• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

What IS Tom Bombadil?

What do you think Tom Bombadil was?

  • Vala..

    Votes: 25 13.2%
  • Maia..

    Votes: 41 21.6%
  • Nature/Earth Spirit..

    Votes: 85 44.7%
  • Other.. (Post your view below)

    Votes: 39 20.5%

  • Total voters
    190
Tolkien loved and put much thought into all he had written, he left Tom in for a reason not just becuase he was out of ideas and needed to throw something in. Tom has an orgin in Tolkien's mind and couldn't help but to uncounciously put clues to what he was into the story, he couldn't help doing it.
 

Yes, but recall that Yavanna *also* "makes"... Ulmo makes... Nienna makes... Manwe makes. Elbereth makes... the Valar had their various parts in creation... the question is *what* was Tom making? Tom's emphasis in the narrative is far more upon singing, talking, walking and watching of the country than making anything concrete... but as to what he makes, we are not told.

Tom Bombadil is MUCH closer in behavior to Tulkas (who is, more or less, a merry fellow... he also did not bear arms, have servants who became corrupt, etc.) than to Aule!
 
My previous post:

>>>Actually, it could, and most likely does mean Morgoth, not Sauron when Tom says
that about 'when the Dark Lord came in from the outside'.

Tom prefaces that by saying 'before the dark knew fear', meaning Morgoth hasn't
come to import evil to Middle Earth.

I wrote about this elewhere last night.
In the Silmarillion, it says that the Valar came down, made all this nice stuff, &
'Melkor looked down, saw what they had done & decended in wrath upon Arda'.

So, The Valar were there before Morgoth.....

If Tom's one of the Valar, he is about as opposite of Aule as could be.....

So, 'The Dark Lord' Tom's referring to MUST be Melkor, not Sauron.

Also, Elrond, I believe, states at The Council of Elrond that "he was known as 'Iarwain-Ben-Adar' & even then, was older that old"
That does not fit into the concept of The Valar forsaking Middle Earth, especially in the First Age.
Only Ulmo didn't forsake ME...

And, Tom himself states he was there when 'the Elves passed westward, before the seas were bent'. Which of the Valar could THAT be?
Only Orome. But, he led the Elves, he wasn't in a fixed place to see them 'pass'.....

So, he really doesn't fit into any of The Valar.

He's either a physical form of Eru or (my guess) some sort of physical manifestation of Middle Earth itself.
Tom's word's to Frodo seem to back this up:
"I was here before the rivers and the trees; Tom remembers the first raindrop & first acorn."
This idea of Tom being a human manifestation seems to be echoed at The Council of Elrond by Galdor: "Power to defy our Enemy is not in him unless it is in the earth itself."

Another point: Tom's first response to Frodo's "Who are you?" is "Don't you know my name yet?"
I strongly doubt that Hobbits would have sufficient knowledge of The Valar to guess Tom's real identity......
 
well, any reason why he could not be a great Maia of Yavanna? Didn't she go to ME early, and then her works were put to sleep?

What does it mean, can't be a Maia because a Maia can be influenced by the Ring? If at the last Bombadil would fall to Sauron, doesn't that mean he is less in power than Sauron?

As usual, I am missing something. I guess I vote for the nature spirit, if there is a reason he would not be a Maia of Yavanna.
 
Glorfindel at The Council of Elrond:

"Could that power (Sauron) be defied by Bombadil alone? I think not. I think that in the end, if all else is conquered, Bombadil fall, Last as he was First, and then night will come."

Notice he says "I THINK".

Nowhere is it definitely stated that Sauron has more power than Bombadil.

Also, Gandalf's statement immediately preceeding Glorfindel that 'such things have no hold on his mind" would seem, if true, to eliminate the fact that he was one of The Valar or their Maiar. Would the enemies of Morgoth & later Sauron space off something as important as the ring?
 
Before I gave up trying to id Tom I used to think he was Tulkas (for pretty much the same reasons Harad has given.) I envision Tulkas having Tom's happy, hearty, and uncomplicated disposition as long as he's not in a fight of some kind. I also don't think he would have left ME.

I'm not saying I think he's Tulkas, just he seems to be more Tulkas than Aule to me.
 
Tom can't be Tulkas, simple as that.
Why?

Because Tom states he was there "before the rivers & trees, before darkness knew fear, before The Dark Lord came in." Read my previous posts for the exact quote......

If Tom was there BEFORE Melkor, how could he be Tulkas, who came in AFTER Melkor?
 

Well not to argue (I wouldn't do that) but notice also that everyone at the council agrees with Glorfindel including Gandalf. How many times in the book, even as Gandalf the White, does Gandalf say, the only person you could meet more powerful is the dark lord? (to Gimli in White Rider TT, et al)

I (honestly!) don't understand why the ring not having hold on Tom's mind means he can't be a Maia. If you are a Maia of Yavanna, you don't care about something that Aule would like to make (i.e. about power, science, weapons, tools, etc), you only care about things that grow...

Also I think Tom being Tulkas is hi-larious, haha imagine a little guy in yellow boots and a feathered cap fighting Melkor
 
Last edited:
>>>IOW Tuklas (Tom) helped build ME and Melkor snuck over to ruin it. Classic "dog in the manger" type.

Where's that from?

In The Silmarillion, it clearly states that Tulkas came later & shifted the balance of power against Melkor, who it also states looked down on the Valar & their work & descended in wrath....Blah Blah Blah.....

So, The way I read the text, it's:
1. The Valar come to Arda & began building.
2. Melkor gets jealous & wants to take over by coming in & picking a fight.
3. Tulkas sees what's happening & enters into the fray on the Valar's side.

As previously stated, Tom was there before the Dark Lord descended on ME.

So, if Tulkas wasn't there yet, how could he possibly be Tom?

BTW, What about Tom saying to Frodo "Don't you know my name yet?"
I have seen NO indication that Hobbits (or Frodo in particular) would at this point in the story have sufficient lore or traditions about the Valar or Maiar to deduce exactly who Tom is if he is Vala or Maia.
The average Hobbit (Ted Sandyman) doesn't even believe the Elves are sailing West, let alone know Tulkas from Aule......
 
I've basically been going by memory & looking up the text as needed.
I'll go back to the beginning & read through until I get to where it says that Melkor descended upon Arda in wrath....

I don't recall Tulkas ever being mentioned prior to it saying he came last & tipped the scales in favor of The Valar, forever earning Melkor's hate......

I could be wrong, but I don't think so. It's only a few pages, I'll try to read it tommorow & report back.
 
I agree with practicly all the above, but find it pointless.
Ive always seen Tom as a way for Tolkien to put himself into the story. Author meets his subjekts kinda thing. So Tom therefore doesnt have any base in the middle earth world at all...
 
>>>So Tom therefore doesnt have any base in the
middle earth world at all...

I find that VERY un-Tolkienesque (?).
You're talking about an author who debated just what happened to the Blue Wizards.
Or what was Gandalf's original identity.
Or 100 other unsettled issues.
He'd say things like "I suspect that...."
Or his son would say "In the end, my father concluded..."

And, that still doesn't answer Tom's questioning Frodo with "Don't you know my name yet?".
That means there IS an answer.


On the Valar's order of appearance:
The Silmarillion says Melkor was there with the Valar 'from the first', 'there was strife between the Valar & Melkor' & he then 'withdrew & departed to other regions'....but did not put the desire of the Kingdom of Arda from his heart'.
Then, he saw the Valar take shape of majesty & splendor.... Melkor saw what was done & his envy grew....& he also took visable form, but because of his mood & malice.... it was dark & terrible. He descended on Arda in power & majesty greater than any other....(Ainulindale)

Valaquenta: Greatest in strength......is Tulkas. He came last to Arda to aid the Valar in the first battles with Melkor.

The first words in The Silmarillion:

'It is told amoung the Wise that the 1st War began before Arda was full-shaped, and ere yet there was nothing that grew or walked upon the earth; And for long Melkor held the upper hand. But in the midst of the war a spirit of great strength & hardihood came to the aid of the Valar..... So came Tulkas....

So, according to Tom's words, "He knew the Dark under Stars when it was fearless, before the Dark Lord came in from the outside".

That would eliminate Tulkas.

He could still be one of the other Valar.

Or could he?
Tom answers the question himself to Frodo:
"Eldest, that's what I am".


So, we're back where we began.
He's either a physical manifestation of Eru or (as I suspect) Arda itself.....


Actually, this well thought out arguement goes for naught if you read on, which I just did:

After Tulkas came, Melkor again forsakes Arda for a time before sneaking back in & delving Utumno.

So, Tom could have meant before the Dark Lord came in for the 2nd time.
Which means Tom could be one of the Valar, even Tulkas, if that's how you interpret his words. Also notice that Tom said 'Dark under stars", not Dark before stars.
So, is he one of the Valar there by the time Varda made the stars?

Bottom Line:
Tom is something unique, with power. And he's been there for a long time.
I'll stick with my guess that he's a living manifestation of Arda.

I feel like a dog chasing it's tail.......
 
I find the idea of Tom being a Valar, be it Aule or Tulkas ridiculas. If a valar was living in Middle Earth during the rise of Sauron in the Third Age, why would the Istari be needed. Surely a Valar is more than a match for Sauron.
If Tom is a Valar then why does he not get involved with events in Middle Earth during the War of the Ring. He obviously knows that things are happening, he even holds the One Ring at one point. I think that if he were a Valar he would have to get involved to drive the evil out of Middle Earth.

I realise that my views bring us no closer to fing out who tom is, but I think that it is very unlikely that he was a Valar.
 


If he is the physical manifestation of Arda, then why would he not fight against a major threat to all of creation like Sauron?
 
mother earth is always described as a female in all mythologies....and she is always decribed as being gentle, and embracing rather being terror

a valar wouldnt necessarily have to or want to interefere in the lives or men or elves in the 3rd age
 
...um...Remember,someone guessed Tom could be a 'nature spirit'?...Well,I've found something that (maybe)supports this idea:in 'The Return Of The King',when hobbits go back to the Shire.When they pass Bree,Gandalf separates and tells them:'I'm preparing for a long conversation with Bombadil,a conversation I've never had before.He(Tom) is moss-grown,and I am a rolling stone.But my rolling has stopped,we'll have lots to tell to each other.'Then Frodo says:
-It would be nice to see our old friend again.I wonder how is he?...
And Gandalf answers:
-Good,as always.He has no bigger problems and, I guess,he doesn't really care for what we've done or seen,unless our staying with ents.
So:if Tom were a Vala,Tulkas or a Maia,he'd certainly care about what has happened during the War of the Ring.Tom is only interested in ents(so NATURE).So,maybe he could be a 'nature spirit'?...
On the other hand,these Gandalf's words can be interpretted differently...I'm just guessing.
P.S.I'm sorry for the mistakes if I've made some.I've read LotR in my native language so this quote might be a bit incorrect.
 
"Don't you know my name yet?"

I don't necessarily see Tom saying this as meaning there is some hidden answer... I take it more in the Zen sense of: "Stop trying to explain everything and experience THIS."... he may have been trying to HELP Frodo to get over need to categorize Bombadil. Too bad Frodo didn't have a historical tradition including the Buddha et al. to give him the proper context.

**
 
Well, whatever we don't know about TB or who he is, we at least know this:

1) The ring of Sauron, a Maia, has no power over him, nor does it interest him
2) He can obviously teleport himself (appearing at the Barrow Downs when summoned), so he doesn't necessarily follow physical laws
3) He was in Arda before the elves awoke and seemingly when the world was formed
4) He is the keeper of the forest and land
5) The war of the ring, between elves, men, dwarves, and orcs and the destruction of Sauron do not interest him
6) Ents would interest him

From this I think, like Branwen, we can conclude that he was probably not Maia or Valar, though he existed before any living/created being on Arda. Branwen may have a point about a nature spirit. He could have been a special creation of Eru.

Don't you just love these enigmas?
 
well someone is going to say, "get over it Eonwe" but here goes

Aragorn speaks of Gandalf the White, by saying something like he could go wherever he wished much quicker than Aragorn, Gimli and Legolas. Perhaps this is a power of a Maia?

The only one interested in Ents, and here from the beginning (before the sleep of Yavanna?) would be someone associated with Yavanna hmm (like a Maia)? If he's a nature spirit, why would Gandalf want to talk with him before going West to Aman?

someday I'll get over it
 
Last edited:
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…