ROTK Review
Visually - extremely impressive
Special Effects - extremely impressive
Music Score - Good
Acting - Very Good
Editing - Average
Did it live up to expectations?
It was close.
I wanted to see the Houses of Healing, Parley at the Black Gates, Parley at
Orthanc, Parley at the gates of
Minas Tirith between
Gandalf and the Whitchking, and of course the
Scouring of the Shire.
I also wanted to see Theodan ride through the Southron cavalry, and characters such as Prince
Imrahil come to life.
I thought it silly that
Pippin light the
beacons.
The Last Debate was utterly pathetic.
I didn't like the defenses of Minas Tirith being on the brink of colapse when
Aragorn arrives. In the book I thought it was important (and seemd natural) that Minas Tirith go on the offensive when the Riders of
Rohan come, when the attention of the
Nazgul is elsewhere.
The Aragorn /
Arwen love story throughout the movies was poorly portrayed. Lets face it there wasn't much to draw from in the book.
Finally, the character I've disliked the most throughout all the movies is
Elrond - Why a 3000 odd year old half man half
elf, renouned for his wisdom, has a problem with
men being weak (considering his brother, and father were men) is beyond me. Peter Jackson you lost the plot on that one.