• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

joxy said:
Isn't that near enough to saying flat out that I haven't seen ROTK, for anyone to get the implication without just "suspecting" it?!
Are you saying that the "factual reports that others have given here" are all biased, that I cannot rely on those others to have been truthful, and, therefore, that any opinions I reach on the basis of those reports are "valueless"?
But you did not say "flat out" you haven't seen it. Perhaps you had and your statement was merely unclear and I misread it. You still haven't said "flat out" you haven't seen it, though the implication is certainly much clearer now. As for the "factual reports", you don't know how "factual" any report is or whether it has been tinted by bias. We are not talking about a criminal case here where a jury must rely on the accounts of witnesses who actually saw the crime. (Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable anyway.) We are talking about a film where you can easily determine the "facts" by viewing it yourself. How can you possibly say you like somethings and dislike somethings (as you do endlessly say) when you haven't seen the film? How can you possibly know whether the film falls short of, meets, or exceeds any norm (be the norm yours, rss691919's or anyone's) if you haven't seen it. I said: "I consider that opinion to have no foundation other than bias and therefore valueless." I am free to assign any value or merit to your opinion that I choose. Based on the evident fact that you haven't seen ROTK, I consider any opinions you have on it valuelesss. The fact that you choose to comment on it at all and primarily in a negative way leads me to place very little value on your opinion of the two films you have seen.

joxy said:
That's telling you that I do NOT dislike the films, and therefore your point about me, and anyone with similar opinions to mine, wasting their money, is irrelevant.
I said nothing about you or anyone with similar opinions to you wasting their money. You stated:
joxy said:
nor is it relevant if they choose to see them several times.
In my experience, people rarely voluntarily, repeatedly, spend money on things they dislike. I asked if in your experience they do. If you are upset about my quip about the English, I am sorry, it was not meant to be insulting, merely humorous -- I am a quarter English myself. As for your dislike of the films, it seems quite apparent to someone who reads more than a handful of your posts. You constantly say you like somethings about the films and dislike others, but you are rarely specific about any "likes". On the other hand you go on seemingly endlessly, on many different threads, about a few barrels that have no relevance whatsoever to the story. You repeatedly cite what your refer to as "instances" of incompetence by Jackson, et al. I have also cited instances when you referred to Jackson as a "porn artist" and a "con artist". Your continual claims not to dislike the films in the face of your evident attitude to the contrary seem specious at best.
 
Last edited:
Sôval Phârë said:
I apologize for this intrusion, but I've just got to say a word or two about "hubris."

What does Greek civilization have to do with this? How the ancient Greeks may have used "hubris" is completely irrelevant to its use in a modern conversation between English speakers, as it has developed a meaning of its own in English. And for that, dictionary.com should suffice. :)

I hardly think you would expect people today to conform to the original meaning of "weird," which was "fate."

The only language which does not change and evolve is a dead one.

Good point. Wish I had thought of it instead of spending time looking up the Encyclopedia Britannica. :( ;)
 
Greenwood said:
Perhaps you would care to enlighten us all as to your defintions of these words in regard to films instead of merely protesting you are misunderstood.

I don't actually claim, in my humble opinion, that you misunderstand. Rather, you have chosen to emphasize the word which suits your purpose, in my opinion. In my opinion, I have endeavored to clarify the meaning of my original statement, and these attempts have been rebuffed as revisions, in my humble opinion.

Rather, these words attempt to get at a concept, one which is somewhat ethereal (and utterly subjective): namely how "good" these movies are in comparison to others of the genre. Certainly, as I have admitted, they are head and shoulders above such garbage as The Frighteners; however, when compared to others, I find that quality of sameness which I have previously discussed.

Greenwood said:
The professional reception of any movie gives insight into how "Hollywood" views the films and how "Hollywood" consider's they compare to the norm.

True, but it does not give any insight into the movies themselves. And ultimately, I really don't care about what Hollywood thinks about itself or its output.

Greenwood said:
Most of us do not consider our opinions equivalent to Truth. We are all presenting our views of some films. Why is it so important to present those views as "persuasive writing" unless the aim is to prove one's personal view is correct and everyone else is wrong? Stating one's personal views with Olympian authority as if they are Truth actually diminshes the possibility those views will receive any serious consideration from others with different views. (IMHO ;) ) The views merely come off as arrogant and hinder any real discussion.

Anyways, go back and look at the post: "My intention is not to mask my opinion as fact, but to state my opinion with the conviction of Truth." I don't have definite knowledge of the future, but I do state my opinions with the conviction of Truth; that is, I state them in the declarative, as do all who write persuasively (and most non-fiction writing is persuasive). If you consider that arrogant, that's your problem: it only hinders discussion because you allow it to bother you. Your own arrogance in belittling my use of English is not commented on...oh the hypocrisy! Your own opinions are quite clear, and no matter how many times you say the imbecilic words "in my humble opinion", you still believe yourself to be correct.

Greenwood said:
Actually it was the Random House Webster's and it did give hybris as the original spelling. Including that irrelevant fact would indeed have been pedantic as well as pompous. We can use the Encyclopedia Britannica if you would like

Ah, more models of scholarship! I suppose it's too much to ask for a more rigorous instruction (I'll get to Soval's quesion in a few moments)?

Greenwood said:
It is primarily a commercial venture. The word primarily is not equivalent to solely.

So, first it was a commercial venture, and therefore the way I view the Hollywood norm was incorrect and my statement thus unsupported. Now, Hollywood also measure itself in terms of artistic merit, and the oodles of praise heaped upon only the third installment of Jackson's "trilogy" are evidence that Hollywood loves the third movie (though it didn't love the first two quite as much). All of which--in my honest, humble, loving, friendly opinion--is totally irrelevant to the worth of the movies.

Incidentally, here's another quote from Albert Einstein: "Generations to come will scarce believe that such a man as this ever in flesh and blood walked upon this earth." Notice he didn't say, "in my humble opinon". Oh the hubris.

And do you know about whom he was speaking? The same man to whom the following quote has been attributed: "If you are a minority of one, the truth is the truth."
 
Sôval Phârë said:
What does Greek civilization have to do with this? How the ancient Greeks may have used "hubris" is completely irrelevant to its use in a modern conversation between English speakers, as it has developed a meaning of its own in English. And for that, dictionary.com should suffice. :)

It is relevant because I have been chastised as misusing the word "hubris" when I have used it in a similar sense to its original meaning. While I am cognisant of the way modern parlance has twisted its meaning, it originally applied to something much deeper than mere arrogance; it generally applied to abuse of power, a murderous act, thievery against someone on the part of someone who felt themselves above the rule of law (or the Gods).

And that is the meaning which I have known and learned, having been deeply immersed in my youth in the study of Greek and Roman civilization. So if you're going to challenge my use of the word, at least have the decency to understand the background of the concept, and at least do it with some decent grammar.
 
aragil said:
RotK has gotten more repeat views than most movies, so the assumption would be that it is more widely appreciated by the general audience than most movies.

And it is an assumption that is not neccesarily (though it is likely) true. If a small group of people went to the movie a whole bunch of times, that could get the grosses up without wide viewing or acceptance. We know there is a subset of people--paticularly within the teenage and early 20-something age groups--that have seen these movies many, many times in the theatre. So the box office dominance is not the truest measure of popularity. That is why I would love to see the how many individuals actually saw any particular movie (not just LoTR). Ultimately, however, I'm certain that these movies are more widely appreciated than most.
 
Greenwood said:
You still haven't said "flat out" you haven't seen it, though the implication is certainly much clearer now.
As for the "factual reports", you don't know how "factual" any report is or whether it has been tinted by bias.
How can you possibly say you like somethings and dislike somethings (as you do endlessly say) when you haven't seen the film?
Based on the evident fact that you haven't seen ROTK, I consider any opinions you have on it valuelesss.


I said nothing about you or anyone with similar opinions to you wasting their money.
**As for your dislike of the films, it seems quite apparent to someone who reads more than a handful of your posts. You constantly say you like somethings about the films and dislike others**, but you are rarely specific about any "likes".
You repeatedly cite what your refer to as "instances" of incompetence by Jackson, et al.
I have also cited instances when you referred to Jackson as a "porn artist" and a "con artist".
Your continual claims not to dislike the films in the face of your evident attitude to the contrary seem specious at best.
Most people around here are pretty good at reading implications into others' posts - though they sometimes read erroneous ones of course - so I was pretty sure that you would have taken that implication, which, as I said, could scarcely have been clearer - and was as clear then, as it is now.
I'm more generous to fellow-posters than you appear to be. When someone here reports a specific factual point about ROTK,
I see no reason to disbelieve it. I may then comment on it, though, as I said, I have actually done so only rarely - and, offhand,
I can't actually think of one specific instance of recently having commented on anything in ROTK.
So, I certainly don't say "endlessly" anything at all about ROTK.
Why are opinions automatically valueless if they depend on second-hand but factual reports?
And IF they are valueless, then are the reports they are based on, and the opinions of the reporters, also valueless?

You said:
<Do you mean that you have met lots of people who voluntarily and routinely pay money over and over again for something they dislike?>
OK, so that was a question, rather than a statement, but I think it was pretty relevant to my response about whether I, and others who share my opinion, waste their money by seeing the films several times.
I scarcely noticed your note about the English! :rolleyes:
You can't square liking something only in parts with not disliking it in is entirety? You consider that disliking part of something implies disliking the whole thing?
Those are my deductions from the combination of your two sentences that I've put between **.
To the last phrase of the second sentence I say: look around you; you'll find contributions from me to threads which have the sole intention of listing the best features of the films. You'll find me thoroughly enjoying some of Jackson's total inventions. When we're discussing the poorer parts of the films, there's not much point in my diverting to the better points in them - is there?
The "instances of incompetence" are plain for all to see. They have nothing to do with whether I like or dislike the films. I think they shouldn't be there, but I'm told that such things are common throughout the film industry, and they have no effect on my like or dislike of the totality of these films.
Those "artist" comments were some time ago; we've been through them before; they were a "bit of fun", like poor Gimli's gags.
"Specious" - misleadingly attractive; well, it's nice to know they're "attractive", anyway. :) You may find them difficult to believe, but they're still true. I get as many thrills and emotions out of these films as anyone here does. I'm very pleased to have ALL of those which are presently available on DVD; I'm delighted that the ROTK DVD is being released sooner than originally planned;
and I'm sure I shall cheer it, as well as occasionally cringe at it, just as I do, frequently, with its predecessors.
 
Last edited:
rs691919 said:
While I am cognisant of the way modern parlance has twisted its meaning,

"Twisted" strikes me as a rather loaded word. I personally prefer "adapted."

it originally applied to something much deeper than mere arrogance; it generally applied to abuse of power, a murderous act, thievery against someone on the part of someone who felt themselves above the rule of law (or the Gods).

If "hubris" was something which was committed against the gods, then it was bound to lose much of its original meaning when people stopped believing in the Greek pantheon.

And that is the meaning which I have known and learned, having been deeply immersed in my youth in the study of Greek and Roman civilization. So if you're going to challenge my use of the word, at least have the decency to understand the background of the concept, and at least do it with some decent grammar.

I certainly hope you're using "you" in a general sense here. I myself am a masochistic student of Greek, and while the amount of knowledge I currently have is small, the level of my respect and appreciation for such things may perhaps be on par with yours. So I say go ahead and use "hubris" in the classical sense if you like- just don't expect modern English speakers to always know what you're talking about. ;)
 
It wasn't; "you" and "one" are interchangeable in English, with the former as the more common usage. End of English lesson.
 
joxy said:
It wasn't; "you" and "one" are interchangeable in English, with the former as the more common usage. End of English lesson.

But "you" is also ambiguous; so if you want to give me a lesson on the proper usage of you, then I know where you can put it. Note that this is by no means an attack against you in particular, and if you perceive it as such then that is entirely your fault.
:p ;) :D
 
Logic Lesson:

If "you" and "one" are interchangeable in English,
then "you" = "one" and "one" = "you."

Which makes one, and this means one too, as opposed to two too, wonder. One being second person singular as well as second person plural, one would think that one ought to be first person ... but given two seconds, and the potential for a singular and a plural to make three ... just how does it all add up? :confused: :) :p

And somehow,

"You Ring to rule them all" just doesn't evoke the same sort of ... dare I say ... hubris.

* innocent look *
 
rs691919 said:
I don't actually claim, in my humble opinion, that you misunderstand. Rather, you have chosen to emphasize the word which suits your purpose, in my opinion. In my opinion, I have endeavored to clarify the meaning of my original statement, and these attempts have been rebuffed as revisions, in my humble opinion.

Rather, these words attempt to get at a concept, one which is somewhat ethereal (and utterly subjective): namely how "good" these movies are in comparison to others of the genre. Certainly, as I have admitted, they are head and shoulders above such garbage as The Frighteners; however, when compared to others, I find that quality of sameness which I have previously discussed.
Your style is much improved. I actually got a chuckle out of your post, but I think a middle ground is still possible. The word "opinion" can be overused you know. There are many ways to clearly express things as opinions without actually using the word. Let me give you an example. Going back to your original sentence that precipitated this dialogue:
rs691919 said:
It is particularly galling to me because all it would have taken was a little vision, some trust in the material, and some trust in the audience to make this movie (and these movies) something that transcends the Hollywood norm.
Consider the following alternative:
It is particularly galling to me because all it would have taken was a little vision, some trust in the material, and some trust in the audience to make this movie (and these movies) something that transcends what I consider the Hollywood norm.
You get to say the same thing without it coming across as a sweeping statement and the last several pages of debate could have been avoided.

rs691919 said:
Anyways, go back and look at the post: "My intention is not to mask my opinion as fact, but to state my opinion with the conviction of Truth." I don't have definite knowledge of the future, but I do state my opinions with the conviction of Truth; that is, I state them in the declarative, as do all who write persuasively (and most non-fiction writing is persuasive). If you consider that arrogant, that's your problem: it only hinders discussion because you allow it to bother you. Your own arrogance in belittling my use of English is not commented on...oh the hypocrisy! Your own opinions are quite clear, and no matter how many times you say the imbecilic words "in my humble opinion", you still believe yourself to be correct.
You seem to be getting a little testy there. I hardly find persuasive the arguments of anyone who links "my opinions" and "conviction of Truth" (captial T) in the same sentence. I doubt any others do either. I would also like to clue you in on another little Internet forum convention. The use of the acronym IMHO is usually meant to convey a certain amount of fun and sarcasm. I will return to English usage in a minute.

rs691919 said:
So, first it was a commercial venture, and therefore the way I view the Hollywood norm was incorrect and my statement thus unsupported.(emphasis added)
You see. You can write a forceful, persuasive, dare I say declarative, sentence that gets your point across and still makes it clear you are talking about your views and not others.

rs691919 said:
It is relevant because I have been chastised as misusing the word "hubris" when I have used it in a similar sense to its original meaning. While I am cognisant of the way modern parlance has twisted its meaning, it originally applied to something much deeper than mere arrogance; it generally applied to abuse of power, a murderous act, thievery against someone on the part of someone who felt themselves above the rule of law (or the Gods).

And that is the meaning which I have known and learned, having been deeply immersed in my youth in the study of Greek and Roman civilization. So if you're going to challenge my use of the word, at least have the decency to understand the background of the concept, and at least do it with some decent grammar.
I know this was directed at Sôval Phârë, but I must interjection a correction here. You were the one who challenged my use of the word "hubris". I used it according to standard, modern English usage and you implied I was incorrect. You say you are "cognizant of the way modern parlance has twisted its meaning". Why then, did you challenge my usage? (I was going to say that I was the first person to use the word "hubris" on this thread, but when I did a search I discovered it had been used by three others first. All in the same sense as I used it.)
 
Greenwood said:
I know this was directed at Sôval Phârë, but I must interjection a correction here. You were the one who challenged my use of the word "hubris". I used it according to standard, modern English usage and you implied I was incorrect. You say you are "cognizant of the way modern parlance has twisted its meaning". Why then, did you challenge my usage? (I was going to say that I was the first person to use the word "hubris" on this thread, but when I did a search I discovered it had been used by three others first. All in the same sense as I used it.)

Actually, under the clearly mistaken belief that you had more knowledge and understanding of the term "hubris," I merely asked the question: "Hubris against whom?" in response to your labelling of my posts as "hubris." I was curious as to what crime I had committed (and against whom) such that some postings on an internet forum coud be termed "hubris". From there, you posted your interpretation of the term, and then I posted mine. You went on to emphasize the difference between your interpretation and my own (post #680) and then finally to say that my interpretation constituted "misuse" (post #690). Again, I was in error to ask the question "Hubris against whom?" in the first place, for I assumed that your knowledge extended further than does that of Encyclopedia Britannica.
 
rs691919 said:
Actually, under the clearly mistaken belief that you had more knowledge and understanding of the term "hubris," I merely asked the question: "Hubris against whom?" in response to your labelling of my posts as "hubris." I was curious as to what crime I had committed (and against whom) such that some postings on an internet forum coud be termed "hubris". (emphasis added)
I might be devastated by your lofty condescension if the highlighted portion above did not show that after all this discussion you still don't understand what "hubris" refers to. To go to your definition:
rs691919 said:
it originally applied to something much deeper than mere arrogance; it generally applied to abuse of power, a murderous act, thievery against someone on the part of someone who felt themselves above the rule of law (or the Gods).
Of course, hubris was deeper than mere arrogance. What you still seem to fail to comprehend is that even under your definition, hubris is not something you do against someone. The act committed (abuse of power, murder, thievery, etc) is not hubris. The act (which was committed against somone) is merely a symptom that shows the person feels themselves above the law or the Gods. The Gods punished them for that feeling, their hubris, not for whatever act they committed. I believe another symptom of hubris is an inability to self diagnose it. :( ;)
 
Two points on English usage:

"One" is also the indefinite third personal singular, just to add to the confusion so wittily commented on by Soval and Incanus.

Britannica has been called into action for the dispute over the meaning and usage of "hubris". My computer version also confuses matters further by claiming that its definitions are simultaneously from "The New Oxford Dictionary of English" and "Merriam Webster's Collegiate Dictionary". It claims that hubris is "excessive pride towards or defiance of the gods". If you, or one, or we, can accept that definition, and allow substitution of something more secular, then hubris clearly can, in current usage, be directed to a grammatical indirect object in the form of a person.


btw: to Greenwood, in persuance of your disbelief in my claim not to dislike PJ's films: I just noticed, in a thread directly adjacent to this one, Powerful Moments, what amounts almost to a paean of praise - yes, I know the "of praise" is redundant! -from me about a scene in FOTR.
 
rs691919 said:
That is why I would love to see the how many individuals actually saw any particular movie (not just LoTR).
Of course, I don't think box office is an absolute barometer, just an indicator. Another indicator can be found at IMDB, where the trilogy as a whole not only has a lot of people (the majority of whom have probably seen the movie) trying to rank the movie, it also does fairly good in the ranking system.
 
Greenwood said:
I might be devastated by your lofty condescension if the highlighted portion above did not show that after all this discussion you still don't understand what "hubris" refers to. To go to your definition:Of course, hubris was deeper than mere arrogance. What you still seem to fail to comprehend is that even under your definition, hubris is not something you do against someone. The act committed (abuse of power, murder, thievery, etc) is not hubris. The act (which was committed against somone) is merely a symptom that shows the person feels themselves above the law or the Gods. The Gods punished them for that feeling, their hubris, not for whatever act they committed. I believe another symptom of hubris is an inability to self diagnose it. :( ;)

Do just this small thing for me, since you don't have the discipline to seek a source of scholarly information on the term: go to a dictionary of Ancient Greek (since you put so much stock in dictionaries), and look up hubris or hybris. Tell us what definitions you find there.

Again, I did not question your usage of the word, but mistakenly believed that you were using it to mean something more than arrogance.
 
rs691919 said:
Do just this small thing for me, since you don't have the discipline to seek a source of scholarly information on the term: go to a dictionary of Ancient Greek (since you put so much stock in dictionaries), and look up hubris or hybris. Tell us what definitions you find there.
If I get a chance I'll look. In my last post I used the definition you posted. I guess you are now saying it was incorrect. I used your definition since I assumed it was based on your extensive Greek reference library and would be more authoritative than anything I could quickly find.
 
aragil said:
Ignoring (as you conveniently do) the necessity for showing the ordering of the Rohirrim after they blow their horns..

I don't have the book handy, but my recollection is that the Rohirrim order their ranks before they blow their horns. The horns are blown only after they begin their charge. The attack is thus a total surprise to armies of Mordor, with the exception of the few Orcs who were manning the ruined Rammas. In the movie, the charge is not a surprise as the Orcs line up opposite them and pig-head has time to order his archers.


aragil said:
...there is still the fact that they arrive in the nick of time for those in the city, and they do manage to clear the gates of enemy forces, though they obviously do not clear out the enemies already within the city walls (what a trick that would be while on horseback).

Indeed, it would be a challenge for the horsemen to drive the Orcs out of the city, but the Orcs were not in the city in the book. Thus, the movie does not follow the book; in the book, of course, the Witch-King is wholly concentrating on the Gate and his confrontation with Gandalf; thus the charge of the Rohirrim takes him and his armies by surprise, and the Enemy does not enter the city--something which is symbolically as well as strategically important. So great were the efforts of Gandalf (and by proxy Iluvatar), that Theoden arrives just at the moment when things seem their worst--the nadir of the West's fortunes.


aragil said:
True, it does not clear out the troops who are actually in the first level of the city, but the implication (based on Pippin and Gandalf emerging from the scrape at the second gate) is that the Gondorians are able to hold out in the second level until the battle out on the fields of the Pelannor is won.

Why then, after saving Faramir from Denethor, do Gandalf and Pippin have their discussion about death if it's clear that the Rohirrim have saved the day and given them the ability to hold out? It appears that Jackson and his writers are trying, in this scene, to make this moment the one in which the West is at the nadir of its fortunes. Thus, Pippin and Gandalf discuss death (sort of) while on the battlefield, things seem hopeless as well.

But ultimately, the charge of the Rohirrim loses potency because of the lack of surprise and the lack of tension (in the form of the confrontation between Gandalf and the Witch-King) at that moment.
 

Today's events

Back
Top