Your "point" in your earlier post seemed to be nothing more than the often expressed complaint that the movie is not the book. To address your "point" now: in the book Theoden was rallying his troops for an apparently suicidal charge against vastly superior enemy forces and that certainly came across in the movie. In the book we have the messenger of Gondor earlier telling Theoden that by the time he arrives perhaps all he will be able to do is disturb the orcs and such from their feasting in Minas Tirith; to which Theoden agrees: "At the least we will do that." Also at this time in the book, the newly returned heir to the throne of Gondor has disappeared onto the Paths of the Dead, from which none have ever returned. The Rohirrim were fulfilling their oaths in coming to Gondor's aid, but they had little hope of success. Theirs was a suicidal "Charge of the Light Brigade".rs691919 said:My point was that the end of Theoden's "speech", he speaks Eomer's lines. And consider those lines and the context in which they are spoken in the movie. "Ride to ruin and the world's ending...death, death, death." Theoden isn't riding to death at that point in the story. He is riding to break the siege--the staves that he speaks in the book are more words of hope than of the madness and despair which are reflected in Eomer's exhortation.
So much of the material in the movie is from the book, unlike your earlier claim that the only similarity was Rohan marshalling its forces and charging the orcs. As for Aragorn, he does indeed arrive in the book with a fleet of ships filled with new forces for the battle and the battle did indeed seem lost until his arrival. Admittedly, in the book Aragorn's forces were not the Dead he had recruited on the Paths of the Dead, but the forces he had gathered by using the Dead in a battle we have not seen at that point in the story. So the movie telescopes some action, it did not make it up. I suppose it would have been a better movie to add another 30 minutes or so for another battle between Aragorn and the Dead on one side and the Corsairs of Umbar on the other before the climatic battle before Minas Tirith? Even Tolkien didn't seem to think that would work in the book.rs691919 said:No, the movie did not make up the Haradrim on their Mumakil, did not make up Eowyn's confrontations with the Witch-king; it did however, make up Aragorn's arrival with a fleet full of ghosts.
And in the book the attack of the Rohirrim has also seemingly failed until the arrival of Aragorn to save the day. Details are different between the book and the movie, but the main storyline and most events are the same.rs691919 said:But in the movie, the attack of the Rohirrim doesn't break up the assault, which is my point. The attack of the Rohirrim doesn't accomplish much at all, for the Orcs still pour in the through the Gate up even to the second level. It takes the arrival of Aragorn and the ghosts to drive the Orcs from the City itself.
I too could draw up long laundry lists of differences between the books and the movies. So what? The movies are "based" on LOTR, they are not a word for word translation into a different medium.
