>>>So
Tom therefore doesnt have any base in the
middle earth world at all...
I find that VERY un-Tolkienesque (?).
You're talking about an author who debated just what happened to the
Blue Wizards.
Or what was
Gandalf's original identity.
Or 100 other unsettled issues.
He'd say things like "I suspect that...."
Or his son would say "In the end, my father concluded..."
And, that still doesn't answer Tom's questioning
Frodo with "Don't you know my name yet?".
That means there IS an answer.
On the
Valar's order of appearance:
The Silmarillion says
Melkor was there with the Valar 'from the first', 'there was strife between the Valar & Melkor' & he then 'withdrew & departed to other
regions'....but did not put the desire of the Kingdom of
Arda from his heart'.
Then, he saw the Valar take shape of majesty & splendor.... Melkor saw what was done & his envy grew....& he also took visable form, but because of his mood & malice.... it was dark & terrible. He descended on Arda in power & majesty greater than any other....(
Ainulindale)
Valaquenta: Greatest in strength......is
Tulkas. He came last to Arda to aid the Valar in the first
battles with Melkor.
The first words in The Silmarillion:
'It is told amoung
the Wise that the 1st War began before Arda was full-shaped, and ere yet there was nothing that grew or walked upon the earth; And for long Melkor held the upper hand. But in the midst of the war a spirit of great strength & hardihood came to the aid of the Valar..... So came Tulkas....
So, according to Tom's words, "He knew the Dark under Stars when it was fearless, before the
Dark Lord came in from the outside".
That would eliminate Tulkas.
He could still be one of the other Valar.
Or could he?
Tom answers the question himself to Frodo:
"Eldest, that's what I am".
So, we're back where we began.
He's either a physical manifestation of
Eru or (as I suspect) Arda itself.....
Actually, this well thought out arguement goes for naught if you read on, which I just did:
After Tulkas came, Melkor again forsakes Arda for a time before sneaking back in & delving
Utumno.
So, Tom could have meant before the Dark Lord came in for the 2nd time.
Which means Tom could be one of the Valar, even Tulkas, if that's how you interpret his words. Also notice that Tom said 'Dark under stars", not Dark before stars.
So, is he one of the Valar there by the time
Varda made the stars?
Bottom Line:
Tom is something unique, with power. And he's been there for a long time.
I'll stick with my guess that he's a living manifestation of Arda.
I feel like a dog chasing it's tail.......