• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Helm's Deep - PJ's Shame Spiral

simbelmyne

Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2003
Messages
322
I finally saw the EE of TTT, and all through the first disk was excited. It was good! The addiditions made it better! Remembering that PJ replaced a scene in the EE of FOTR (getting into Lorien) with a better version, I had high hopes that some of the big errors in the second half of the movie would be fixed, or at least explained in a way that made more sense...and then the lumbering beast of Helm's Deep began...

What what what is going on in this part of the movie? What about...
1. Gandalf and Aragorn's advice to Theoden. They tell him that "open war is upon" him and that he should ride out to meet it, drawing orcs away from the women and children. That Helm's Deep is a trap. Not only is that terrible advice, but Grima contradicts it in his scene with Saruman, telling him that the smart thing for Theoden to do will be to go to Helm's Deep, where he has a chance to defend himself. Aragorn agrees at Helm's Deep that it is the best place for T to defend himself. A also then says that the orcs come to Rohan to destroy everyone, "down to the last child". So not only would troops have been masacred in open battle, but it would have left women and children defenseless in Edoras. What?

2. The status of Rohan before the battle. Aragorn, etc. make it pretty clear that Rohan will probably "not last the night" because the orc #'s are so great. A few hours before the battle Aragorn advises T to send for help to Gondor and the elves. Umm...how exactly is that suppossed to happen? Not only do those of us who have read the books know this to be impossible, but those who have seen ROTK know what a huge distance lies between Gondor and Rohan (lighting the beacons). Then a hundred or so elves show up and all of a sudden Theoden is leering down at the orcs saying "is this all you've got?". Well, yeah, and they are still kicking your ___, Theoden - with or without the Olympic Orc.

3. Theoden's split personality. So one minute he's brave, the next he's cowering in the corner. The "who am I?" speech before the battle? You're the guy who two minutes ago was authoritative and two minutes from now will be saying "is this all you've got" (then back and forth again). The only reason I could IMAGINE he says this is because he thinks he made the wrong decision by coming to Helm's Deep and should have listened to Aragorn's "advice", even though other characters admit the advice was wrong.

4. Aragorn as Rambo. The one man army leaping onto bridges and ladders, punching orcs and yelling. Sylvester Stallone should be proud. How about a skillfull swordfight? Displaying some of the smarts he's supposed to be overflowing with?

5. Gimli the buffoon. If just one of Gimli's terrible moments (of which there are SO many) had been cut out...the stuff about dwarf tossing is the worst. That joke was subtle and funny in FOTR. Here it's so over the top and campy that it's PAINFUL to watch. He's left with no dignity. Actually, maybe the chain mail scene is the worst...

6. Not only is Helm's Deep filled with nonsense (Aragorn dead/alive again, Legolas on the surfboard, Orc with torch), but it goes on and on and on and on and on and on...I think the EE only made it longer....

Any FAD out there who can explain in what way these things make sense?
 
Last edited:
i agree with you quite a bit. although if you read my other posts, i find it a great offense that you would say that PJ made specific things better. that is not the issue here.

i also rented the extended edition. i rented it on vhs as i didn't have a dvd player available to me at the time. the first vhs left me feeling that the movie was capable of redeeming itself, and becoming enjoyable for me to watch. the second vhs was even more painful than all of the original theatrical release itself.

i think part of the problem is the overwhelming amount of screen time that helm's deep is given. this is disproportionate in a few ways. book iii concentrates mainly on the relationships developing, and the development of characters. the friendship of legolas and gimli, the discovery of theoden and eomer as new allies of brave stature, the introduction of eowyn and her emotional turmoil, merry and pippin helping each other escape from orcs without the rest of the fellowship to help them, merry and pippin's unlikely friendship in treebeard and contribution to the fall of isengard, and finally the inevitable confrontation between gandalf and saruman who are members of the istari.

helms deep is not really about action. in the books it serves as a backdrop for tolkien to develop these things i mentioned earlier even more.

helms deep and the game that legolas and gimli play really does a lot to show us their solidifying friendship. also, after seeing the caves of the deeping coomb, gimli is willing to strike the bargain with legolas of travelling with him after the war.

theoden and eomer act bravely by riding to helms deep knowing that they may well die. you see that they do trust gandalf. also, when in helms deep you see theoden, and his distaste for not being engaged in the combat. he is worried more about the lives of his soldiers than his own. mind you, he needed to live through that so that he could lead them to the battle of pellenor fields. helms deep is the vehicle that allows us to see this.

eowyn is introduced in meduseld. but we get a vivid picture of her in the way she reacts to the king going off to helms deep. she wishes to fight, but is not allowed, the cause of some of her stress. also we see that she is held as a woman of good stature by the people of rohan, as they nominate her to lead them in theoden's absense.

merry and pippin, are largely on their own during helms deep, and seperated from it. so they are not in any major way developed by it. however, if helms deep becomes the overwhelming focus, we tend to forget about the changes they were making in book iii.

the conflict between saruman and gandalf is the conclusion of the war of which helms deep was the only major battle. it was largely gandalf who defeated saruman on the field tactically, by bringing the huorns and also finding erkenbrand. and it is gandalf who removes his ability to wage war by breaking his staff. we really see gandalf developing into a very active and integral part of the victory against sauron. and by being a good tactician, as opposed to supporting people in peace as he has done before.

the tremendous disproportion here is that the action drowns out almost all of this character development. a lot of people complain about being able to identify and care about the fates of the characters in rotk. they would identify better if we had been given sight into the depth and changes in the characters instead of overwhelming amount of action in ttt.

the other disproportion is that helms deep is so active, it drowns out the battle of pellenor fields. it is simply given more screen time, despite the fact that pellenor fields is the much more important battle. there is just so much random action shots in the sequence. PJ had to make up for some of the things he left out ttt in the beginning of the rotk. this ate away at the time available for the battle we all really wanted to see, pellenor fields.
 
-K- said:
I find it a great offense that you would say that PJ made specific things better.
I took Symbelmyne to mean that the TTT EE makes the film better than the TTT TE, at first, and that's something that most people here have agreed on. It's after the first sixty minutes or so that it starts to fall apart again, as the TE does.
Otherwise, I agree with everything you both say!
 
I'm not sure whether to happy about the fact or not, but most of the things mentioned above are actually rather insignificant in comparison to other much more blatant Peter Jackson hijinks.
 
That Helm's Deep is a trap. Not only is that terrible advice, but Grima contradicts it in his scene with Saruman, telling him that the smart thing for Theoden to do will be to go to Helm's Deep,

Perhaps Gandalf knows that Saruman will send his army to Helm's Deep so that if they evacuate the women and children to the east towards Gondor it will give them maybe 4-5 days headstart.

I am just trying to imagine 10,000 Uruk-Hai turning up to find an empty fortress and Saruman wasting his time conjuring that thunderstorm!

If 10,000 unstoppable Uruks attack, it's not the best idea to shove them into a corner and put 500 semi-soldiers in front. It's handy to be able to escape.

Aragorn advises T to send for help to Gondor and the elves. Umm...how exactly is that suppossed to happen? Not only do those of us who have read the books know this to be impossible, but those who have seen ROTK know what a huge distance lies between Gondor and Rohan.

Within the seemingly impregnable fortress of Helm's Deep, the Rohan could have withstood the Uruks for weeks since the only weak point is the gate, which could be defended by 500 with ease. Gondor and the Elves could have mustered a force and travelled the distance by then and saved the day.

So one minute he's brave, the next he's cowering in the corner.

The reason Theoden is acting so brave in such a loud and open manner is to boost his men's morale.
Aragorn tells him that he shouldn't be optimistic and Theoden quietly but forcefully tells him:
What would you have me do? Look at my men. Their courage hangs by a thread.

This is also why he does his "Is this all you can conjure, Saruman?", because he is surrounded by his men and to strengthen their morale.

How about a skillfull swordfight?

Having 100 Uruk-Hai armed with scythes who will simply hack away at you until they knock the sword out of your hand or knock your head off your shoulders, is not the best time for a fencing duel or any elegant swordplay. You simply block, slash, then move on to the next one.

Gimli the buffoon.

Unfortunately, we only see glimpses of Gimli's formidable skill as a warrior. Amon Hen, Battle with the Wargs, Helm's Deep, Pelennor Fields and the Black Gate.
At Helm's Deep we see him kill two Beserkers (Of which there are only thirty) and at the defence of the breached wall and the gate. He then blows the Horn of Helm because he can't ride out on a horse.

He also provides the essential comic relief. How dull and serious would the trilogy appear without it. Most of it is masterfully done, especially the original "No-one tosses a dwarf, the eyes of a hawk and the ears of a fox, That one counts as mine, you could have picked a better spot, it still only counts as one!"
I must admit, I don't see why he doesn't wear his dwarven mail. Perhaps it was too light for a serious battle? The second dwarf-tossing is just a little reference that makes you smile. Nothing wrong with that.

Peter Jackson isn't stupid. He knows that to keep the female portion of the audience happy, there must be scenes where Legolas gets to do his fancy bit, whether on a Cave Troll, mounting a galloping horse, killing a mumak or surfing down stairs.

The beserker with the torch is a very tense piece of cinema and a very nail-biting moment. The special torch is probably because the bombs require a hotter flame than an average torch.

Thanks
Morgaphry
 
"He then blows the Horn of Helm because he can't ride out on a horse."

Couldn't he help any other way? Maybe engage in some ground fighting? Anyway, I fid it ridicullous that he would be blowing the horn, while I would not think he qualified to do that.

"He also provides the essential comic relief. How dull and serious would the trilogy appear without it. Most of it is masterfully done, especially the original "No-one tosses a dwarf, the eyes of a hawk and the ears of a fox, That one counts as mine, you could have picked a better spot, it still only counts as one!"
I must admit, I don't see why he doesn't wear his dwarven mail. Perhaps it was too light for a serious battle? The second dwarf-tossing is just a little reference that makes you smile. Nothing wrong with that."

Nothing wrong? Here I would greatly disagree with you, because it's these supposedly "comic" scenes dont they achieve their purpose of comedy at all. They were usually failed attempts of humor, entertaining only a small portion of movie-goers ( I have asked lots of my friends and family, this is not just talk). They only achieve making Gimly look ridicullous and rob him of any dignity, making himthe silly scottish dwarf instead of the brave, hardy, saving-Eomer's-life dwarf.

As for the film being too serious, I don't think that's too bad. i would prefer it to a film with very weak humor.

I will stop now before i go into an anti PJ fit.
 
Morgaphry said:
He also provides the essential comic relief. How dull and serious would the trilogy appear without it.
Most of it is masterfully done, especially the original "No-one tosses a dwarf, the eyes of a hawk and the ears of a fox, That one counts as mine, you could have picked a better spot, it still only counts as one!"
Peter Jackson isn't stupid. He knows that to keep the female portion of the audience happy, there must be scenes where Legolas gets to do his fancy bit.
The beserker with the torch is a very tense piece of cinema and a very nail-biting moment.
"Essential", "dull and serious"? You and I are clearly living in different worlds.
Tolkien knew exactly how much humour this kind of story needs and he provided it. PJ was welcome to use it, and if he had done so he would have achieved a trilogy that was the reverse of dull, though of course being serious is a pretty vital part of it! Comic relief belongs in a different kind of film altogether.
"Masterfully" done, and those quotations? What world is this? They were writing better comedy than that when the first talking pictures came out.
I mustn't call him stupid of course, but if he really did that thing of "keeping the female....happy", I would be immune from criticism for calling him sexist.
That guy is a berserker? Oh well, near enough I suppose. But "tense"?? I thought it was another bit of deliberate comic relief.
An Olympic torch is needed to detonate what look like mines, and the guy happens to trip over something? Surely the trip,
at least, was meant to be comic relief?
I'm almost out of energy for asking questions.
One last one: have I just been answering seriously a spoof entry?
 
Last edited:
May I start by saying From our modern view, Humour is not one of Tolkien's strongpoints.
The humour in the book, whilst undoubtedly there, is slightly too subtle for most people. Comic relief can be overdone, but can also be vital in breaking tension at exactly the right moment.
Pippin's "Great. Where are we going." Was pulled off with great expertise.
Gimli's "You could have picked a better spot was also perfectly timed. The joking that followed perfectly displayed the way the two veteran warriors maintained a sense of humour despite what was approaching in the dark. This was further strengthened by the competition between them.

Gimli may have been a source of comic relief, but unlike most characters who possess that role in movies, he was very funny. (Fake cough that sounds like JarJar, JarJar.)

Thanks
Morgaphry

P.S Perhaps some of those reading this could accept the fact that for such a stupendously visual battle like Helm's Deep, comic relief is part of the formula for making Films.
 
But Morgaphry, you must understand that I am not attacking comedy or comic relief in movies as a whole, but I am rather dissapointed with PJs weak and (usually) failed attempts at it. Although I admit, with no guilt, that I had a few laughs during the film, most humor attempts did not entertain me at all. Maybe it was not jar-jar sized failure, but Gimli is somewhat the not-nearly-as-funny-as-was-meant-to-be character. As for the orc scene, I think it was intended to be funny, but failed so much in that people did not even realise it was meant to be funny. But, of course, you can credit PJ with that saying he went for subtlety. ;)
 
Morgaphry said:
May I start by saying From our modern view, Humour is not one of Tolkien's strongpoints.
The humour in the book, whilst undoubtedly there, is slightly too subtle for most people.
Comic relief can be overdone, but can also be vital in breaking tension at exactly the right moment.
Gimli's "You could have picked a better spot was also perfectly timed.
Gimli....was very funny.
the fact that for such a stupendously visual battle like Helm's Deep, comic relief is part of the formula for making Films.
There's nothing to stop you giving YOUR point of view, and there's no denying it's modern, as you made it today.
Whether anyone shares it, to justify the "our", is another matter.
There has been general agreement for fifty years, and I am sure it will continue for another five hundred, that Tolkien's
well-thought-out humour, given to the right people, in the right place, at the right time, is one of the major factors that go into making his works into great literature.
I have more respect for "most people" than to think them incapable of appreciating subtle humour. Surely we left the Keystone Cops behind a while ago?
PJ certainly knows how to overdo his comic relief. Why is it "vital" to break tension? And why with comic relief? It's seemed odd to me from the start that PJ's idea of the "right moment" is immediately after he has set up a wonderful emotional situation, as if he couldn't bear the idea of taking such a thing seriously.
If you believe those two claims about Gimli, then we're back in our two different worlds.
If the film industry really does work to formulas, then it's time they caught up with this real world: "fomulaic" is almost a dirty word these days, in most branches of the arts and crafts, as in most areas of life.
And if their formula includes a requirement for comic relief in any "stupendously visual" battle, then I'm sure there are plenty of people with a wider experience than mine of films, who will tell us of instances in which that requirement was conveniently forgotten, or ignored.
 
Last edited:
I've been away far too long. TTF wasn't working for about a week, and now I have literally hundreds of posts to catch up on. :rolleyes:

simbelmyne said:
1. Gandalf and Aragorn's advice to Theoden. They tell him that "open war is upon" him and that he should ride out to meet it, drawing orcs away from the women and children. That Helm's Deep is a trap. Not only is that terrible advice, but Grima contradicts it in his scene with Saruman, telling him that the smart thing for Theoden to do will be to go to Helm's Deep, where he has a chance to defend himself. Aragorn agrees at Helm's Deep that it is the best place for T to defend himself. A also then says that the orcs come to Rohan to destroy everyone, "down to the last child". So not only would troops have been masacred in open battle, but it would have left women and children defenseless in Edoras. What?[/I][/B]
Just a warning to start off; I might accidentally insert something from the book into the movie, as I just lately read that part. If I do, please correct me. Forward

You fail to back up the claim that it is "terrible advice." The fact that Helm's Deep offers the best defense doesn't mean it is the best option. That is crucial. It would be far better to wage a type of 'guerilla warfare.' Advance out to meet the Uruk Hai, while sending the women and children in the opposite direction, not leaving them in Edoras, as you suggest. And correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't believe Grima says Helm's Deep is the smart choice, he merely knows Theoden well enough to understand that he will flee to Helm's Deep.

2. The status of Rohan before the battle. Aragorn, etc. make it pretty clear that Rohan will probably "not last the night" because the orc #'s are so great. A few hours before the battle Aragorn advises T to send for help to Gondor and the elves. Umm...how exactly is that suppossed to happen? Not only do those of us who have read the books know this to be impossible, but those who have seen ROTK know what a huge distance lies between Gondor and Rohan (lighting the beacons). Then a hundred or so elves show up and all of a sudden Theoden is leering down at the orcs saying "is this all you've got?". Well, yeah, and they are still kicking your ___, Theoden - with or without the Olympic Orc.
No doubt this is hope born of desparation. :p Aragorn is stuck with Theoden in Helm's Deep. To send for aid and hope that it comes in time, farfetched as it may be is the seeming last hope. The beacons work both ways, so Gondor could make it in what...2 or so days? Definitely a long shot.

I won't bother answering #3. Anyone who's been on TTF for a while know that I hate Theoden and his split personality in TTT. Heck, I did a Powerpoint speech for school on it once... :rolleyes:

4. Aragorn as Rambo. The one man army leaping onto bridges and ladders, punching orcs and yelling. Sylvester Stallone should be proud. How about a skillfull swordfight? Displaying some of the smarts he's supposed to be overflowing with?
You're telling me that you have a problem with him punching orcs and yelling? Dear lord. ;) The bridge I think was fine, perhaps the ladder was a bit over done. JRR Tolkien's Lord of the Rings has medieval warfare. It was up close and brutal, not known for its finesse. And I seriously don't think the 'real' Aragorn fought in silence.

5. Gimli the buffoon. If just one of Gimli's terrible moments (of which there are SO many) had been cut out...the stuff about dwarf tossing is the worst. That joke was subtle and funny in FOTR. Here it's so over the top and campy that it's PAINFUL to watch. He's left with no dignity. Actually, maybe the chain mail scene is the worst...
The chain mail is the worst. And you forgot to put IMHO after that point. :p ;) It wasn't painful to me.

6. Not only is Helm's Deep filled with nonsense (Aragorn dead/alive again, Legolas on the surfboard, Orc with torch), but it goes on and on and on and on and on and on...I think the EE only made it longer....
Technically Aragorn dead and alive really had nothing to do with Helm's Deep as a whole. Legolas was on a shield, and I hate the Orc with a torch. Yes it's long, the only problem is that the Ents slow it down too much.

So good being back! :)
 
Gandalf White said:
TTF wasn't working for about a week....
The chain mail is the worst.
Helm's Deep....the only problem is that the Ents slow it down too much
What was wrong with your TTF? :confused:
I don't think it's possible to rank Gimli for worst. I can think of only one scene that doesn't qualify for worst: the TTT EE addition about his gift from Galadriel. That was great - how tragic that PJ restricted him to that one moment of being his true self -
unless, of course, he relents in ROTK? :rolleyes:
Do you mean the rapid alternations between HD and Fangorn? If so, I tend to agree with you.
That's not the only problem though; the whole thing is the problem! Read the eight pages in the book describing it, imagine how PJ's great actors could have portrayed it, and how it would have looked in PJ's great settings and special effects, then compare what he invented for us instead - a confusion of noise and circus tricks - that "spiral of shame", going ever "on and on"!
 
joxy said:
What was wrong with your TTF? :confused:

....the TTT EE addition about his gift from Galadriel. That was great...

...Do you mean the rapid alternations between HD and Fangorn? If so, I tend to agree with you....

One day it just decided to put up the "This Page Cannot Be Displayed" message. That went on for about week, until today it suddenly worked, without any tinkering at all. That's computers for you! :p

Thank you for reminding me of that scene. One wonders how people can still stick to the view that the movies would be worse if they followed Tolkien closer and then watch that scene and compare it with Gimli's chain mail. :confused: Oh well.

No, I rather liked the alterations. However, the Ents (probably due to PJ's decision to have Treebeard say no) take far too long to get into action. Helm's Deep has a battle going on and Treebeard's scenes are far too slow in comparison. I believe this was more evident in the TE.

Edit: I just realized something. When the Forum quit working I could swear that my post count was 16xx, now I'm in the 1700's. :eek:

*looks around suspiciously*
 
Last edited:
Gandalf White said:
That's computers for you!
However, the Ents (probably due to PJ's decision to have Treebeard say no) take far too long to get into action.
Since the changes the TTF server is sometimes busy and won't let anyone else in. That usually lasts only a few minutes.
That decision messes up the whole ent thread. It would have been better to leave it out altogether than to make it so confusing.
 
Gandalf White said:
The fact that Helm's Deep offers the best defense doesn't mean it is the best option. That is crucial. It would be far better to ...advance out to meet the Uruk Hai, while sending the women and children in the opposite direction, not leaving them in Edoras, as you suggest. And correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't believe Grima says Helm's Deep is the smart choice...

Welome back GW! Hmm...interesting theory, but IMHO ;) "open war" doesn't have much in common with guerilla warfare...where could the women and children be safer than at Helm's Deep? especially when Aragorn says the Uruk Hai are coming to kill EVERYONE? 10,000 orcs are enough to obliterate Theoden and squash the little kids running away too...(hey, that part wouldn't be so bad, haha)

Good point about Grima, unsure what he means. He says Edoras is vulnerable, and T will go to the vast fortress of Rohan. But then T says to one of his guys (in the EE) that leaving Edoras is not a defeat, which pretty much means he thinks it is. Who in their right mind would want to stay at Edoras?

Heck, I did a Powerpoint speech for school on it once...

Go GW! Way to school 'em!

You're telling me that you have a problem with him punching orcs and yelling?

Well yeah, when it's vigilante style. I'm suprised he didn't have a scarf tied around his head. Other battle scenes were more about amazing visuals (that looked at least halfway real). Helm's Deep is seriously lacking in this area, and focuses more on the "raw power" of Aragorn. Which, forgive me, he doesn't have :eek: :p
 
Morgaphry said:
Rohan could have withstood the Uruks for weeks since the only weak point is the gate, which could be defended by 500 with ease. Gondor and the Elves could have mustered a force and travelled the distance by then and saved the day.

That's true, they should have been able to hold out for several days...so why before the battle did some whiny kid say "we will not last the night", and Legolas get all pouty about how pitiful Rohan's defense was? How long did that battle last in the book?

Peter Jackson isn't stupid. He knows that to keep the female portion of the audience happy, there must be scenes where Legolas gets to do his fancy bit, whether on a Cave Troll, mounting a galloping horse, killing a mumak or surfing down stairs.

Well this is one female who would have appreciated more of the FOTR "fancy bits" that looked/seemed more realistic. :p The mumak scene ALMOST makes me snigger, but I don't feel right about it...
 
I'm just remembering the squealing that filled the cinema when Legolas did his Mumak bit. It happens in every movie:
FOTR - Climbs on cave-troll, shoots him in head.
TTT - Grabs onto galloping horse and flips onto saddle (containing Gimli.)
ROTK - Climbs on Mumak. Untbuckles the war-tower. Shoots the Mumak in head.

Just an observation.

Morgaphry
 
Confusticated botheration. I had a whole response typed out, and screwed it up somehow, now I have to start all over again. :rolleyes:

simbelmyne said:
Welome back GW! Hmm...interesting theory, but IMHO ;) "open war" doesn't have much in common with guerilla warfare...where could the women and children be safer than at Helm's Deep? especially when Aragorn says the Uruk Hai are coming to kill EVERYONE? 10,000 orcs are enough to obliterate Theoden and squash the little kids running away too...(hey, that part wouldn't be so bad, haha)

If the Uruk Hai are coming to kill everyone, then the best defense would be for the women and children to flee in the opposite direction, perhaps heading to the mountains, to places hard to find. Not to run to the most obvious hiding place and wait for the huge, marauding army. No sir!

Theoden tells Aragorn, "I will not risk open war," not wanting to instigate anything with Saruman. To my knowledge, Aragorn never counsels Theoden to charge head-on into Saruman's army, he simply tries to get it into Theoden that he will have to fight and that holing himself up is a bad idea.

symbelmyne said:
Good point about Grima, unsure what he means. He says Edoras is vulnerable, and T will go to the vast fortress of Rohan. But then T says to one of his guys (in the EE) that leaving Edoras is not a defeat, which pretty much means he thinks it is. Who in their right mind would want to stay at Edoras?
Hate to admit it, but this royally confused me. Translation! ;) :eek:

Anyway, in conclusion, it would have caused much less debate (is that good?) if PJ had merely followed Tolkien; I re-read that part several weeks ago, and Tolkien's story makes Theoden's decision clearer. Oh well...

joxy said:
Since the changes the TTF server is sometimes busy and won't let anyone else in. That usually lasts only a few minutes.
That actually hasn't happened to me since we switched to 3.0. It used to come up from time to time with the earlier version, but it always gives a message telling me why, and like you said, it only lasts a few minutes to an hour--never a week or so.
 
Last edited:
Okay, I've got to say this:
T is leading his people to HD, and Wormtongue knows this, as well as the weakness of it. So then wouldn't T know about the drain and that it was HD only weakness, and therefore why didn't he have that area protected? Why would Gimli consent to being thrown in TTT but in FOTR he said "no body tosses this dwarf....a dwarf...." or something like that, so why now? That has been bothering me since I saw that in TTT. Also, what's up with the running of the torch? Was Aragon alive or dead, and what brought him back?
 
Warrior said:
Okay, I've got to say this:
T is leading his people to HD, and Wormtongue knows this, as well as the weakness of it. So then wouldn't T know about the drain and that it was HD only weakness, and therefore why didn't he have that area protected? Why would Gimli consent to being thrown in TTT but in FOTR he said "no body tosses this dwarf....a dwarf...." or something like that, so why now? That has been bothering me since I saw that in TTT. Also, what's up with the running of the torch? Was Aragon alive or dead, and what brought him back?

1) Neither Theoden, nor anyone else in Rohan, has any idea about explosives. The drain has bars on it. One or two orcs at a time, squeezzing through it, if they could, would hardly constitute a threat to the defenses.

2) Because in the scene in FOTR Gimli thinks he can jump the distance himself. In TTT it is too far for him to jump.

3) I don't know "what's up". The "olympic orc" never made that much difference to me. Perhaps a little silly, but so what.

4) Aragorn was not dead so nothing brought him back -- he wasn't gone.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top