jallan
Member
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2003
- Messages
- 630
Actually their aristic worth is probably quite a bit higher than the Hollywood norm. But remember Stugeonās Law: ninety percent of everything is crap.
Today the average Hollywood picture goes to DVD immediately and most gradually drift into oblivion except for people interested in a particular actor or director or producer or camerman films in a particular era or tradition.
To say only that something is better than normal Hollywood output is damning with very faint praise, especially with films based on a story already so cinematic as was The Lord of the Rings.
I think the films will be reasonably lasting as spectacle pictures and because of of some very fine acting and some excellent pieces of cinematography and special effect and because much of the original tale does come through. I really donāt think anyone denies that these films are better than average Hollywood.
But if I can see a better visualization in my mind, why should I want to see them again? That I am more aware of their material makes them worse to me than they otherwise would be, just as if I read an historical novel covering an era I know well, I may find it worse because of errors than I would find for a far more inaccurate historical novel in a period I donāt know at all.
Iām not talking about Jacksonās changing things especially, rather that he loses the vision of the original and what he substitutes is mostly (but not always!) less. Yes, sometimes he is sooo good! But then come the Gimli jokes or a stupid oliphaunt Harryhausen tribute.
I really donāt care what film professionals in particular might have to say about such things. Iāve seen professional critics and commentators (on books and film) rave over things I donāt like and ignore much that I think excellent, not necessarily because they are bad commentators, but because they are appreciating or not appreciating particular works in a different way than I am. And the fault, as much as there is fault, may be mine.
And Iāve even seen commentators rave over things I like and know that they are talking nonsense, e.g. reading into Tolkienās work meanings that just arenāt there.
Thatās how it works.
Thatās the problem when one attempts to cite supposed experts as proof of oneās position. There are often other experts of opposite opinion. So one eventually has to start arguing the details of the work instead.
Greenwood seems now to insist that everyone has to be what he calls normal response. Eccch! That weak defense again. Normal people like it therefore it must be excellent from all viewpoints: the Britney Spears argument, the lowest common denominator argument.
In fact the films are in many ways superior to lowest common denominator material and also quite accessible. So it is not surprising they are a popular success. But their flaws remain along with their excellences and all the whining in the world about their popularity wonāt make the flaws go away for those who see them and are bothered by them.
For example, the sword fighting remains fake Hollywood sword and shield sword fighting, probably good enough if you like that sort of thing, just as wire stunts in phony martial arts films are great fun if you like that kind of amusing schlock. But it remains amusing schlock.
Today the average Hollywood picture goes to DVD immediately and most gradually drift into oblivion except for people interested in a particular actor or director or producer or camerman films in a particular era or tradition.
To say only that something is better than normal Hollywood output is damning with very faint praise, especially with films based on a story already so cinematic as was The Lord of the Rings.
I think the films will be reasonably lasting as spectacle pictures and because of of some very fine acting and some excellent pieces of cinematography and special effect and because much of the original tale does come through. I really donāt think anyone denies that these films are better than average Hollywood.
But if I can see a better visualization in my mind, why should I want to see them again? That I am more aware of their material makes them worse to me than they otherwise would be, just as if I read an historical novel covering an era I know well, I may find it worse because of errors than I would find for a far more inaccurate historical novel in a period I donāt know at all.
Iām not talking about Jacksonās changing things especially, rather that he loses the vision of the original and what he substitutes is mostly (but not always!) less. Yes, sometimes he is sooo good! But then come the Gimli jokes or a stupid oliphaunt Harryhausen tribute.
I really donāt care what film professionals in particular might have to say about such things. Iāve seen professional critics and commentators (on books and film) rave over things I donāt like and ignore much that I think excellent, not necessarily because they are bad commentators, but because they are appreciating or not appreciating particular works in a different way than I am. And the fault, as much as there is fault, may be mine.
And Iāve even seen commentators rave over things I like and know that they are talking nonsense, e.g. reading into Tolkienās work meanings that just arenāt there.
Thatās how it works.
Well Greenwood seems to stress elsewhere that heās been a fan of Tolkien for over forty years as though that gives credibility to his statements. But Christopher Tolkien has almost everyone beat in terms of appreciation for his fatherās writing and for Tolkien scholarship. Christopher Tolkien felt that the films should not have been made at all.rs691919 said:I actually intended this question to be broader; that is, leave aside for a moment the discussion about the movies (and leave aside the question of being paid, which was poor wording on my part). Does my opinion on Tolkien therefore carry more weight than yours, because I have lectured on him off and on for the last four years?
Thatās the problem when one attempts to cite supposed experts as proof of oneās position. There are often other experts of opposite opinion. So one eventually has to start arguing the details of the work instead.
Greenwood seems now to insist that everyone has to be what he calls normal response. Eccch! That weak defense again. Normal people like it therefore it must be excellent from all viewpoints: the Britney Spears argument, the lowest common denominator argument.
In fact the films are in many ways superior to lowest common denominator material and also quite accessible. So it is not surprising they are a popular success. But their flaws remain along with their excellences and all the whining in the world about their popularity wonāt make the flaws go away for those who see them and are bothered by them.
For example, the sword fighting remains fake Hollywood sword and shield sword fighting, probably good enough if you like that sort of thing, just as wire stunts in phony martial arts films are great fun if you like that kind of amusing schlock. But it remains amusing schlock.
