• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

joxy said:
I believed what PJ told us: that he had made a faithful representation of his source material.
Does anybody have a quote about "what PJ told us"? I think that the words he used would be quite enlightening, especially in regards to what we should have expected and what we were actually delivered.
 
Joxy...

when she quotes me, then replies, she is rebutting me. If her replies were general in nature, then she should note have quoted my post verbatim. She should have made her replies independant of my prior observations.

And I have absolutely no problem with her rebutting me if she wishes, thats what makes a forum interesting, a civilized exchange of differing opinions. But the fact is, Mrs M rebutted two points that I did not attempt to make, thus framing my post out of context. I was merely clarifying. I clearly said that I did not believe purists went expecting a verbatim adaptation. And I did not hint or imply in any way that the length of the movies are a testament to their quality.

I would still like for someone to explain exactly how Jackson's adaptation changed the spirit of the story. Without that, the criticism is really all based on people losing sight of the message of the story for the sake of details, isn't it? To me, the crux of both the books and the movies was friendship and sacrifice, and the idea that no matter how insignificant you may see yourself, you may just get the chance to change the world. I sae that in both, just told a bit differently.
 
Rowan Evensong said:
....when she quotes me, then replies, she is rebutting me. If her replies were general in nature, then she should note have quoted my post verbatim. She should have made her replies independant of my prior observations.
But the fact is, Mrs M rebutted two points that I did not attempt to make, thus framing my post out of context.
I clearly said that I did not believe purists went expecting a verbatim adaptation.
For "rebutting", read "disagreeing". Is that a problem?
You said "if a person went expecting a verbatim retelling of the books on film, that was more than a little naive."
Mrs M pointed out that, in her opinion, which I share, there are no "people who went expecting a verbatim retelling".
You speculated, by using the word "if", on the possibility that such people existed; Mrs M said they do not exist. I accept, and I am sure Mrs M accepts, that your statement was only a speculation, but I have to add that I did not see the further statement, to which you refer above, that in fact you did NOT now believe that the speculation was valid, that "I did not believe purists went expecting a verbatim adaptation". Perhaps you would specify where you made that statement, and may I mention my posting #335 on the same topic.
On the second "rebutting", it really wasn't one! It was inspired by your mention of the length of the films, but then had no further personal relevance to you.
Regarding the point that Mrs M should not have quoted ALL of your posting, I have to mention that this is something that often happens here, that people do not necessarily remove all parts of a quotation that are not strictly relevant. They mean no harm!
Also, I believe you commented, quite rightly, on the title of this thread. It goes back to the release of FOTR, and has had Parts I and II previously; it was a bit of mischievous fun by the person who started it, and we have all learned to live with it since then.
I hope you will come to view it in that same light.
 
Here.

"If a person went expecting a verbatim retelling of the books on film, that was more than a little naive. I suspect the purists went knowing what they were going to get for the most part, but wanting to hate the movies because, after all, they weren't the book."

That was my opening quote on this subject. It was in the second line, the one right after the line you have quoted me on, that I said I did not believe "purists" went expecting a verbatim adaptation. As for the rest, if I were to rephrase it now, I would replace the word "wanting" with "expecting." Most of the criticism I have read in this thread and the others regarding this particular topic have only enforced that belief. I truly believe that many purists, already knowing it was not an exact adaptation as we all now freely acknowledge, went expecting to not like what they saw, and with their mental tally sheets ready to check off all that was not Tolkien verbatim.

Go back and reread this thread in its entirety. Gauge for yourself the passion behind the dislike expressed by some of the critics. What may have started out in mischief quickly attracted those that saw it as gospel.
 
Last edited:
aragil said:
Does anybody have a quote about "what PJ told us"?
All the media were anticipating the films for a long time before they were released. They regularly carried reports of what Jackson had said and written about his intentions. These quite naturally varied in their content and in their emphasis, but I think it was generally accepted at the time that the message that came over most strongly was that he had the firm intention of presenting an accurate translation from the books to the screen. We did not get that accurate translation.
Four weeks before ROTK was released he proudly proclaimed on the extended edition of TTT that the Saruman confrontation would be the brilliant opening of ROTK. It wasn't. No further comment is required.
 
WHAT A BUNCH OF HORSE PUCKY!!!!

You npw's are trying to re-write history now! Rowan has nailed the npw to a "T".

You complain about the changes but expect us to believe you expected them? You claim you don't hate him, but you use words like "evil", "sick mind" and thye like to discribe him? If you don't hate him, I'd hate to see what your definition of hating someone is. :rolleyes:
 
Rowan Evensong said:
"If a person went expecting a verbatim retelling of the books on film, that was more than a little naive. I suspect the purists went knowing what they were going to get for the most part, but wanting to hate the movies because, after all, they weren't the book."

That was my opening quote on this subject. It was in the very next line that I said I did not believe "purists" went expecting a verbatim adaptation.
If I were to rephrase it now, I would replace the word "wanting" with "expecting."
Go back and reread this thread in its entirety. Gauge for yourself the passion behind the dislike expressed by some of the critics.
Do you mean that "I suspect the purists went knowing what they were going to get" was your confirmation that you "did not believe "purists" went expecting a verbatim adaptation", about which you had speculated when you said "If a person went expecting a verbatim retelling", or isn't that the "very next line" to which you refer?
Once again, as far as I know, no-one went expecting that verbatim re-telling, mainly for the reason that it would self-evidently be impossible to provide such a thing. For the same reason, we did not WANT that verbatim re-telling either - for the length alone, it just wouldn't be practical.
I do read the postings, including my own, and I don't normally see "passion", from either side. Frankly, the idea of being "passionate" about something as trivial as a film seems pretty ridiculous to me. Admittedly, and unfortunately, one or two recent contributions HAVE been more intense than we are used to, but I hope they can be regarded for the exceptions they are.
 
Joxy....I blame you for a lot of the confusion here. I for one refuse to read a back and forth banter from you when you are defending maggots posts. What are you, joined at the hip? Can't maggot speak for herself? How do you know what she meant and more importantly, what she understood? You ought to just fight your own battles and let maggot defend her own.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
You complain about the changes but expect us to believe you expected them?
You claim you don't hate him, but you use words like "evil", "sick mind" and thye like to discribe him? If you don't hate him, I'd hate to see what your definition of hating someone is.
What we expected, and indeed knew, was that the film would not be a verbatim rendering of the books.
We also guessed that there would be changes, and when we found that there were changes, we began to discuss them here; that's what this area of the forum is for. For the most part the word "discuss" is the appropriate one; in some cases, of the more drastic changes, then I'll allow "complaining" as the appropriate word. Since when did it become objectionable to "complain" about the occasional faults in any commercial product?
I don't use the word "evil". I don't say PJ has a "sick mind"; I do say that he occasionally shows us a "dark corner" of his mind, and most of us real human beings have one or two of those! Far from "hating" him, I'm indifferent to him as a person; as one who pays for the product of his craft, or art, if you will, I merely point out his occasional departures from being a perfect craftsman.
You're too free with the word "hate". In my philosophy, and in my religion, it's a word that is very rarely required, being reserved for much more important things and people than films and their directors.

Foe-Hammer said:
How do you know what she meant and more importantly, what she understood?
Rowan tells us how he understood Mrs M; I say how I understood her.
I wasn't "defending" Mrs M, and I wasn't attacking Rowan.
There are no battles here, there is no fighting.
If either or both of us misunderstood Mrs M, she is welcome to tell us so, or not to, according to her desire.
 
Last edited:
joxy said:
Rowan tells us how he understood Mrs M; I say how I understood her.
I wasn't "defending" Mrs M, and I wasn't attacking Rowan.

It is the original context that is lost and that creates the confusion. It's surely a worse reading experience than reading posts with a few mis-spelled words.
 
joxy said:
All the media were anticipating the films for a long time before they were released. They regularly carried reports of what Jackson had said and written about his intentions. These quite naturally varied in their content and in their emphasis, but I think it was generally accepted at the time that the message that came over most strongly was that he had the firm intention of presenting an accurate translation from the books to the screen. We did not get that accurate translation.
Four weeks before ROTK was released he proudly proclaimed on the extended edition of TTT that the Saruman confrontation would be the brilliant opening of ROTK. It wasn't. No further comment is required.

I don't recall him ever saying that it was going to be "accurate". I remember "true to the spirit". That's a big difference, and of course open to interpretation.
I also don't recall him saying that Saruman would appear in RotK (I may be wrong), but rather that Theoden riding to Isengard was going to be in the opening. Which it is.
 
Four weeks before ROTK was released he proudly proclaimed on the extended edition of TTT that the Saruman confrontation would be the brilliant opening of ROTK.

Will this (Possibly Erroneous) quote be used to promote the fact that Jackson makes promises and then breaks them?
 
Foe-Hammer said:
It is the original context that is lost and that creates the confusion.
Not so much "lost", as difficult to find, as the forums seem to be extremely slow to navigate these days.
That's why I quoted the relevant lines each time, so that the two points didn't go adrift. I agree though that it didn't make for comfortable reading.


aragil said:
I also don't recall him saying that Saruman would appear in RotK.
Morgaphry said:
Will this (Possibly Erroneous) quote be used to promote the fact that Jackson makes promises and then breaks them?
I quoted what I take to be the authoritative source: the EE of TTT on DVD. Other sources include Christopher Lee, whom I assume to be almost equally authoritative!
Not only was Saruman to "appear" in ROTK; the confrontation with him had been filmed, an extract from it was shown on the DVD, and it was going to be the spectacular opening of the film, which I thought was a brilliant idea - from PJ!
If the DVD can be taken as a "promise" then it certainly IS a fact that he broke this one. Whether anyone wants to use that as an example of his unreliability is up to them.
 
Last edited:
joxy said:
Not so much "lost", as difficult to find, as the forums seem to be extremely slow to navigate these days.
That's why I quoted the relevant lines each time, so that the two points didn't go adrift. I agree though that it didn't make for comfortable reading.

It was post #339 where you went spinning off into defending maggots words as if you were one in the same. As you can see by your mis-reading of the situation, the thread went off on a tangient that was totally uncalled for. I just think it's for the best to let others explain what they meant and/or understood.
 
aragil said:
I don't recall him ever saying that it was going to be "accurate". I remember "true to the spirit". That's a big difference, and of course open to interpretation.
Oh, come on, aragil. We all know that this 'spirit of Tolkien' 'it wasn't made to be like the book' is all nonsense. PJ's own painstaking detail as to what he did right negate that argument.

(extensive sarcastic tone as Thorin speaks as PJ and the rest of them)

"Heaven forbid that we should have the same characters speak the lines in the book because then there is no room for director's interpretation. It can't be EXACTLY like the book, remember our aim is only to capture the 'spirit of Tolkien' and cover the themes of good versus evil.....BUT lets just put Elven runes that no one can see on the elven blades and engraved horses on the chair of King Theoden that are non existent to the movie goers' eyes. Oh yes, and lets make some of the characters exactly like the book anyway, just for kicks. But no, we're only looking for the 'spirit of Tolkien'....Okay folks, lets read the chapter before we film this scene!" :rolleyes:

If you're not trying to make it authentic, you don't even use a source. The whole 'spirit of Tolkien' is a clap trap argument brought up to try and justify needless changes that happened simply due to ego and poor script writing.
 
Thorin,

You keep using the phrase "needless changes" as if you really know what you're talking about and are qualified to determine what does and does not work in the medium of film.

Had PJ done what you npw's wanted, this movie would have had the feel of "labyrinth", "legend", "willow", or goodness knows.....bakshi's version! Thanks heavens he had the skill to bring this to film and make a better story that will be enjoyed for years.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
It was post #339 where you went spinning off into defending maggots words as if you were one in the same.
I just think it's for the best to let others explain what they meant and/or understood.
I didn't mean that I found it difficult to trace the posts. I meant that, with so many posts in this thread, and with the slowness of the system, it could be difficult for others to find references, and for that reason I quoted the specific references that were the subject of my posting.
I've already said, I wasn't defending Mrs M; no-one was attacking Mrs M so there was nothing to defend against.
I was giving my comments on the postings from both Mrs M and from Rowan. That's what people do here: they give comments on other people's postings, as well as raising new points of their own.
Rowan explained how he understood Mrs M's two specific comments. I explained how I understood them.
It's entirely up to Mrs M whether she wants to expand on those comments.

Foe-Hammer said:
You keep using the phrase "needless changes" as if you really know what you're talking about and are qualified to determine what does and does not work in the medium of film.

Yes, I know that was addressed to Thorin, but I'm still commenting on it!!

This old argument would have more chance of making its mark if someone, anyone, could explain why some parts of the book are so difficult to adapt without changes, while others, which are well in the majority, are perfectly easy to adapt without changes.
Just one example: Do we really need to be "qualified" and to be experts in the "medium of film" to determine whether Gimli needed to be changed into a cheap comedy act, while Legolas could be represented with very little change?
 
joxy said:
I didn't mean that I found it difficult to trace the posts. I meant that, with so many posts in this thread, and with the slowness of the system, it could be difficult for others to find references, and for that reason I quoted the specific references that were the subject of my posting.
I've already said, I wasn't defending Mrs M; no-one was attacking Mrs M so there was nothing to defend against.
I was giving my comments on the postings from both Mrs M and from Rowan. That's what people do here: they give comments on other people's postings, as well as raising new points of their own.
Rowan explained how he understood Mrs M's two specific comments. I explained how I understood them.
It's entirely up to Mrs M whether she wants to expand on those comments.

I understand your rational, but it still caused needless confusion.

joxy said:
Yes, I know that was addressed to Thorin, but I'm still commenting on it!!

This old argument would have more chance of making its mark if someone, anyone, could explain why some parts of the book are so difficult to adapt without changes, while others, which are well in the majority, are perfectly easy to adapt without changes.
Just one example: Do we really need to be "qualified" and to be experts in the "medium of film" to determine whether Gimli needed to be changed into a cheap comedy act, while Legolas could be represented with very little change?

How, in your view, was gimli made into a cheap comedy act? Just because you ignore the overly prideful aspects of his character in favor of what you like about him, doesn't make it fit for film. It makes a better movie when elves, dwarves, hobbits, and men, are focused on in different ways. Who needs every character to act like an elf? Each character has traits that we identify in ourselves...pride, heroism, fear, anger, mistrust, etc.....if they all acted the same, it would be very boring.
 
An example of unreliability

joxy said:
I quoted what I take to be the authoritative source: the EE of TTT on DVD. Other sources include Christopher Lee, whom I assume to be almost equally authoritative!
Not only was Saruman to "appear" in ROTK; the confrontation with him had been filmed, an extract from it was shown on the DVD, and it was going to be the spectacular opening of the film, which I thought was a brilliant idea - from PJ!
If the DVD can be taken as a "promise" then it certainly IS a fact that he broke this one. Whether anyone wants to use that as an example of his unreliability is up to them.
Well, this is certainly a case of unreliability, but I don't blame PJ. What he said (as far as I remember) is that the trip to Isengard would be the opening of RotK. And you know what? It was in the opening, right after the transformation of Gollum. When you actually see the movie, you'll recognize the excerpt that was in the TT DVD.
Perhaps he did say that it was to be the confrontation with Saruman, but that is not my recollection. I will try to check tonight.
 
Thorin said:
Oh, come on, aragil. We all know that this 'spirit of Tolkien' 'it wasn't made to be like the book' is all nonsense. PJ's own painstaking detail as to what he did right negate that argument.
I don't think it is nonsense at all. PJ said one thing: ~"I will be true to the spirit of Tolkien, and I will be as accurate as possible to the world of Middle-earth."

He did not say he was going to be as accurate as possible to the books. In fact, he explicitly stated that this was going to be his version of the tale. You can blast his choices all you want, but don't say he lied, because he didn't. You (the general you) misinterpreted him.
 

Today's events

Back
Top