Aulë said:
One thing that puzzles me about LotR, is that
Tolkien says that the
Nazgul weren't allowed to cross the
Anduin, yet they must have done so to transport Grishy & co. across.
The exact words were "He won't let them
show themselves across the
Great River yet, not too soon. They're for the War-and other purposes."
Presumably if the Nazgul did the ferrying under cover of darkness (and only just to the westward shore of the Anduin), then it would not be "showing" itself to any in
Rohan or
Gondor, and thus spoiling the surprise factor for the war (and other purposes). However, crossing Rohan to attack
Ugluk and co. would have been running afoul of
Sauron's intent (even though, as pgt points out, the potential payoff was quite large). Sauron could have done smarter things, like guard the entrance to Orodruin or allow the Nazgul to pursue Ugluk, but he didn't. We have to live with the fact that the bad guy did stupid stuff which was exploited by the good guys. "Oft
evil will shall evil mar."
jallan said:
aragil said:
The guard that gives the speech is assumed to be a Northerner by
Pippin. Pippin of course is no great judge of
Orcs, ...
I don’t see any assumptions made about the guard at that point.
I guess this once again falls into the category of 'reasonable assumptions' based on the narrative. Pippin rolls over and sees
In the twilight he saw a large black
Orc, probably
Uglúk, standing facing
Grishnákh, a short crook-legged creature, very broad and with long arms that hung almost to the ground. Round them were many smaller
goblins. Pippin supposed that these were the ones from the North.
Since the guard was one of the first three killed, he was probably one of the 'smaller goblins' in close proximity to Ugluk and
Grishnakh, which Pippin assumes to be "ones from the North".
I suppose alternative readings would be that Pippin didn't see the yellow-fanged guard when he made his supposition, or that Pippin was wrong in his supposition. Neither of these readings seems likely correct to me because Pippin's supposition is later backed up by
Aragorn's pronouncement (see below), and in order for the guard to be slain he would have been relatively near to Ugluk, hence within Pippin's view at the time.
jallan said:
aragil said:
... but that particular Orc is killed and later observed by Aragorn, who also
places him as a Northerner.
Aragorn doesn’t quite make that identification. ...Those words are not inconsistant with, for example, there being corpses of three Northern Orcs and two
Mordor-orcs. Aragorn points out that these, that is the Orcs he is pointing at, are Northern Orcs. He also points out that among the slain are none of the
great Orcs with the strange badges. Why say “Among the slain ...” if all the bodies are those of northern Orcs? More natural would be to say something like: “These are all Northern Orcs from far away, none of them the great Orcs with the strange badges.”
In order for you to say that Aragorn does not make that distinction, you first have to assume that he is only referring to a select subset of the orcs. There is no indication that he does so. He is never described as pointing at a two or three of the Orcs, therefore the most likely explanation (i.e.
the one involving the least explanation outside what occurs in the text) is that he was referring to all five orcs. The fact is that here he names only Orcs from the North and Orcs from
Isengard. He never mentions Orcs from
Mordor as being present, and neither does he do so when looking at the Orcs from Parth Galen. Pippin does not recognize any of the Orcs in the party as being Mordor Orcs until Grishnakh reappears, and then the description of the Mordor orcs is that they are something new, not something that was at Parth Galen, then missing for two days, then suddenly reappearing at the Entwash. It may sometimes be difficult to argue something by silence from the author, but in cases where the omissions are as consistent as they are here, I think that the answer is quite obvious.
jallan said:
The absolute statement that the dead orcs are not orcs of Mordor is changed to wording that indicates only that many of them are not folk of Mordor.
I hate to argue linguistics with a linguist, but here I think you are wrong. I would parse the sentence as follows:
subject: many ... that are not folk of Mordor
verb: lie
object: here
I would parse the subject into a pronoun (many) and an adjectival element (that are not folk of Mordor). "Many" would then indicate "a large number" rather than "a relative large part of the whole". This reading is further backed up by Aragorn and
Legolas's exchange with
Gimli:
'I have not seen these tokens before,' said Aragorn. 'What do they mean?'
'S is for Sauron,' said Gimli. 'That is easy to read.'
'Nay!' said Legolas. 'Sauron does not use the Elf-runes.'
'Neither does he use his right name, nor permit it to be spelt or spoken,' said Aragorn. 'And he does not use white. The Orcs in the service of
Barad-dûr use the sign of the Red Eye.'
If Mordor Orcs were present, why would Gimli make such an obvious error? Why wouldn't Legolas and Gimli simply point to a Red Eye? Simplest answer: because none were present.
jallan said:
Grishnákh does not have the Northern Orcs to command. At least some of them want to head back north. Do any really want to go with Grishnákh? If full battle broke out between Uglúk and Grishnákh at that time the Northern Orcs would most likely side with the more numerous party (Uglúk’s troops) or make a break for it.
This is not at all born out by the text. The Northerners do oppose Ugluk, and do so at the urging of Grishnakh, hence they are at least under his influence, if not officially under his command. The Northern Orcs ARE the more numerous party, and the fighting breaks out because they are opposing Ugluk. Why would they be less likely to oppose Ugluk with Mordor Orcs present? Who do you think the Northerners were fighting for? They certainly were not fighting against the invisible Mordor rabble.
Moria Orcs are nominally
creatures of Sauron- we know this from Appendix B. Grishnakh portrays Ugluk and
Saruman as rebels ("'Is Saruman
the master or the Great Eye?" ... "Who does he think he is, setting up on his own with his filthy white badges?"), and finally beseeches the Northerners to attack using an us (creatures of Sauron) against them (creatures of Saruman) argument: "
Swine is it? How do you folk like being called
swine by the muck-rakers of a dirty little wizard? It's orc-flesh they eat, I'll warrant." These are the last words spoken before the attacks occur. Later on, Pippin (or more properly, the narrator) portrays the conflict as having occurred between Northerners and Isengarders ("The Orcs were getting ready to march again, but some of the Northerners were still unwilling, and the Isengarders slew two more before the rest were cowed.").
And again, Grishnakh portrays himself as being alone: he never once uses first-person plural (as Ugluk does, repeatedly). He refers to himself as the trusted messenger (again singular) of
Lugburz, and he says that he (alone) was able to cross the Anduin. When he suggests that they go to Lugburz it is implied that he (again alone) will leave with the rest of the Orcs behind. When Grishnakh does slip off, it is described as a singular event ("Grishnákh stepped aside and vanished into
the shadows.) There is no indication of a general exodus of Mordor Orcs, and up until Grishnakh rejoins the group the rest of the Orcs are described as being exclusively Northerners and Isengarders. The simplest way to explain this is that Grishnakh is alone, otherwise non-Northerners would have
1) been described as opposing Ugluk, and
2a) been described as leaving with Grishnakh, or
2b) have been present when the entire party of Orcs is described in the following passage
There was some cursing and scuffling, and then most of the Northerners broke away and dashed off, over a hundred of them, running wildly along the river towards the
mountains. The
hobbits were left with the Isengarders: a grim dark band, four score at least of large, swart, slant-eyed Orcs with great
bows and short broad-bladed
swords. A few of the larger and bolder Northerners remained with them.
Notice- no Mordor Orcs described as being present. If no Mordor Orcs opposed Ugluk, no Mordor Orcs left with Grishnakh, and no Mordor Orcs were still with the group, then in my reading is that no Mordor Orcs ever existed. The author does not need to be any more explicit than this. I am not trying to argue in absolutes, I am trying to argue in "most-likelies". Invisible Mordor Orcs which are never described do not fall into the latter category. Barring an obvious statement by Tolkien, you will always be able give a counter (no matter how ridiculous) to every example, just as you have earlier said you can not diprove that "Eldar=star folk" means that the
Elves are actually aliens. However, most people would agree that this is
unlikely.
In any case, arguing absolutes is tiring. How about this: we can each state our case and then let the forum vote on which scenario seems more likely. The winner can then gloat like Shagrat over the body of Gorbag. The loser will be reduced to hanging his head in shame. Or would trusting the opinions of our fellow members be considered
Argumentum ad populum?