?
Until we see some specific examples to support this claim, of cinematographic necessity, then the changes will remain credited simply to PJ's personal likes and dislikes.

Have the others anointed you their spokesperson? Whats with all this "we" crap?

I already explained bree. And Gimli. And several other points and you continue to reject them out of hand. So, tell me, why should bother? You are not listening and you have no skills to justify not listening.

So, from now on when you ask a question like that my only answer to you will be....

"It obviously worked because people like it"

Of course you will then attack the caliber of person who liked it. (again, with no hard provable data to back it up)

That is the exact vicious circle this discussion has been on since the movie came out.
 
Morgraphy posted:
Aragorn, a trained Ranger and Numenorean Royalty, with nine Nazgul within earshot, in an age where swords were a necessary and widespread tool of society. I am sure Aragorn would have reacted quite differently than "a friend."
Anyone who uses swords or knives in any culture first learns to use them carefully and not wave them about randomly and not to use them jokingly, e.g. don’t run with pointed scissors.
Also, the flat of a blade is not exceedingly sharp, and direct contact with a sharp blade will not lacerate the skin without considerable force. Boromir is cut because he runs his finger along the blade.
Arwen has the point of the blade against Aragorn’s throat, not the flat. Try it with the point of a knife if you wish.

Knives are a necessary and widespread tool today. Movie-Arwen’s behavior whether with knife or sword is indefensible in any period. It would be equally indefensible with a gun. “Oops! I tripped and it went off!”

Foe-hammer posted:
Your statement pre-supposes that YOU (and those like you) are they only ones capable of telling if a roof leaks. I'm here to tell you that most people can tell if a roof leaks, that would be a MAJORITY OF PEOPLE. A majority of people like the movies, as is, and do not view them as you do. Your opinion about this movie is OUTSIDE the majority. So, we are not talking about something as simple as a leak in a roof. Making a successful movie is not as easy as making a roof that doesn't leak.
Again, argumentum ad populum is a fallacy Foehammer. Majority doen’t rule in taste, or in science, or in historical beliefs. Search out argumentum ad populum on a web search engine. It can only makes sense as a subsidiary argument to indicate that a position supported by many cannot be disregarded entirely.

I provided several roof-leaks in the films. So have others. You could try to deny them by showing they are not roof-leaks. But insisting that only people who have studied architecture can recognize roof-leaks is silly. Even many of those who like the films may recognize some of the flaws.

When Sam lies to about Boromir’s death and Faramir doesn’t call him out on it something has slipped badly in the scripting. No matter how often you attempt your argumentum ad populum the films themselves confute you on many issues.
The way I see your argument about changes that positively, 100%, for sure would have made it a better movie for everyone, is more along the lines of a compition to get to the moon. You figure all you have to do is take aim and fire and you'll hit it. The truth of it is the gravitational pull of the moon and earth along with a thousand other technical facts (that you are totally clueless of) makes your solution impossible. By the time you reached the original position, it's been long gone and now your momentum makes it impossible to get back. Meanwhile, your compititor is using all the technical knowledge and facts to plan his trip and his actually works because he hits the moon. But you sit there heading into deep space and complain that you didn't like the way he did it and if he had only done what you said it would have been better. He tries to point out why his plan worked, but you don't listen to that and continue to claim your plan was better, yet do not have the technical knowledge or the desire to be educated about said knowledge to give your argument some credibility.
You are raving. What does this moving target stand for in anything I’ve said?

You claimed Arwen’s joke with the sword is good film because it reveals character. What kind of character does it reveal? No answer of course, other than pointing at the moon!

I have asked you to educate by explaining why following the books more faithfully would have necessarily have made Jackson’s films more like Labyrinth. You seem unable to do so.
If you really feel that those changes would have made it a better movie for you and those like you, then say so, and stop claiming that everyone else (the majority) are somehow flawed because they liked this movie as it is.
More of the argument ad populum fallacy: many others like something or believe something therefore everyone should like it or believe it.

And an argument that the majority of people who like the film like the film demonstrates nothing.

Majority doesn’t much enter into convincing anyone on asethetics, other than to consider an argument or viewpoint.
It is very possible that the silent majority has been waiting for a feel good film that doesn't glorify behavior them deem immoral etc and are rewarding new line for giving them a good movie. I would suggest that people who like springer would NOT go see this movie because arwen breasts were not shown. I can see the segment of people that like survivor shows would not like this movie because the worst, sneakiest, low-life did not win in the end.
Now we see you arguing that you, yourself, are quite at liberty to dislike something many others like.

Of course I can take your argument to mean that there is a silent majority who likes Jackson’s films for moral reasons despite the flaws found. I don’t think you mean that. But silent majorities are rather imaginary things, arguments from silence.
For starters, Arragorns character is too fairytale-like for a realistic film.
Fairytale-like is what I said. Unrealistic. Not acting like a real king would.
Aragorn acts like no real king I am familiar with in either book or film

He is not a king for most of the story. So how can he act like one? But Aragorn in both film and book is as honest and self-sacrificing and conscientious and faithful a person as it is possible to be for a warrior-type (save that Jackson’s bad plotting makes movie-Aragorn advise Théoden unwisely). That is certainly not like most historical kings.

In the film Aragorn is more self-doubting. That doesn’t seem to me particularly more like a real king. Movie-Aragorn is also less ambitious. That doesn’t seem to me particularly more like a real king.

But what has any of this to do with realism? In fact there have been historical kings who doubted themselves and historical kings who were not ambitious.

A case can be made that movie-Aragorn is far more saintly than book-Aragorn. Movie-Aragon is unsure of his worth. Movie-Aragorn has no desire for power. Movie-Aragorn gives up Arwen for what he feels is her own good despite his deep love for her (shades of Rick and Ilsa in Casablanca). Is that what you mean by good film? But in Casablanca we saw the whole story. Showing the break-up in a flashback long after it happened and having it make no difference to the story isn’t especially good story invention.

So explain what you mean.

Jackson’s love story of Aragorn and Arwen is rather tacky on the whole.
(Aragorn is floating down the river. He washes up on a rocky shore. Scene fades to Arwen lying on a bed. Fades back to Aragorn on the shore. Arwen bends over his face and kisses him softly.)

Arwen: (voiceover) May the grace of the Valar protect you.

(She fades away. Aragorn lies on the shore. Brego comes up and nuzzles him. He turns him onto his back.)
Honestly! Not great cinema. Or is this supposed to comedy? If so, it is not great comedy.

Foe-hammer posted:
I already explained bree. And Gimli. And several other points and you continue to reject them out of hand.
Not out of hand if explanations were given.

I personally have no great problem with Bree. However I don’t see that it had to be changed. I don’t accept the idea that there is only one possible way to adapt The Lord of the Rings and that Jackson’s way must be the best. Gimli sticks in my craw for example, just as Nigel Bruce’s Dr. Watson was annoying to many and possibly most Sherlock Holmes fans in the older films. Newer adaptations of the tales show unequivocably that Watson didn’t have to be made into dumbed-down comic relief in films for the results to be popular.

Jackson created a schlock one-dimensional comic relief sidekick because that’s an easier and cheaper way to get laughs than to use comedy deriving from a fuller character. Yes Gimli is funny in that cheap sort of way. But the film is accordingly cheapened by it.
So, tell me, why should bother? You are not listening and you have no skills to justify not listening.
Then don’t bother. Continuous name-calling and insistance that majority rules (except in areas where you don’t agree with popular taste) are not cogent arguments.
So, from now on when you ask a question like that my only answer to you will be....

"It obviously worked because people like it"
Then one can equally respond that something didn’t work because people don’t like it. That is a tautolgy in matters of aesthetics.

And counting heads to find out how many people liked or disliked something doesn’t work in aesthetics or science or history or in many other areas. It only shows current opinion which people may change when they examine more closely.

Britney Spear’s singing obviously works because people like it. It obviously dosn’t work because people don’t like it.

More honest is to say: “It works because I like it!” or “It works because I don’t like it!”
Of course you will then attack the caliber of person who liked it. (again, with no hard provable data to back it up)
You’ve been attacking the caliber of everyone who disagrees with you far more than you’ve been attacked personally.

You attacked the caliber of people who like reality television with no hard data to back you up. What’s the difference?
 
Ol'gaffer said:
Those kind of statements are things that start arguments.

Who is to say that people who enjoy both the movies and the books as equal works of art is not a 'true' Tolkien fan? Not you or I can say that.

So please, refrain from statements like that in the future.

I apologize for this mistake of meaning, but I meant rather Tolkien "Purists" by that. I'm sorry for the confusion, poor choice of words on my part.
 
There's too much around here to fully address, but I thought I'd drop my opinion on a matter or two:

jallan said:
When Sam lies to about Boromir’s death and Faramir doesn’t call him out on it something has slipped badly in the scripting.
I don't agree that this was a lie, and I gave you my reasons before without a response (that I recall). There is no reason to assume that Sam's reference is a literal one. He never says "The Ring killed Boromir" (one would assume by swallowing it). He said (among other things) that the Ring drove Boromir mad (not a lie). Boromir then (out of a sense of regret and seeking redemption) died defending the Hobbits- a relatively hopeless task that he probably would not have attempted had he not been racked by guilt for his own attack on Frodo and subsequent curse upon all halflings. If he had not first been driven mad by the Ring, he would not later have sacrificed his life in trying to save others. I thought this was the generally accepted reading of the book- that Boromir's madness brought around his own demise.


For joxy- the collective film writers' credits:
Fran Walsh
Phillipa Boyens (also she is a noted fan of the Book that reads it yearly)
Peter Jackson
Stephen Sinclair (Two Towers only)
 
Great post jallan. You made it quite plain the absurdity of the 'majority' argument that Foe-Hammer futilely continues to fall back upon.


aragil said:
For joxy- the collective film writers' credits:
Fran Walsh
Phillipa Boyens (also she is a noted fan of the Book that reads it yearly)
Peter Jackson
Stephen Sinclair (Two Towers only)
I don't know why you added that little addition of reading Tolkien to Phillipa Boyens' name. From watching the extras on the TTT EE, I thought she was the bane of Tolkien based on her comments and she might as well have been reading another book because LoTR didn't help her in making this movie. The more I watched it the more I felt she had her own agenda more so then PJ when it came to writing the script. Justifications up the wazoo why characters and scenes needed to be changed. She basically admitted to deviating from the book and then being stuck in the writing of scenes and making it up as they went along. Not great screenwriting abilities IMO.
 

Today's events

Back
Top