simbelmyne
Member
- Joined
- Mar 2, 2003
- Messages
- 322
I finally saw the EE of TTT, and all through the first disk was excited. It was good! The addiditions made it better! Remembering that PJ replaced a scene in the EE of FOTR (getting into Lorien) with a better version, I had high hopes that some of the big errors in the second half of the movie would be fixed, or at least explained in a way that made more sense...and then the lumbering beast of Helm's Deep began...
What what what is going on in this part of the movie? What about...
1. Gandalf and Aragorn's advice to Theoden. They tell him that "open war is upon" him and that he should ride out to meet it, drawing orcs away from the women and children. That Helm's Deep is a trap. Not only is that terrible advice, but Grima contradicts it in his scene with Saruman, telling him that the smart thing for Theoden to do will be to go to Helm's Deep, where he has a chance to defend himself. Aragorn agrees at Helm's Deep that it is the best place for T to defend himself. A also then says that the orcs come to Rohan to destroy everyone, "down to the last child". So not only would troops have been masacred in open battle, but it would have left women and children defenseless in Edoras. What?
2. The status of Rohan before the battle. Aragorn, etc. make it pretty clear that Rohan will probably "not last the night" because the orc #'s are so great. A few hours before the battle Aragorn advises T to send for help to Gondor and the elves. Umm...how exactly is that suppossed to happen? Not only do those of us who have read the books know this to be impossible, but those who have seen ROTK know what a huge distance lies between Gondor and Rohan (lighting the beacons). Then a hundred or so elves show up and all of a sudden Theoden is leering down at the orcs saying "is this all you've got?". Well, yeah, and they are still kicking your ___, Theoden - with or without the Olympic Orc.
3. Theoden's split personality. So one minute he's brave, the next he's cowering in the corner. The "who am I?" speech before the battle? You're the guy who two minutes ago was authoritative and two minutes from now will be saying "is this all you've got" (then back and forth again). The only reason I could IMAGINE he says this is because he thinks he made the wrong decision by coming to Helm's Deep and should have listened to Aragorn's "advice", even though other characters admit the advice was wrong.
4. Aragorn as Rambo. The one man army leaping onto bridges and ladders, punching orcs and yelling. Sylvester Stallone should be proud. How about a skillfull swordfight? Displaying some of the smarts he's supposed to be overflowing with?
5. Gimli the buffoon. If just one of Gimli's terrible moments (of which there are SO many) had been cut out...the stuff about dwarf tossing is the worst. That joke was subtle and funny in FOTR. Here it's so over the top and campy that it's PAINFUL to watch. He's left with no dignity. Actually, maybe the chain mail scene is the worst...
6. Not only is Helm's Deep filled with nonsense (Aragorn dead/alive again, Legolas on the surfboard, Orc with torch), but it goes on and on and on and on and on and on...I think the EE only made it longer....
Any FAD out there who can explain in what way these things make sense?
What what what is going on in this part of the movie? What about...
1. Gandalf and Aragorn's advice to Theoden. They tell him that "open war is upon" him and that he should ride out to meet it, drawing orcs away from the women and children. That Helm's Deep is a trap. Not only is that terrible advice, but Grima contradicts it in his scene with Saruman, telling him that the smart thing for Theoden to do will be to go to Helm's Deep, where he has a chance to defend himself. Aragorn agrees at Helm's Deep that it is the best place for T to defend himself. A also then says that the orcs come to Rohan to destroy everyone, "down to the last child". So not only would troops have been masacred in open battle, but it would have left women and children defenseless in Edoras. What?
2. The status of Rohan before the battle. Aragorn, etc. make it pretty clear that Rohan will probably "not last the night" because the orc #'s are so great. A few hours before the battle Aragorn advises T to send for help to Gondor and the elves. Umm...how exactly is that suppossed to happen? Not only do those of us who have read the books know this to be impossible, but those who have seen ROTK know what a huge distance lies between Gondor and Rohan (lighting the beacons). Then a hundred or so elves show up and all of a sudden Theoden is leering down at the orcs saying "is this all you've got?". Well, yeah, and they are still kicking your ___, Theoden - with or without the Olympic Orc.
3. Theoden's split personality. So one minute he's brave, the next he's cowering in the corner. The "who am I?" speech before the battle? You're the guy who two minutes ago was authoritative and two minutes from now will be saying "is this all you've got" (then back and forth again). The only reason I could IMAGINE he says this is because he thinks he made the wrong decision by coming to Helm's Deep and should have listened to Aragorn's "advice", even though other characters admit the advice was wrong.
4. Aragorn as Rambo. The one man army leaping onto bridges and ladders, punching orcs and yelling. Sylvester Stallone should be proud. How about a skillfull swordfight? Displaying some of the smarts he's supposed to be overflowing with?
5. Gimli the buffoon. If just one of Gimli's terrible moments (of which there are SO many) had been cut out...the stuff about dwarf tossing is the worst. That joke was subtle and funny in FOTR. Here it's so over the top and campy that it's PAINFUL to watch. He's left with no dignity. Actually, maybe the chain mail scene is the worst...
6. Not only is Helm's Deep filled with nonsense (Aragorn dead/alive again, Legolas on the surfboard, Orc with torch), but it goes on and on and on and on and on and on...I think the EE only made it longer....
Any FAD out there who can explain in what way these things make sense?
Last edited:


