• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

rs691919 said:
My point was that the end of Theoden's "speech", he speaks Eomer's lines. And consider those lines and the context in which they are spoken in the movie. "Ride to ruin and the world's ending...death, death, death." Theoden isn't riding to death at that point in the story. He is riding to break the siege--the staves that he speaks in the book are more words of hope than of the madness and despair which are reflected in Eomer's exhortation.
Your "point" in your earlier post seemed to be nothing more than the often expressed complaint that the movie is not the book. To address your "point" now: in the book Theoden was rallying his troops for an apparently suicidal charge against vastly superior enemy forces and that certainly came across in the movie. In the book we have the messenger of Gondor earlier telling Theoden that by the time he arrives perhaps all he will be able to do is disturb the orcs and such from their feasting in Minas Tirith; to which Theoden agrees: "At the least we will do that." Also at this time in the book, the newly returned heir to the throne of Gondor has disappeared onto the Paths of the Dead, from which none have ever returned. The Rohirrim were fulfilling their oaths in coming to Gondor's aid, but they had little hope of success. Theirs was a suicidal "Charge of the Light Brigade".

rs691919 said:
No, the movie did not make up the Haradrim on their Mumakil, did not make up Eowyn's confrontations with the Witch-king; it did however, make up Aragorn's arrival with a fleet full of ghosts.
So much of the material in the movie is from the book, unlike your earlier claim that the only similarity was Rohan marshalling its forces and charging the orcs. As for Aragorn, he does indeed arrive in the book with a fleet of ships filled with new forces for the battle and the battle did indeed seem lost until his arrival. Admittedly, in the book Aragorn's forces were not the Dead he had recruited on the Paths of the Dead, but the forces he had gathered by using the Dead in a battle we have not seen at that point in the story. So the movie telescopes some action, it did not make it up. I suppose it would have been a better movie to add another 30 minutes or so for another battle between Aragorn and the Dead on one side and the Corsairs of Umbar on the other before the climatic battle before Minas Tirith? Even Tolkien didn't seem to think that would work in the book.

rs691919 said:
But in the movie, the attack of the Rohirrim doesn't break up the assault, which is my point. The attack of the Rohirrim doesn't accomplish much at all, for the Orcs still pour in the through the Gate up even to the second level. It takes the arrival of Aragorn and the ghosts to drive the Orcs from the City itself.
And in the book the attack of the Rohirrim has also seemingly failed until the arrival of Aragorn to save the day. Details are different between the book and the movie, but the main storyline and most events are the same.

I too could draw up long laundry lists of differences between the books and the movies. So what? The movies are "based" on LOTR, they are not a word for word translation into a different medium.
 
Greenwood said:
..in the book Theoden was rallying his troops for an apparently suicidal charge against vastly superior enemy forces and that certainly came across in the movie. In the book we have the messenger of Gondor earlier telling Theoden that by the time he arrives perhaps all he will be able to do is disturb the orcs and such from their feasting in Minas Tirith; to which Theoden agrees: "At the least we will do that." Also at this time in the book, the newly returned heir to the throne of Gondor has disappeared onto the Paths of the Dead, from which none have ever returned. The Rohirrim were fulfilling their oaths in coming to Gondor's aid, but they had little hope of success. Theirs was a suicidal "Charge of the Light Brigade".

While they did indeed have little hope of success, the key word here is "hope". The words that Theoden speaks, lifted from Eomer, are the words of despair, of madness, of wrath, of defeat. The moment (in the book) when the **** crows and the Horns of Hope answer as the Rohirrim charge the field of the Pelennor is not shrouded with despair (as are the words of Theoden in the movie) but rather uplifted with hope--hope that victory may still be achieved even when all seems lost.

Greenwood said:
So much of the material in the movie is from the book, unlike your earlier claim that the only similarity was Rohan marshalling its forces and charging the orcs.

Oh yes, much of the material is from the book, but I was originally giving thought to the charge of the Rohirrim (and how their part is diminshed in the movie). Of course, virtually everything in the movies superficially resonates with the book. It is that veneer, when stripped away, that leaves the movies emotionally flat.


Greenwood said:
As for Aragorn, he does indeed arrive in the book with a fleet of ships filled with new forces for the battle and the battle did indeed seem lost until his arrival. Admittedly, in the book Aragorn's forces were not the Dead he had recruited on the Paths of the Dead, but the forces he had gathered by using the Dead in a battle we have not seen at that point in the story. So the movie telescopes some action, it did not make it up. I suppose it would have been a better movie to add another 30 minutes or so for another battle between Aragorn and the Dead on one side and the Corsairs of Umbar on the other before the climatic battle before Minas Tirith? Even Tolkien didn't seem to think that would work in the book.

Greenwood said:
Yes, and then the movie has all that made up stuff about Haradrim on mumakils and Theoden being crushed by his horse when the Witch-King arrives to turn the tide of battle against Rohan, and a silly confrontation between Eowyn and the Witch-King in which she kills the Witch-king, and Aragorn arrives with a fleet full of ghosts to save the day, etc. But wait, it seems to me I read all that somewhere about forty years ago. Jackson must have copied it from somewhere. I will have to go to my library and see if I can find where.

Aragorn did not arrive at the field of Pelennor with a ship full of ghosts.



Greenwood said:
And in the book the attack of the Rohirrim has also seemingly failed until the arrival of Aragorn to save the day. Details are different between the book and the movie, but the main storyline and most events are the same.

The attack of the Rohirrim has not failed (in the book) of its foremost purpose: dislodging the Enemy from the Gate and preventing the invasion of the city. In the movie, it most certainly does fail: the Orcs pour through the gate and overwhelm the defenses. Now, the fury of the Rohirrim is spent as the Witch-King, distracted from his main purpose, turns to deal with the newcomers. And when he does deal with them, he meets his end--another sign of hope. The forces of Mordor, specifically the Haradrim to the southeast of the City rally their forces, as reinforcements begin to arrive on the field, and the Rohirrim see that they are outnumbered once again. It is at this point that Aragorn's arrival turns the tide.

But still, the Rohirrim succeeded in their intital charge, something the movie neglects woefully.
 
If I didn't read it with my own eyes, I wouldn't believe someone could seriously make such claims. In the movie the Ride of the Rohirrim is thrilling and filled with hope. They absolutely decimate the orcs- the orcs that are inside the city are cut off- no orcs 'continue pouring in'. All that is left is the Mumakil- about 20 or so, at least 4 of which we see taken out by the Rohirrim alone, though at great cost. The Witch King, apparent Haradrim chieftain and Gothmog (or 'pig head', if it pains you so much to use book names for creatures in the movie) all perish at the hands of the Rohirriim, leaving the forces of evil completely leaderless. If anything is diminished, it is the might of Gondor, as the charge of the Rohirrim in the movie accomplishes what the charge of the Rohirrim and the charge of the beseiged Gondorians accomplishes in the book. I can only speculate at what would motivate someone to say otherwise.

Regarding the arrival of the Rohirrim and their squaring off against the Orcs- this is a very slight telescoping of time. In the books Tolkien was able to provide both the moment of unexpected hope (the Rohirrim horns answering the Rooster), as well as the careful deliberation of Theoden's charge, because he wrote the later event first, then went back a chapter to describe how the Rohirrim got there and how they ordered the force before the charge. Obviously this wouldn't work in a movie, unless you hold that a flashback immediately preceding the charge would have been good cinema. The film showed us both the moment of unexpected hope, as well as how the Rohirrim overcame their own fear and charged, and the movie did this in the only way which didn't violate causality. Why this is even worth complaining about is beyond me.
 
rs691919 said:
The attack of the Rohirrim has not failed (in the book) of its foremost purpose: dislodging the Enemy from the Gate and preventing the invasion of the city.
Gee, I always thought the foremost purpose of the Rohirrim was to prevent the destruction of Gondor by preventing the destruction of Minsa Tirith. Dislodging the enemy from the gate, etc., merely seems to be one means to that end. It alone accomplishes nothing if there are still legions of enemies to renew the attack. The Rohirrim accomplish just as much in the movie as they do in the book, and in both their ultimate victory depends on the arrival of Aragorn in a fleet of ships with reinforcements.

rs691919 said:
Aragorn did not arrive at the field of Pelennor with a ship full of ghosts.
So what? If you are going to include the Paths of the Dead in the movie then you either have to add a whole other battle with them that leads to Aragorn gaining the reinforcements he needs to save the day at Minas Tirith, or you just have them as the reinforcements. A simplification to be sure, but one that is still true to the basic story of the book: there are these "ghosts" who are condemned to "ghosthood" because they broke their oaths to Aragorn's ancestor; they can only achieve peace by fulfilling their oaths and only the heir to the throne of Gondor can call on them to fulfill their oaths by fighting against the enemies of Gondor; this the heir of Gondor does and this they do leading to the salvation of Minas Tirith. The story is the same in both the book and the movie except for inconsequential simplification.

rs691919 said:
Oh yes, much of the material is from the book, but I was originally giving thought to the charge of the Rohirrim (and how their part is diminshed in the movie). Of course, virtually everything in the movies superficially resonates with the book. It is that veneer, when stripped away, that leaves the movies emotionally flat.
First it was that in the movie "The charge of the Rohirrim does not follow the books." When that charge is shown to be wrong we have an admission that the movie actually follows the book quite well, but somehow it is only a veneer.

You don't like the film. Fine, you are entitled to your opinion. You are certainly entitled to say it didn't engage your emotions. That is far different from making false claims that the movie does not tell the story from the book.
 
Greenwood said:
Gee, I always thought the foremost purpose of the Rohirrim was to prevent the destruction of Gondor by preventing the destruction of Minsa Tirith. Dislodging the enemy from the gate, etc., merely seems to be one means to that end. It alone accomplishes nothing if there are still legions of enemies to renew the attack.

The Rohirrim accomplish just as much in the movie as they do in the book, and in both their ultimate victory depends on the arrival of Aragorn in a fleet of ships with reinforcements.

From both a tactical and thematic standpoint, driving the Enemy from the Gate (as the Rohirrim do in the book and NOT in the movie) is extraordinarily important. Battles are not won only at the end; rather, the turns of a battle at each instance can effect the outcome greatly. Thus, the Rohirrim remove the imminent threat from the City, and give needed time to deal with the overall threat of the armies of Mordor. Of course, if one wants to discuss only the "ultimate victory", victory depends solely on the destruction of the Ring. So by your argument, nobody accomplishes anything at the Fields of the Pelennor (either in book or movie), and everything that happens at Minas Tirith is devoid of meaning because it doesn't directly involve the destruction of the Ring. That is an argument I do not think you would make.

From a thematic standpoint, the charge of the Rohirrim is absolutely crucial the narrative because it shows that ray of hope when the West is at the nadir of its fortunes. It demonstrates the power of Gandalf's "stewardship": for it is he that is moving these deeds. It is he that set into motion the Ride of the Rohirrim, he that organized the defense of Minas Tirith, he that confronts the Witch-King at the gate through which no enemy had yet passed. And the charge of the Rohirrim thus validates his actions and proves that there is still "someone" who is helping to order these events.

In the movie, the West is not at the nadir of its fortunes. For the Orcs, despite aragil's assertion that they are cut off from reinforcements, continue to ransack within the city--so much so that Gandalf and Pippin, facing the assault, pause to have a conversation about the nature of their imminent death. The nadir in the movie occurs just before Aragorn and company appear in the black ships. Thus, the thematic impetus of the Rohirrim's arrival is lost in the movie as well--it does not drive the Orcs from out of the City; that is only accomplished by the shades of Dunharrow. Similarity between book and movie, then, is only superficial.

Greenwood said:
The story is the same in both the book and the movie except for inconsequential simplification.

I'll say again: Aragorn does not arrive with the ghosts at the Field of the Pelennor, which is what your original post seemed to infer.

Greenwood said:
First it was that in the movie "The charge of the Rohirrim does not follow the books." When that charge is shown to be wrong we have an admission that the movie actually follows the book quite well, but somehow it is only a veneer.

Yes, it is indeed a veneer. The movie in this particular case (and in most cases as well) follows the book superficially. The arrival of the Rohirrim diverges from the text in several subtle ways, but thematically is altered much more deeply.

aragil said:
The Witch King, apparent Haradrim chieftain and Gothmog (or 'pig head', if it pains you so much to use book names for creatures in the movie) all perish at the hands of the Rohirriim, leaving the forces of evil completely leaderless. If anything is diminished, it is the might of Gondor, as the charge of the Rohirrim in the movie accomplishes what the charge of the Rohirrim and the charge of the beseiged Gondorians accomplishes in the book. I can only speculate at what would motivate someone to say otherwise.


Oh, I didn't realize that pig-head took the place of Gothmog, the lieutenant of Minas Morgul. He'll always be pig-head in my heart--a totally useless character who has some of the most pathetically banal lines in the movie.

Anyways, I think you're leaving out the arrival of Aragorn, which as Greenwood points out, leads to the "ultimate victory" on the field (in the movie). From what I recall on only one viewing, things looked pretty bleak for the Rohirrim and the City, despite the deaths of the Witch-King, the Harad chieftain, and the pig-head orc--and only Aragorn's arrival turns the tide.
 
rs961919 said:
From both a tactical and thematic standpoint, driving the Enemy from the Gate (as the Rohirrim do in the book and NOT in the movie) is extraordinarily important. Battles are not won only at the end; rather, the turns of a battle at each instance can effect the outcome greatly. Thus, the Rohirrim remove the imminent threat from the City, and give needed time to deal with the overall threat of the armies of Mordor. Of course, if one wants to discuss only the "ultimate victory", victory depends solely on the destruction of the Ring. So by your argument, nobody accomplishes anything at the Fields of the Pelennor (either in book or movie), and everything that happens at Minas Tirith is devoid of meaning because it doesn't directly involve the destruction of the Ring.
You are equating a battle with a war, something I did not do or imply. There are often many battles in a war. It is the rare war that consist of a single battle. And yes, there can be many turns of fortune during a battle, but the traditional way of deciding who won a battle (in most cases) was looking at who controlled the field when the fighting stopped. Theoden and the Rohirrim did not ride to Gondor merely to clear the gates of the city of Minas Tirith. The Battle of Pelennor Fields was not a multi-day or multi-part affair where first the Rohirrim clear the gates and then the next day more of Mordor's armies are brought up and a new battle is engaged, and so on. It was one massive battle in both the book and the movie.

rs691919 said:
I'll say again: Aragorn does not arrive with the ghosts at the Field of the Pelennor, which is what your original post seemed to infer.
Brilliant rhetorical device, ignoring that I have twice corrected and expanded that original post.

rs691919 said:
Yes, it is indeed a veneer. The movie in this particular case (and in most cases as well) follows the book superficially. The arrival of the Rohirrim diverges from the text in several subtle ways, but thematically is altered much more deeply.
I think everyone agrees that it is impossible to follow the book exactly in translating it to the screen. What you really mean by the above is that if you had been doing the translating you would have made some different choices in the adaptation and what parts of the story were emphasized. I would have also. To many of us with a considerable knowledge of the books we find that the main storyline and themes of the books are indeed there even when details have been changed.
 
Greenwood said:
And yes, there can be many turns of fortune during a battle, but the traditional way of deciding who won a battle (in most cases) was looking at who controlled the field when the fighting stopped.

Exactly, whether battle or war, the outcome can hinge on many turns of fortune. And yes, one can (particularly in this instance) determine the "winner" of the battle by looking at who controlled the field at the end of the day. But how you get from point A to B does of course matter.


Greenwood said:
Theoden and the Rohirrim did not ride to Gondor merely to clear the gates of the city of Minas Tirith.

No indeed. They came in the broader sense of aiding Gondor in its darkest hour. But we got from point A (the West at the nadir of its fortune) to point B (clearing the Pelennor of the armies of Mordor) for several reasons: first and foremost being the ability of the Rohirrim to drive the Enemy from the Gate, just as they were about to enter it in force. If they hadn't charged at just that moment, what then might have happened? But it is a testament to the deeds of Gandalf (and the One who sent him back), that the Rohirrim turn up at just the right time. It is a major thematic point, and one that is diminshed in stature because of the writers' choice to set up a Braveheart-type battle with two armies staring each other down followed by a heroic charge--not much original cinema there incidentally.


Greenwood said:
I think everyone agrees that it is impossible to follow the book exactly in translating it to the screen. What you really mean by the above is that if you had been doing the translating you would have made some different choices in the adaptation and what parts of the story were emphasized. I would have also. To many of us with a considerable knowledge of the books we find that the main storyline and themes of the books are indeed there even when details have been changed.

Oh certainly, had I my druthers, much in this movie would have been taken back closer to the book--not just superficially, but thematically. The bones of the story remain the same of course. It is the intrusion of unwarranted matter, owing to not perceiving where the core of the original lies (as Tolkien might say), that fails the movie in general and the screeplay in particular. It is particularly galling to me because all it would have taken was a little vision, some trust in the material, and some trust in the audience to make this movie (and these movies) something that transcends the Hollywood norm.
 
rs691919 said:
It is particularly galling to me because all it would have taken was a little vision, some trust in the material, and some trust in the audience to make this movie (and these movies) something that transcends the Hollywood norm.
They do transcend the Hollywood norm. That is why so many professional critics referred to them as making cinematic history. That is why ROTK is the first fantasy film to win the Best Picture Academy Award. That is why ROTK did an unprecedented sweep of eleven Academy Awards. That is why they are the most successful movie trilogy in history. That is why they have made a record nearly $3 billion in worldwide box-office (not to mention video and DVD rentals and sales). You don't have to like these films. That is your right. But to say they don't "transcend the Hollywood norm" in the face of their critical and public success is absurd.
 
Greenwood said:
....to say they don't "transcend the Hollywood norm" in the face of their critical and public success is absurd.
Whether they "transcend the norm" and whether they have "critical and public success" are two distinct and separate factors.
I see nothing absurd in the claim.
 
Greenwood said:
They do transcend the Hollywood norm. That is why so many professional critics referred to them as making cinematic history. That is why ROTK is the first fantasy film to win the Best Picture Academy Award. That is why ROTK did an unprecedented sweep of eleven Academy Awards. That is why they are the most successful movie trilogy in history. That is why they have made a record nearly $3 billion in worldwide box-office (not to mention video and DVD rentals and sales). You don't have to like these films. That is your right. But to say they don't "transcend the Hollywood norm" in the face of their critical and public success is absurd.

Goodness, this reliance on critical acclaim and financial success to demonstrate the validity of these movies has become quite pervasisve (and disheartening). The pornography industry makes a whole lot of money too--are we going to start praising it as transcending the norm, simply because of financial prowess?

I can certainly see that the movies made cinematic history: the sheer audacity of shooting a $300 million dollar project at once, releasing them three years running in order to maintain momentum, and filling them with (for the most part) state of the art special effects is indeed an accomplishment. For that, Jackson deserves some credit (as does Bob Shaye of New Line). WETA, perhaps, deserves more credit for bringing Middle-earth to (film) reality. The land of New Zealand deserves some credit as well for being just a damned beautiful place. So, in those respects, perhaps the movies do transcend the norm.

But in terms of storytelling, which is (or should be) at the heart of any narrative art, there is a dreadful "sameness" that pervades these movies--the sensation that cinematic formula is more important than originality. Understand, I don't think that these movies are any worse than the other epic fare that we have been inundated with in the last several decades. They are really the same--Hollywood banalities inserted into a new setting. And what a setting it is!!! Middle-earth is the real hero of these movies. Strip away the majestic scenery, the intricate armor, the detailed costuming, and you basically have Braveheart, or Gladiator, or Star Wars or whatever you choose.

This is not historic storytelling. I watched the first half of Two Towers last night, and a particular scene sticks out in my mind. It is the scene where the Orc chases Merry and Pippin into Fangorn. The Hobbits climb up a tree, the music decrescendo's (is that a verb??), M&P give a sigh of relief, there is a slight pause, and then BANG! The Orc grabs Merry's leg as the music swirls up loudly around the viewer.

How many times have we seen scenes like this in movies? The pause for "dramatic" effect. How many times do we see it in these LotR movies? Again and again. The cave troll scene in Moria employs it; even the climax of the entire story utilizes it (the ultimate cliffhanger) with Frodo hanging on for dear life. And what's more, this director couldn't even be unoriginal with original material--he has to appropriate someone else's!

When you watch some of the extra discs on the EE's, pay attention to one of the sections where various scholars (Tom Shippey, Patrick Curry, even Rayner Unwin) go on and on and on about how Tolkien's writing eschews the form of the traditional novel; how far from the normal it departs. Ironic then that the filmmakers were unable to do the same with their movies. Here was a chance to do something different--to tell a beautiful story that remains true to the source. They could still have their epic battles, their monsters, their stunning visuals, but all they had to do was have some faith in the material and have some faith in the audience. Instead they resort to the tired old creatively bankrupt formulas and the worn-out, intellectually dishonest excuse that the media are so diametrically opposed so as to preclude honest translation from the one to the other.

Pioneers in moviemaking? Possibly. Pioneers in storytelling? No.
 
rs691919 said:
Goodness, this reliance on critical acclaim and financial success to demonstrate the validity of these movies has become quite pervasisve (and disheartening).
Validity? I said nothing about validity, whatever that means. I merely pointed out that your implication that these films did not "transcend the Hollywood norm", could not be supported. It was in fact easily refutable by these movies' records. Your revision of your claim to "Pioneers in moviemaking? Possibly. Pioneers in storytelling? No." acknowledges that you could not support your original statement. Once again, as I have said repeatedly in the past, dislike these films all you want. That is your right. The films are not perfect as films and certainly not as adaptations of the book. Jackson made choices I would not have made and choices I disagree with. Just don't make sweeping generalizations that cannot be backed up; that in fact can easily be shown to be wrong.

joxy said:
Whether they "transcend the norm" and whether they have "critical and public success" are two distinct and separate factors.
They are not "two distinct and separate factors". By many measures these films the record of these films has been unprecedented. Certainly a textbook case of "transcending the norm". Even rs691919 clearly recognizes the lack of validity of his statement since he has so completely revised it.

I would point out that even the Ben Affleck/Jennifer Lopez turkey Gigli "transcended the norm" in the depth of its box office failure and the virtually universal panning it received from the critics. :D
 
Greenwood said:
Validity? I said nothing about validity, whatever that means. I merely pointed out that your implication that these films did not "transcend the Hollywood norm", could not be supported. It was in fact easily refutable by these movies' records.

In making my original statement ("It is particularly galling to me because all it would have taken was a little vision, some trust in the material, and some trust in the audience to make this movie (and these movies) something that transcends the Hollywood norm."), I thought it would be clear that I was referring not to the "form", but rather the heart of the movie--which is the story and the themes contained therein. Sad indeed when transcension of the norm is primarily thought to reside in financial success, but certainly by transcending the norm, I did not mean box office dollars and DVD sales.


Greenwood said:
Your revision of your claim to "Pioneers in moviemaking? Possibly. Pioneers in storytelling? No." acknowledges that you could not support your original statement.

You may call it revision if it pleases you. But it was in fact clarification, since I in no way would ever apply the phrase "transcending the norm" to either financial or critical success. Validity, which you question above, refers to the enduring strength of the art, or worth of the art (if you like).


Greenwood said:
Just don't make sweeping generalizations that cannot be backed up; that in fact can easily be shown to be wrong.

I did not, in fact, make a sweeping generalization; rather, I stated an opinion: "It is particularly galling to me because all it would have taken was a little vision, some trust in the material, and some trust in the audience to make this movie (and these movies) something that transcends the Hollywood norm."

Again, the less pedantic mind will note that perhaps your definition of what it means to transcend the Hollywood norm is different from mine, something which I attempted to clarify in the following post (though you of course will insist that this is "revision").
 
Greenwood said:
By many measures these films the record of these films has been unprecedented. Certainly a textbook case of "transcending the norm". Even rs691919 clearly recognizes the lack of validity of his statement since he has so completely revised it.
It depends on which norm you're talking about!
rs has made it quite clear which norm he was talking about, and which I certainly understood him to be talking about.
 
rs691919 said:
Sad indeed when transcension of the norm is primarily thought to reside in financial success, but certainly by transcending the norm, I did not mean box office dollars and DVD sales.
Whether you like it or not Hollywood is first and foremost a commercial venture. "Artisitic merit" comes second. By the "norms" of what Hollywood considers most important, what its very existence is based on, these films transcended the norms.

rs691919 said:
Validity, which you question above, refers to the enduring strength of the art, or worth of the art (if you like).
Thank you for explaining what you mean by "validity" in this case. It was unclear to me in your original use of the word. There is no way for you or anyone else (includiing me) to know what the "enduring" strength of any artistic endeavor is. Only time will reveal that. It is hubris to claim to know the answer now. The only evidence we have for the current view of the "strength" or "worth" of any artisitic endeavor is the reception a work receives by the professional critics of the medium and public acceptance (admittedly these are not always in agreement and can sometimes be diametrically opposite). Once again by any measure of critical appraisal and audience acceptance, these films transcend the norm.

rs691919 said:
Again, the less pedantic mind will note that perhaps your definition of what it means to transcend the Hollywood norm is different from mine, something which I attempted to clarify in the following post (though you of course will insist that this is "revision").
IMO, an objective mind will recognize that your "clarification" does not coincide with what a reasonable person would consider the Hollywood norm.
 
Greenwood said:
Whether you like it or not Hollywood is first and foremost a commercial venture. "Artisitic merit" comes second. By the "norms" of what Hollywood considers most important, what its very existence is based on, these films transcended the norms.

Artistic merit...that's another good substitute for "validity". Suffice it to say that your definition of what constitutes "transcending the Hollywood norm" diverges from mine. My definition (and the one by which my posts should be read) implies that transcension involves rising above the standard--not in a mathetmatical or accounting process, but rather a conceptual manner. I am indeed talking about artistic merit, and these movies do not transcend the Hollywood norm in those terms.

Greenwood said:
There is no way for you or anyone else (includiing me) to know what the "enduring" strength of any artistic endeavor is. Only time will reveal that. It is hubris to claim to know the answer now.

Hubris against whom?


Greenwood said:
The only evidence we have for the current view of the "strength" or "worth" of any artisitic endeavor is the reception a work receives by the professional critics of the medium and public acceptance (admittedly these are not always in agreement and can sometimes be diametrically opposite).

Should the individual then subordinate his own opinion to a "professional" or to "the public"? Does the professional's opinion carry more weight than the individual's? More pointedly, since I have been paid to examine and teach Tolkien critically, does that make my interpretations of his writing more valid than yours?


Greenwood said:
IMO, an objective mind will recognize that your "clarification" does not coincide with what a reasonable person would consider the Hollywood norm.

Tell me why. I had a rather lengthy post which detailed why I think these movies--in terms of storytelling--are unoriginal. Why would that be foreign to the objective mind?
 
rs691919 said:
Should the individual then subordinate his own opinion to a "professional" or to "the public"?
Not at all! I have repeatedly said everyone is entitled to their opinions.

rs691919 said:
Does the professional's opinion carry more weight than the individual's?
I thing most people will tend to give more consideration to a professional's opinion than a nonprofessional's (in the professional's field of expertise) because the professional usually has a greater knowledge of the field and factors peculiar to it. This does not mean a professional's opinion automatically trumps a nonprofessional's. When something as subjective as "art" is considered, a professional's view will generally carry much less wait than in other fields, except perhaps for the technical aspects of the craft under consideration. (I know you like yes or no answers to your questions, but such answers are often simplistic. Questions are often framed in terms of such a dichotomy to obscure the complexity of the issue under discussion.)

rs691919 said:
More pointedly, since I have been paid to examine and teach Tolkien critically, does that make my interpretations of his writing more valid than yours?
No, because we are discussing an extremely subjective subject, the "artistic" merit of these films. Secondarily, I might point out that on your "public profile" on the TTF your occupation is listed as physician. I assume this is your profession. That you are being paid to give a lecture tells me nothing about your qualifications as a professional critic. Your statement "I have been paid to examine and teach Tolkien critically" certainly does not give any indication of an expertise in film criticism. Your apparent lack of comprehension of the commercial basis of Hollywood would tend to indicate a very limited expertise in that area.

rs691919 said:
Hubris against whom?
I don't understand your question. I have never thought of hubris as being something that is against someone else. From the dictionary: hubris -- excessive pride or self-confidence; arrogance. To claim that one knows what is going to be "enduring" (your word) in terms of art strikes me as the height of hubris/arrogance/showing excessive prode in one's own opinion. You take your pick.

rs691919 said:
Suffice it to say that your definition of what constitutes "transcending the Hollywood norm" diverges from mine. My definition (and the one by which my posts should be read) implies that transcension involves rising above the standard--not in a mathetmatical or accounting process, but rather a conceptual manner. I am indeed talking about artistic merit, and these movies do not transcend the Hollywood norm in those terms.
I find your statements here confusing. Once again, according to the dictionary: norm -- 1. a standard, model, or pattern. 2. a rule or standard of behavior expected to be followed by each member of a social group. 3. a behavior pattern or trait considered to be typical of a particular social group. 4. the general level or average. And: transcend -- 1. to rise above or go beyond the ordinary limits of; overpass; exceed. 2. to outdo or exceed in excellence, extent, degree, etc.; surpass; excel. Your latest statement "rising above the standard" seems to fit quite well with the dictionary definitions I have given. The key question here is what is the "norm" you are referring to. You chose to categorize it as the "Hollywood" norm. It is fair then to ask what is the "Hollywood" norm. I have pointed out that Hollywood is a commercial operation and these films have undoubtedly surpassed the "norm" for the commercial success of a Hollywood film by any measure one might choose. You protest that you are talking about "artisitic merit" and the "enduring strength of the art". But how do we know what the "Hollywood norm" (your choice of words!) for "artisitic merit" is? You seem to think that we should accept your judgement what this norm is (hubris again). I think it is fair to look at Hollywood's judgement as reflected in the critical reviews and awards presented. Once again, these films are unprecedented -- that certainly seems to transcend the norm. As for "enduring strength", I point out again only time will tell whether these films have it. Your apparent belief that you know what the judgement of the future will be is IMO the height of hubris.

rs691919 said:
Tell me why.
I just did. :D
 
Last edited:
Greenwood said:
I think it is fair to look at Hollywood's judgement as reflected in the critical reviews and awards presented. Once again, these films are unprecedented -- that certainly seems to transcend the norm.
Look at them, certainly, but nothing more than that. Do you mean the films are "unprecedented" in the appraisal they have received in terms of reviews and awards? I'm not at all sure that is true, but whether it is or not, it's not relevant. If it IS true, then the films transcend THAT norm; but that's not the norm that I, and I think rs, are talking about.
 
joxy said:
Look at them, certainly, but nothing more than that. Do you mean the films are "unprecedented" in the appraisal they have received in terms of reviews and awards? I'm not at all sure that is true, but whether it is or not, it's not relevant. If it IS true, then the films transcend THAT norm; but that's not the norm that I, and I think rs, are talking about.

Then explain what "norm" you are talking about. So far the only thing I can see in your posts that might be considered a "norm" is a personal dislike of the films. You are entitled to that opinion (BTW have you seen ROTK yet? [retracted by Greenwood]) However, judging by objective criteria it does not seem to be the norm for the rest of the people seeing the film (both the professionals and the general public).
 
Last edited:
Greenwood said:
The only evidence we have for the current view of the "strength" or "worth" of any artisitic endeavor is the reception a work receives by the professional critics of the medium and public acceptance

Rewinding for a moment, you seem to imply that--while an individual may have opinions--those opinions are valid only if they are reflected in professional criticism or public acceptance. Or am I reading you too literally.

Greenwood said:
I thing most people will tend to give more consideration to a professional's opinion than a nonprofessional's (in the professional's field of expertise) because the professional usually has a great knowledge of the field and factors peculiar to it. This does not mean a professional's opinion automatically trumps a nonprofessional's. When something as subjective as "art" is considered, a professional's view will generally carry much less wait than a nonprofessional's, except perhaps for the technical aspects of the craft under consideration.

Isn't film criticism ultimately all about subjectivity? Or do film critics just set out to report how much money a movie makes and base their criticism on the bottom line?

Greenwood said:
Questions are often framed in terms of such a dichotomy to obscure the complexity of the issue under discussion.

Layers of complexity are often added to a discussion to mask the refusal to commit to an answer.


Greenwood said:
No, because we are discussing an extremely subjective subject, the "artistic" merit of these films.

I actually intended this question to be broader; that is, leave aside for a moment the discussion about the movies (and leave aside the question of being paid, which was poor wording on my part). Does my opinion on Tolkien therefore carry more weight than yours, because I have lectured on him off and on for the last four years?

And then again, you seem to suggest that the critical acclaim Jackson's films have received is "evidence" that the movies have "artistic merit". Is this so?

Greenwood said:
Your apparent lack of comprehension of the commercial basis of Hollywood would tend to indicate a very limited expertise in that area.

Oh come now, do you really think that I don't understand the financial implications within the industry that is Hollywood? Don't be so silly.

Greenwood said:
I don't understand your question. I have never thought of hubris as being something that is against someone else.

This is irrelevant to the discussion, but hubris had more specific meaning to the Greek. Hubris was something that someone committed, generally involving crossing the gods or setting oneself up to a position that was not allowed. Hubris was more than pride or arrogance; it was an act, usually one that crossed a "moral" line.


Greenwood said:
I find your statements here confusing. Once again according to the dictionary: norm -- 1. a standard, model, or pattern. 2. a rule or standard of behavior expected to be followed by each member of a social group. 3. a behavior pattern or trait considered to be typical of a particular social group. 4. the general level or average. And: transcend -- 1. to rise above or go beyond the ordinary limits of; overpass; exceed. 2. to outdo or exceed in excellence, extent, degree, etc.; surpass; excel. Your latest statement "rising above the standard" seems to fit quite well with the dictionary definitions I have given.

To quote Winston Churchill: "This is just the type of errant pedantry, up with which I shall not put."



Greenwood said:
The key question here is what is the "norm" you are referring to.

I'll say again: the norm to which I refer is that of, broadly speaking, artistic merit. It may also refer to the lack of originality that pervades Hollywood.


Greenwood said:
You chose to categorize it as the "Hollywood" norm. It is fair then to ask what is the "Hollywood" norm. I have pointed out that Hollywood is a commercial operation and these films have undoubtedly surpassed the "norm" for the commercial success of a Hollywood film by any measure one might choose.

I must admit that I've never head the word "transcends" used in conjuction with such actuarial matters as commercial revenue, but I guess there's a first time for everything. Regardless, I didn't intend to categorize anything; I think you're reading a bit too literally, which is easy to do on an internet forum.

Greenwood said:
You protest that you are talking about "artisitic merit" and the "enduring strength of the art". But how do we know what the "Hollywood norm" (your choice of words!) for "artisitic merit" is? You seem to think that we should accept your judgement what this norm is (hubris again).

No, you don't have to accept it; I am merely presenting what my view of the Hollwood norm--this relentless emphasis on the banal and the sentimental, this formulaic creative bankruptcy--is.


Greenwood said:
Once again, these films are unprecedented -- that certainly seems to transcend the norm.

I would say that there are long years of precedent for these movies. The storytelling is wholly unoriginal; the directing is derivative; the acting is sentimental. These movies repeat that which has come before; they just do it in a different (and wondrous) setting.


Greenwood said:
As for "enduring strength", I point out again only time will tell whether these films have it. Your apparent belief that you know what the judgement of the future will be is IMO the height of hubris.

Oh, I don't know (for certain). But I have a hunch. Actually, the movies won't endure because their artistic worth is no greater than that of the Hollywood norm.
 
rs691919 said:
Rewinding for a moment, you seem to imply that--while an individual may have opinions--those opinions are valid only if they are reflected in professional criticism or public acceptance.
No, as I said everyone is entitled to their opinion. You, however, have repeatedly brought up, reasonably I might add, the term "enduring" in relation to artistic merit. Artistic merit is a highly subjective matter and views of it change over time, but I agree one measure of it is whether something endures, stands "the test of time" as the old saying goes. For a new work there is no such measure of endurance to fall back on. The closest we can come is the reaction of the professional critics and the general public. We can still disagree with that assessment and time may prove us right and the professionals and the public wrong. I wouldn't even begin to suggest odds either way. It is however extremely arrogant to take the attitude that you know what that judgement of history will be, especially when your opinion is currently the minority one.

rs691919 said:
Isn't film criticism ultimately all about subjectivity? Or do film critics just set out to report how much money a movie makes and base their criticism on the bottom line?
All criticism is largely subjective. I would not say that criticism in any field is all about subjectivity. In regard to film criticism I have seen and read many a review that praised the technical aspects of a film but criticized the acting, or vice versa. In fact I would say it is the norm for professional film critics to comment on plot, acting, directing, writing, etc. Your second question is clearly specious (for the most part) since the vast majority of film criticism takes place when the movie is released before any one knows what the bottom line will be.

rs691919 said:
Layers of complexity are often added to a discussion to mask the refusal to commit to an answer.
Few things in life are black or white, yes or no. If a person likes simple answers, he/she should concern themselves only with simple subjects.

rs691919 said:
Does my opinion on Tolkien therefore carry more weight than yours, because I have lectured on him off and on for the last four years?
Weight with who? You obviously place great weight on it. In any event, the question is irrelevant here because you have been setting yourself up here as a film critic, not a Tokien critic.

rs691919 said:
And then again, you seem to suggest that the critical acclaim Jackson's films have received is "evidence" that the movies have "artistic merit".
It is evidence that todays professional film critics consider the films have "artisitic merit". As I have said repeatedly, only time will tell if that view is "enduring".

rs691919 said:
Oh come now, do you really think that I don't understand the financial implications within the industry that is Hollywood? Don't be so silly.
You don't seem to.

rs691919 said:
Hubris was something that someone committed, generally involving crossing the gods or setting oneself up to a position that was not allowed. Hubris was more than pride or arrogance; it was an act, usually one that crossed a "moral" line.
They committed the sin of arrogance, of being overly prideful. For that the gods punished them. They did not commit it against anyone which is what your question said.

rs691919 said:
To quote Winston Churchill: "This is just the type of errant pedantry, up with which I shall not put."
It is not pedantry to point out the misuse of the English language via the twisting of meanings of words. Winston Churchill, who was a great orator and writer and lover of the English language, IMHO would be on my side.

rs691919 said:
I'll say again: the norm to which I refer is that of, broadly speaking, artistic merit. It may also refer to the lack of originality that pervades Hollywood.
The norm you specified was the "Hollywood" norm. You have now shifted it to some vague "artisitc merit" norm which you further qualified as "enduring". None of us have any idea what is going to prove "enduring" in art. I repeat, to claim to know is an act of hubris.

rs691919 said:
No, you don't have to accept it; I am merely presenting what my view of the Hollwood norm--this relentless emphasis on the banal and the sentimental, this formulaic creative bankruptcy--is.
Finally, an explanation of "Hollywood norm". I appreciate that you acknowledge the "Hollywood norm" you are referring to is your opinion, not an objective fact. I will now give my opinion that I think these films do transcend the "Hollywood norm" you just stated.

rs691919 said:
I would say that there are long years of precedent for these movies. The storytelling is wholly unoriginal; the directing is derivative; the acting is sentimental. These movies repeat that which has come before; they just do it in a different (and wondrous) setting.
Glad to have your opinions. I disagree with most of them, but that is of course my opinion.

rs691919 said:
Oh, I don't know (for certain). But I have a hunch. Actually, the movies won't endure because their artistic worth is no greater than that of the Hollywood norm.
You started out well there expressing your opinion, but I am afraid you slipped into hubris again with that last sentence, expressing it as a definite declarative.
 

Today's events

Back
Top